Service humans and the planet with care.

Book: Service Design Principles 401-500

The fifth book in the Service Design Principles Series with 100 tiny ideas, provocations and tips to better serve humans and the planet that hosts them.

You'll get weekly emails showing how the book writing progresses

Bonus

The gift you get when you join the waitlist

When you join the waitlist you'll get by email a PDF with the very first drafts of the first 8 Service Design principles from this new book.

A little toilet book to help you make your service for people better work for the planet too.

This little two-hour read gives 100 tiny and simple principles, ideas, or pieces of advice to help you better serve the people around you and the planet that hosts them. These people can be your users, your customers, your employees, or even just your family and friends.

My hypothesis for the fives books in the Service Design Principles series is that you don’t need to understand the full extent of Service Design and its theories to improve the lives of the people around you. Simple rules and practical examples are good enough to bring meaningful change for humans and the planet.

I’ve promised myself I would at least write five books in this series. For this last one in my promise, I wanted to do something new for these books: start with a topic of exploration. As a dad and just human being I feel it’s important that I get better at not just taking care of humans but also the planet that hosts us. So for this book I’ve tried to look at the world of sustainability for services. 

This book is a bit of a summary of my early findings on this topic. Still, it was important for me to stay true to the original intention of this series: not offer philosophical ideas, but things that my dentist, a pastor a service worker can actually implement. Small things that make a good enough difference.

So to be clear, this book isn’t a book about System Thinking, Regenerative Design, Eco-Social Design, Policy. It’s just a humble list of ideas, tips and stories to help those who build services to be a bit more mindful of the planet and not just the humans that sit on it.

As the elements in this book are simple, down-to-earth elements, don’t read it like a book. 

Instead, read it like one of those magazines you have in your bathroom. Open it from time to time to get inspiration, a laugh, or just to help you through a boring moment. Feel free to cherry-pick and read randomly.

That’s why I call it a “toilet book”. It’s a book that is perfect to read on the toilets in small sessions.

I'm excited that somewhere in 2026 you'll be reading this tiny book on the toilet or elswhere.

Greetings from Switzerland,

Daniele

Sharing my research

Interview journal

I'm speaking with sustainability enthusiasts worldwide to inform the writing of this new book. I'm sharing these conversations with you here.

Crisis and War

How can we design services in times of deep crisis?

Oleg Koss and Liza Pidopryhora — Ukraine

A photo of Oleg Koss and Liza Pidopryhora

Early principles uncovered

This conversation with Oleg and Liza inspired me 11 early Service Design Principles to better serve others in times of crisis.

  • Trust and use your skills even in crisis: Knowing how to serve people comes handy in all life situations, from a birthday party, to mental health and even war times.

  • Safety doesn’t mean closing shop: Safety is not a black or white thing, it’s a negotiation. If your service can’t be totally safe, closing it fully might mean that you make people even less safe. Find ways to stay open in times of crisis to continue to give access to essential services.

  • Remember we get used to crisis mode: war, pandemics and crisis times that live for long times feel like a new normal that we get used too.

  • Think about what happens when people get trapped in your service: Do you have some basic necessities for people to survive in your service if they are blocked in it because of natural disasters or war events?

  • Inclusion is even more important in crisis: In war and crisis times, people with disabilities are the ones that suffer even more, how can you service serve them first?

  • If you don’t have an impact, change context: Service skills can make a real difference, find a context where those skills are a necessity and not just a nice add-on. Change company, change industry or even country to serve others that deeply need you.

  • Create and train your emergency kit: Have an emergency kit in your service or organization, train staff members and remind them on how to use it.

  • Make your service escapable: Don’t design your service just for being easy to enter to but also easy for fleeing from in case of emergency.

  • Serve to give hope in crisis: When emergencies and crisis happen, keep parts of your service open to give a sense of normality. Offer moments where people can also get served and don’t have to only survive and defend themselves.

  • Protect the basics: in times of crisis, basic services like water, electricity, communication, etc. keep communities alive and healthy. Protecting these services ensures life continues with a sense of normalcy.

  • Remember: Things are Better Done Than Perfect: Even more in times of crisis, getting things done matters more than doing them perfectly right.

About the humans

Oleg Koss and Yelyzaveta (Liza) Pidopryhora are two Service Design enthusiasts who both work at Lanka.CX, a customer experience and Service Design agency in Ukraine.

Oleg founded the agency, and Liza works as a Service Designer & Lead for NGO, Public, and Military Projects

The full conversation

Interview chapters

  • 0:00: Teaser

  • 4:27: Challenges and Misconceptions

  • 5:48: Service Design in Crisis

  • 6:37: Adapting to War Conditions

  • 11:33: Learning and Resilience

  • 17:34: Practical Examples and Innovations

  • 24:24: Safety and Service Design

  • 26:50: Negotiating Safety in Business

  • 28:16: Balancing Remote and In-Person Interactions

  • 28:40: Inclusion and Safety for People with Disabilities

  • 29:40: Medical Preparedness in Public Services

  • 33:18: The Role of Service Design in Military Support

  • 38:21: Human-Centered Design in Government Services

  • 42:44: Closing Thoughts and Call to Action

Transcript of the interview

This transcript was automatically generated using Descript without any hand-made corrections. So it might be pretty creative at moments.

Daniele: How can we design services in times of deep crisis? That's what we chatted about with Oleg Koss and Liza Pidopryhora in an interview for my next book on how to create services that serve both humans and planet. Oleg and Liza are two Service Design enthusiasts who work both at Lanka, a customer experience and Service Design agency in Ukraine. Oleg founded the company and Liza works in it as a consultant and service designer.

Yes. These two lovely humans work on Service Design topics in Ukraine, A country going through a deep crisis because of war.

It has been really inspiring for me to see how life and work in Service Design has continued with an impressive resilience.

I truly think that what they are learning and experiencing every day can help us in other types of crisis too.

This conversation with Oleg and Liza inspired me. 11 Early Service Design principles to better serve others in times of crisis. Here are my five favorite ones.

Number one, serve to give hope in crisis: when emergencies and crisis happen, offer moments where people can also get served and don't have to only survive or defend themselves.

Number two, safety doesn't mean closing shop. Safety is not a black or white thing. It's a negotiation. If your service can't. If your service can't be totally safe, closing it fully might mean that you make people even less safe.

Number three, think about what happens when people get trapped in your service.

Do you have some basic necessities or an emergency kit for people to survive in your service if they are blocked in it because of natural disasters or war events?

Number four, inclusion is even more important in crisis. In war and crisis times, people with disabilities are the ones that suffer even more. How can your service serve them first?

Number five, if you don't have an impact, change context. Service skills, service skills can make a real difference. Find a context where those skills are a necessity and not just a nice add-on. Change company, change industry, or even country to serve others that deeply need you.

Thanks so much to Oleg and Liza for this lovely and humbling conversation.

Hello, Oleg. Hello, Liza. It's such a pleasure to see you here today.

Oleg Koss: Daniele.

Liza: Hi.

Explaining Service Design

Daniele: Before we get started with all the service designing nerdiness I'd like maybe just to start by asking you a very dumb question, which is how would you present yourself in a birthday party?

Oleg Koss: I would say, hi, I am, I'm od I'm a service designer, which usually may means nothing to people. Yeah. So I would probably go with saying we help businesses and organizations to be customer centric and probably mention couple of projects like we did recently. Improving the services of the food retail, or improving the recruiting process of the Ukrainian Military Corps or helping NGOs to fundraise more money, et cetera.

So giving some examples of the recent projects, which is a good conversation starter.

Daniele: Ah, wonderful. Thanks so much. And I see that you brought a lovely French to this imaginary birthday party. You with you. And so Liza, how would you present yourself to this imaginary birthday party?

Liza: First of all, I'm happy that I haven't been on birthday parties where all I was als always also because he would take my words that I will usually say too. No, but making it more simple for people, I would say. Hi, I am Liza. I'm a friend of someone whose birthday is ole, and I work as a service designer in the first Service Design agency in Ukraine.

And what it means I make services work better, and mostly I work with government services or military services or services around non. Nonprofit organizations. So that's what I do. And yeah, I think I would say like this,

Challenges and Misconceptions

Daniele: I love how we all struggle with the same stuff, which is. Come back to birthday parties and you're like, oh, fuck. Again, the question about my profession.

Liza: Yes.

Daniele: And then you're like yeah I'm doing stuff with design. And then people, oh, you do chairs? Oh, no, again. So I like that In all cultures we have the same issues.

Liza: Yeah, usually it would be confused about ux, UI designer. They would ask me like, so you design like apps? And I'm like, nah, not really, but so like that.

Daniele: Then the service designer are skills in us where we are very good at interviewing. Others are very handy because then we make the others speak.

Liza: Okay. But have you had a situation when you then become the middle of a tension because everyone is like, what is Service Design? And you start talking and everyone is like gathering around you and you're like, wow, I have never heard about this thing. And yeah, just whole party is about you and the birth the one who has a birthday is like left.

Oleg Koss: What happens almost every time. Liza joins some new people very short period of time, everybody's gathered about Liza and she's passionately explaining everybody what Service Design is and how beautiful it is.

Daniele: So we'll need one across course with you around how to bring all the people around us to create some some attention around Service Design. That's lovely.

Service Design in Crisis

Daniele: But I'm very interested in your take around Service Design because from what I've understood, obviously you are working in a Ukraine, which is. A country which is in a wartime, which is in a crisis time. And to me, it's quite interesting to have conversations about how we use Service Design in many different settings. For example, I find quite interesting how people sometimes use Service Design in everyday life, for, organizing a birthday party and maybe also managing mental health. But I find this is another example, which is quite unexpected of how. Service Design is also used during crisis time. Could you maybe share a few examples of how Service Design has helped you, maybe personally, but also as a business in this difficult times.

Adapting to War Conditions

Oleg Koss: I probably start just again, to give, to put into the context right now, there is an air alert in Kiev, the, guns are actually shooting at the targets as we record this meeting. So that's the reality. Just put you into the context and again, it's going for and a half years already. at the same time, Design I mean, that's strange to say is blossoming. Mo most service designers get ready and become service professional service designers. in 2022 when the full started, we wouldn't expect this to happen. I remember our first process. A project for the actually Czech operator who was preparing a special charity Ukrainian refugees coming to check here, and they asked us to. Help them to design this product, make it more convenient, not affordable because it was free, but more convenient for the refugee to be used. And we did that. And actually that time, speaking about the mental health, doing this project in 2022 was actually helping us to prepare, to get some sense of normality. That's that's what happened. And, Yeah. And since 2022, we do quite a many projects in the area of charity support and jobs. And basically since Liza joined the team, we started that, that's why she's part of this conversation. Yeah, and I maybe a few things, few more things and since. The part of 2022 we just realized that this is not a short war or race conflict, but something Ukrainian business will show the resilience.

We still need to run the economy to, to sustain the economy and sustain the people ukrainian businesses kept their customer-centric transformation. They kept innovating new products, they kept improving services, and actually was, again, surprising to me, and it's actually very promising to the service designers around the world. I know very few companies who actually fired service designers. So they, despite that companies had on scale had to, reorganize despite the fact that their strategies were like, we have a six week strategy. That, that was the reality of the business in 2022. And still they kept their Service Design teams and those Service Design teams should proved to be very reliable partner for the business. that's like maybe two takes I would give at the start, Liza. Oh, your first experience with design thinking was also in 2022.

Liza: Yeah I haven't worked in Service Design before the full scaled war in Ukraine. So for me, I started already when the. In this new circumstances of the full scaled war. So for me, I don't know. I have nothing to compare with. Yeah, maybe because of that my experience is quite different in this way.

However, I I think since we started working precisely in Ukraine on the topics. Observe, like when I started studying Service Design in in Madrid, in IE school, I knew already that I'm gonna. Work not around the business questions, but around charity organizations, nonprofit organizations. I haven't thought yet in that time that I would be able to use Service Design for the military projects.

Just that idea didn't come up in my mind. I didn't know that it is possible, but now as. As we already did some projects, I realized that it's not even just possible, but it's actually really useful and also read about some experiences in USA in Estonia about using Service Design in the war.

And that is like just coming as a more and more inspiration of how to use this tool. To make things that we think cannot be more human-centered, but actually more human-centered to make it, to serve better for people, basically. Yeah.

Daniele: Thanks so much. It's quite impressive to see both your takes about, about that situation. I'm quite impressed by the this notion of, in tough times. Resilience is really the key skill. And that key skill is also something that we see in professionals in many fields, including service designers professionals who have learned on how you manage cows.

You manage problems that arise at moments that you can't imagine that they could come. And I'd be quite curious to know from your take.

Learning and Resilience

Daniele: What's something that you learned in these past? Years that you say, wow, this this is really a different way of thinking. That what I was maybe taught for you Liza back in Madrid and maybe for you, Oleg before, when business was as usual and now what are maybe things that you learned that you say, oh, these are other ways of working, these are other ways of living That, that I have now integrated and that once. war ends. I will still use for everyday life and everyday business as usual.

Liza: Of course when you study how to do Service Design, when you listen to podcasts, listen to courses, there's some rules and like some principles of Service Design you have to apply and kind of expectation on how the project should go. And this is something I also got from my.

Education first and then from working in Atlan C six. But then when I started working with the military units, I realized that I have to be much more E even though Service Design is at first are quite flexible as our nature, we work with uncertainty. We have to be flexible, but there you have to be even more flexible and have to adapt to this fast tempo of war.

That like everything is for yesterday and this husband been already done a week ago. And you have to understand how to prioritize your task in a way that the. This project still makes sense for the people you are doing it for because, everything changes in work very fastly. And also other things about takes on co-creation processes because I wish I could live in the per perfect world where we could do a facilitation workshop.

With all the need stakeholders in one physical room in enough time we have and everything, but it's impossible when you work with questions around war and you invite people who work with very urgent task all every day. So it's impossible to get, gather them all together in one room.

Sometimes it's even impossible to gather them all around. In one call. So you have to be more creative on the co-creation styles that you make and be more adaptable to your client because you want them be involved, even like nevertheless. Because the Service Design is about this involving everyone around inside the project.

So I think this experience in general made me more. More strong, more resilient, and more flexible. Yeah, that, that will definitely help me to handle more harder projects on a higher scale later off.

Oleg Koss: I would probably start with the on the helicopter view design process works point. Regardless, all the extreme situation, all the. And all the challenges the method, tactics, how you use it differs, of course, like I maybe give some, like first in, in the normal life you are looking for the bright, shiny room.

So you, that you got everybody together and everybody's inspired with delight and with the view from the windows. And then the workshop brings you more creativity. Now we are looking for the underground premises so that we are not interrupting the workshop during the the alarm. So we don't we don't stop our work.

And the concept of, and inspiring pace change it, it still matters. The same goes for people you still are trying to get to, involved to them, but again stealing from these examples. If you need to interview the and you design the project for the other soldiers, you cannot expect they will do the. Not even face to face interview, but sometimes you cannot expect them to do the interview that is long enough. So you would basically do half of the interview in the messenger. Just asking the questions, getting it again, or when asking something. People not sharing information with you, not because it's personal, but because it's sensitive in terms of the security, say security, et cetera. And in terms of resilience? Resilience, yeah. It's just. This is strange. In theory, you would feel less empowered. I'm speaking about businesses, I'm speaking about military. During the war, like is uncertain. You don't have resources. everything is unpredictable. But actually in, when you are put in more extreme situations, you actually feel more things are possible because, you don't have a safety net. So you actually start thinking better than in the conflict situation. And I just want one thing Liza said, because know everybody in every organization thinks, every service designer thinks that you are not given. to design. You'd prefer to do a little bit more research, more prototyping, have some time to generate insights, and everybody is' unhappy with the pace. But trust me, the pace of the military organizations, not working eight hours, five days a week, not even 10 hours. They are literally 24 7 at work, and when you try to engage them in the design process, you consider their workload is nothing to be compar of civilian life. I.

Daniele: It's really impressive to see how, y in these situations which are crisis situations. It's not all despair. Live continues. I imagine that in your own profession as service designers, you have maybe uncovered Service Design principles of your own and how to. Work, live survive. Are there some that you would be willing to share with us around those ideas?

Practical Examples and Innovations

Oleg Koss: I'm not sure if this is Service Design principal, but this is definitely a learning. you get used to everything.

There were conditions you have, you get used to it, and then you, interesting you, so you get used to it and then you, if you are design minded person you immediately start looking for the ways to improve it. So I don't know. Blackouts, you don't have electricity for hours. That's awful. Then you learn how to do it and then you are for the ways, how to organize it better Ukrainian electricity in days, not even weeks. They designed a very. I still get electricity for a few hours. It's not like right now.

If it might happen in, in few weeks again because Russia need to be targeting u Ukrainian electricity grid again. But like you get at least the tool that makes the electricity presence and absence predictable. And then it some neighbors some people in the multi-story buildings start design the package for those who get stuck in the elevator and all of a sudden in every elevator and give you have a chair and a bottle of water which is essential.

And then also an empty bottle. Go into motels here and things like that. So again you first adopt and the sooner you adopt the better and. Work trains you to adapt the better, and then you immediately start finding the design solutions, how to make this awful situation a little bit better every day.

You also, and then you start appreciating basic services much more.

One of the love marks in Ukraine now is Ukrainian rail estate rail services railway.

Daniele: Yeah.

Oleg Koss: We not always the best in the peace times they are. literally the national love mark now because they are working in the, in the good schedule, despite all the difficulties and because the the closed and Ukraine is the biggest church, biggest country by the territory in Europe.

So we need travel and railways works. The same goes for the electricity providers. We do electricity much more. And the same goes for I know PE station, et cetera. So every business that point became essential. They supported they, they are now much more valued.

Daniele: Yeah, it's back to the basics in those moments where we appreciate really the fact that we can click on a button and we get some light we get some water and we can move around. Yeah, absolutely. Wonderful. Liza, I thought I saw that you have few

Liza: Yeah. Yeah. I was like writing them down because, I don't know if you have this thing, but when I listen to conversation, have so many points and thoughts and I have to write them down not to forget. So EG was mentioning blackouts and I realized that like I just have a practical example of this happening because I dunno if someone from.

Spain or Portugal is hearing us right now, but they remember how that happened in Europe, the Black house that happened there. I was not there. I was in Ukraine, but my friends who were from Ukraine who lived through Black House in Ukraine and they were in Spain and Portugal during the Black House, they were like, that's not a problem at all.

Like they were so already adapted to it because they adapted that to that in Ukraine. So it's just like a take on what Alleg just said, that when we are used more to worse. Work conditions, then it's so easy for us to adapt to anything. So just, yeah, stay close to ba to basics, don't over do it.

But my also, it's hard for me to say a Service Design principle because I didn't read your Service Design principles, all of them that you had said. So I might repeat something you already have said. So I'm sorry for that. It's not on purpose. But when I was doing with the team and the the project with military unit was military corps haria this year Alek told me several times this thing about Liza, it's better done than perfect.

And I was like, yeah, it's important that we do this and that in this way. Like this is how we make sure that we have a good insights and stuff. But actually, I think. Sometimes we actually have to remind ourselves that it's better done than perfect and sometimes even do some Service Design projects, even though we know that it would be better on a bigger scale, but still do it because it's better to at least touch a bit the client's needs and what is already have done and Prototype at least a bit, but nothing.

So I think that's important to remember. Yeah, and I think.

Oleg Koss: one more. This is, this might sound a little bit controversial, but again, Liza did a great project with the. team in the military academy and we were teaching them Service Design principle. They are already designers that, that's very important to understand that the majority, it's perceived like there are civilians and there are military personnel and it's military's personal to sacrifice their lives. But that's not like that because actually Ukrainian army consists. Civilians who had no choice but to start serving the country. So there is, they are military personnel, but they are also civilians. And for example, we worked with the team who was, who were designers before the war, and they joined as a team, the military and they innovative military innovation team within the military academy. And what's interesting is the design still need to be focused on the provider. In case of the military service provider is actually a soldier. So when you design some tool or you design some process, you still need to make sure that the service delivery is convenient for the service provider.

And that was like, okay that's how you, because usually you would imagine the vendor or the seller in the shop here it's actually the sold still want to make it usable, useful, efficient, et cetera.

Liza: Exactly just.

Oleg Koss: user, but also on the service provider, again, became quite noticeable.

Liza: Yeah, just be just say, continue. Then innovate. Just if we just have a new innovation, but it is not easy to be used. By people who are using it. So what's the point of it? So that's really important also because in in war, the efficiency is very important and making things more human centered is about making it more safe and more actually yeah, more useful, effective.

Safety and Service Design

Daniele: I'd be curious to hear from your side, do you see some things around safety where you say, oh, these are interesting practices interesting service elements that have been put into place?

Liza: This year we were able to organize together Atlanta six 11 Service gems at the same time.

So I think you're familiar with the Service Jams initiative and we love it a lot because it's a great tool to get. More people introduced to Service Design. But in Ukraine, for the first time ever, we had 11 in different cities in all around Ukraine at the same time, service jam jamming and bringing that to people.

And I rem this is when we were starting the whole thing, the most the first thing we said, like that all the spaces that you're gonna do, the gyms have to be in the shelters. Like we don't negotiate it. We don't say oh, we can be out in shelter, for some time, but if there is a danger, we go there.

No, we are in the shelters and like even the like parts of Ukraine, that seems to be more safe because they're more far from the Russia border, but still, this is like a first priority. So talking about us, our services as a. Service Design Agent Lanka, this is something we change in our perspective of giving out the service.

We always think the, this basic safety of the place first and then other tools. Yeah, so that's like kind of first thing.

Oleg Koss: I would say again, that what's important? It's and now going slightly contradict, again, GM is it's an event for days. You can consider the, like you, you can say that safety is not, is non negotiable. But if you are like in the business. You are working every day you then don't have this option to put all the stuff in the shelter, et cetera. So it's interesting how kind of consensus about the level of safety that is developed. Like for example. It's, again, it sounds scary, but that's what it our shop is closed. When there is a danger. You mean when there is an air raid alarm? No. When there is an air raid alarm, we are open. But if there are multiple rockets shut at our city, then we close. that's. That's less safety, but that's what I mean.

Negotiating Safety in Business

Oleg Koss: Safety is not absolute. You negotiate it. And what's important, you communicate it. Because like many international businesses, I can give an example of McDonald's. They close with the first sound of their alarm. keep working because there, there are two levels of safety. Okay? You want to provide pe make people safe within your promise, but at the same time you want to people. Have access to their services. Like what if you are in hospital? What's safe not to be able to practice with the doctor or be closed when there is a risk of of shelling? That's so you it's become more complicated and yeah, again, you need to see what's the perspective of the service provider. You need to see the perspective of the service user and then find the balance.

Liza: Yeah. Yeah just building on that, just just two things

Oleg Koss: Yeah.

Liza: wanted to say something more? No, you say

Oleg Koss: wanted to be one more illustration that just blew my mind. It's very recent in iv, which is very close to Russian border. It, is

Liza: you,

Oleg Koss: one you wanted to give?

Liza: yes. Great. Mind think or it's something else, but Yeah. You say it. I have another one.

Oleg Koss: They're building three story on the ground school in Hake. So you just build three story building, but you just dig it under the ground. And yeah, safety is still important and yeah. And what's what, I think that actually illustrates one more thing.

Balancing Remote and In-Person Interactions

Oleg Koss: There was this plenty of discussion between remote and face-to-face.

And in theory, remote should dominate Ukraine now because, it's. Seems to be safer, but no personal interactions matter after some time, most of projects in our agency, I actually have quite a significant part of offline workshops where we meet in person. It matters and it builds empathy.

Inclusion and Safety for People with Disabilities

Liza: Yeah, just last thing I would say, like about how services in Ukraine are developing in terms of. Understanding this really important concept of safety is also about kind of safety and inclusion of people with different disabilities. Because while Ukraine is actually, has a increasing number of people who has different disabilities because of the attacks and it is, are these are civilians or those are people from ex-military.

So it's. Kind of everyone. And it's interesting how we have to now think about public services in terms of public transportation, public health services, how we have to and it's already is happening, we changed not only the infrastructure of the place to make it more usable because not only for people just to use it, but for people also to be able to escape it in case of danger.

So it's you have to think about this in the always and also.

Medical Preparedness in Public Services

Liza: We put an extra attention on the prevention health prevention methods, like for example, that you have to, for example when I walk around the city, I always have a tourniquet with me. It's a, it's something that can help to stop a massive blood.

Explosion, right? I dunno how to say it right in English words, but if something happens, so I can do this and save someone's life, hopefully. So this, what I've seen now more and more is that in some places where. Where services are provided these basic medical things like, everyone is oh, you have to have a medical kit in your place.

Now it's not, you just have to have it. Your staff have to know how to do this basic pre, pre-med things to stop, like the blood, the explosion or something if something happens. Near your service like provider place. Like when you're a business, even if you are just a grocery store, like a beauty cell, and it doesn't matter.

Your staff has to know how to make, we can't call it service, but it's a thing to your client if something happens around you. So it's it's all about how business owners and like people who are organized services are conscious. About what is happening and how seriously they take it.

Yeah.

Daniele: Thank you so much. I'm very impressed by this level of practical of how practical these things are, and I'm a sucker for these ideas, which are not just philosophical things, but which are, really implemented and that make a difference. And and it's quite beautiful to hear. How safety has taken a different meaning. And still for me, when I hear you guys, I'm like, shit, there is so much to learn from that. There is so much that could be applied in all also other situations. So that's quite interesting.

So for example this shift from. means, we could say, oh in a in a time of crisis, a flawed, a war or something, we should close service. is that really safety, or is keeping the essential stuff open, and finding ways to find a negotiation around the safety so that we can continue to serve and that can, and life can continue is a very beautiful. More complex way of saying, see safety as black or white. It's all in the middle. And so that's a beautiful reminder also here to say that in crisis, it's not just about closing shop and escaping, but also how do you. Stay open. How, when what's the negotiation that you make also for the safety of your employees, but also for the

Liza: Yeah.

Daniele: who come and it's not that easy, but it's a negotiation that I find deeply interesting in in, in how you guys practice that.

Obviously there are many other tiny things that I'm stealing from this conversation, but I'd be quite curious to know from your perspective. When you first emailed me Oleg you told, you said, oh, I have a few ideas and stories that I could share. Is there something that you had in mind that you wanted to share that you couldn't share yet and that you'd like to share?

Now

Oleg Koss: It's interesting, you asked so many questions. We discussed so many things.

Liza: I'm sorry. I just, I needed to move outta my room because I hope my internet will still will be fine, because there was a huge explosion. Yeah. Honestly I think I have I don't know. It is connected to the topic we have been talking about, but this is a project I'm personally,

Daniele: I.

Liza: I think I'm the most proud of.

That's something I have done and that's will be. Forever may be my favorite one. And it is about working with military topics stuff.

The Role of Service Design in Military Support

Liza: Example, last year we worked with the biggest charity foundation of Ukraine. That helps military. It is called Come Back Alive. The most effective organization that has been working since the war started in 2014.

And they came to us with a really interesting challenge that some people would say that they didn't need a Service Design, they just needed researchers. But I'm really happy that they actually approached to us and that we start, they were open to try this new, instrument, even though they didn't know what is Service Design.

So basically what they want us to what they wanted to understand is that why people are starting, donate less, donate money for the military, support for the yeah, for military support because they have seen like a decrease in the donation levels. And that's by the way, it would be. It's topic that about talking about lots of charity organizations.

So yes, why a charity organization always want to know why they decreased. But we propose to investigate better why people actually donate. What makes this behavior actually more why people choose to donate? How do they do it when they do it? Will they donate to how they understand what sums of money they're gonna donate and stuff like that.

So we decided to do this whole Service Design project around this. And we involved the whole c, like C level, let's call it C level, like top level through the, to the work. And they were reading, like with us, working together doing with as the Service Design and what we had in the end. It was a combined expertise of us as a service.

And this is what we have sent from the interviews, but also the expertise from the people who have been working in this organization for ma many years. And when we came up at the end to the some archetypes of people donators to the, their behavioral scenarios we realize like that it actually is works and it actually recalls what these people have been noticing through these years. And this then influences the whole change of the marketing strategy for this organization. 'cause they realize finally who they are talking to usually and who they are trying to change behavior of. So

For me it was a good example on how.

Talking about quite hard topic, which donating to money to the Army? It just, this is, this might sound as like really nice topic to talk about, but it's not about donating money to Greenpeace, like it's just like a good person, it's about donating to support the military units in Ukraine.

So like talking about this type of thing still, even though it was emotionally hard sometimes, it still brought us to the insights that gave us a meaning. Motivation, behavioral change. Yes. But I'm sure Alexa has something to talk, tell about this.

Oleg Koss: Yeah. Then honestly, I thought we would, first of all just wanted to share some examples to give you some ideas. in the end of the day, I think the main messages. I think we, we managed to bring them through that first level continuous. And Ukraine is still under attack, unfortunately. And basic services for the civilians, they actually not only. they provide sense of normality. This is one more example, I wanted to share that. For the people who live very close to the front line presence of the logistic operator post service or the presence of the pet station, it brings huge sense of just the presence of the commercial services available to people.

The that's I don't know. I saw hundreds of posts from Ukrainian soldiers who were the petrol station of the specific brand orco because they were serving them with the coffee and hot dogs. Not even the petrol in the, literally in the few kilometers from the frontline and how they are, that finally the company had to close this petrol station because the frontline got to close. So again, this providing services is actually valuable. Sometimes we under appreciate what we do, providing the basic services you need to get to the extreme conditions to start appreciating it. that. Again, you get used to it and you keep developing the services and make sense. And there is room for Service Design and there is plenty of room for the Service Design for the extreme services like the Army. And it the method works. You need to change the tactics, but strategically it works in, it brings the value for the user, it brings the value for the service provider.

Liza: Exactly.

Oleg Koss: Yeah, actually essential profession for the humanities.

Liza: Yes. And we are sure about it.

Human-Centered Design in Government Services

Liza: And just like one more thing also about that, I didn't expect that human-centered design would be so popular also among like people who work with government services in the. Also territories that are close to the front line or like just in the small communities, inside villages or towns.

But we have been doing projects with, together with unicef, Ukraine, bringing human-centered design instruments to those people on hand. And they were try, they were eager to try human-centered design. They were, they actually did like more than 20, we did more than 22 projects. Like them using human centered design to develop their government services, public health services, social services.

And this is something impressive for me personally that I did. I would, if someone would ask me like that, back five years ago, like I. Would you imagine this happening? I don't know, maybe nobody will care about human centricity while we having a war. But no, this is not true because we all understand that while people like living through such a hard times, they really would appreciate if services work better.

Daniele: It's a, it's an impressive love letter to humans and services that you're sharing. Here, at least that's how I receive it on my side. This notion of. It's in tough times. We appreciate the presence of people who are here to serve us. Even if it's the guy doing some coffee, we appreciate in tough times someone being here, staying here to give the coffee

Liza: Absolutely.

Daniele: and saying thank you in the middle of two attacks because. That person is serving us in times where everything is attacking us. And I think that's quite a beautiful way of framing that services in a way are also so now I'm being very, maybe too poetic, but there are also an act of humanity and act of love and appreciation for others just by saying, this moment of very tough times, I'm taking some risk to be of service for you. And and that's a very beautiful way of turning what we sometimes feel as service designers, at least in times of peace where we feel, oh, are we just making things a little bit nicer? And there suddenly you realize how the. The basic aspect of services is really something that, that's, that, that connects humanity together. And that brings people together. That is an act of I'm human. You are a human, and I'm taking time, space, safety risks to be with you and to be there for you. So that's a beautiful act of of appreciation.

Oleg Koss: Absolutely.

Liza: Yes, I absolutely agree. And just if I could just build on the thing that you just said that actually I would even have some kind of a call for service designers all around the world that like if you actually feel that you are, everything that you do is just like making the service a bit better, then maybe you should actually change the place where you work.

Because a Service Design work is really important for many services around like business or government. And you have to feel like you're really making this real change because you have a whole power to make a real change for how people are receiving, are living their life. So that's like super important.

So I, I wish every service designer understand this great power.

Daniele: Absolutely. And this is something that, that, we you can do by moving from one company to another, from one industry to another, from one country to. Another also but it's something that, that I've personally felt in my own career experience where suddenly you come in another setting and you like, oh, the same skills that I've been using suddenly are of service for something bigger. And maybe you move less fast, you move you do less, but you do better or you do more important. And I. I, it's a very poetic call to action to say if you are a service owner, service creator, service designer who's not sure about the impact of what you're doing, maybe try another setting.

Try another context because the skills can be really used for good work.

Oleg Koss: Strive for impact.

Daniele: Yeah, absolutely.

Closing Thoughts and Call to Action

Daniele: Hey I'm deeply touched by this conversation. I have even like physical goosebumps at the moment. It's quite it's I'm very touched by the fact that you're giving time in In this moment to have this conversation, about things that at times I was like, oh my God.

We are having conversations about Service Design and and there is much more important things to attend to. But at the same time, I think with this conclusion that we came at the end, it's quite beautiful also to see that the act of serving others is always a lovely thing to do. And, and no matter the context, no matter the situation. So that's something that I deeply appreciate and I also deeply appreciate, how you help me. And I think others also contextualize how life is for you guys and and in, in a way that is very clear and and and very hopeful.

I'm impressed by the hope. And and, the hope and the sharing and the practical side of things.

Liza: I think Danielle, I would say here do you know this famous phrase? I don't know. This was a motto for my master degree that trust the process. I think. I think we are just here just trusting the process, that we do what we do what we love, but we did what we make, the better, what we can make.

And we believe in Service Design. We trust the process, so we just continue working in that.

Oleg Koss: Yeah,

You for inviting us, and

Liza: Yes.

Oleg Koss: you for helping

Daniele: knows?

Liza: For us it's important.

Daniele: And who knows, maybe in a few years. We'll be able to write a book together. All the three of us speak, around, Service Design, basic Service Design instead of advanced Service Design, but basic Service Design for the. Difficult times.

I think that will be a beautiful kind of twist to how, we always are looking for advanced ai, blah, blah, blah. And coming back to basic de basic Service Design for Tough Times will be a beautiful book or topic that we could explore together. I'm sure that you will have a lot of ideas and things to share. Maybe just a bit of a closing question. Where can people find you if they want to know more about your work and know more about you guys personally? What's the best way or is there a good way for people to reach out to you?

Oleg Koss: As an agency, we are Lanka, LAN. KA cx, is not very difficult to spell, otherwise Liza Lanka would probably work easier to find. And Lanka goes the same, so the second names may be more difficult to spell.

Liza: Yours is quite simple. Mine, I would even like, even, not even, you don't even try guys. But yeah, I'm sure when you are, like there will be links under this post that you, and please yes, reach out to us, to me, like first, I dunno if you've all I'll talk about myself, but reach out to me in case you have any ideas on how to.

Bring more service people around service than, and ideas of service than to use in Ukraine, in public services and military services. And I'm really curious about that. And really open to sharing and work on it. Let me know if you have any ideas. And yeah if you want to travel to Ukraine in just just if you felt this is the thing you wanna do and you wanna join, maybe Service Jam in Ukraine, or you wanna join, I don't know, just to teach something in Ukraine and Service Design or to to.

Yeah, let us know. We are here one of the representative Service Design Network of Ukraine, and we are open to host and share and yeah. Exchange knowledges. Yep.

Daniele: Wonderful. Hey, thank you so much. We are coming to a close, this conversation could last for many more hours and I imagine even days there is, many more things to learn from you guys but I'm also obviously aware of your time and deeply appreciate the fact that you gave me so much time and really appreciate also the way that you had of sharing all of that.

And the message of hope that is all in the all in between the lines. It's something that I deeply appreciate. So a big thank you to you, Liza. A big thank you to you, Oleg. And yeah. Stay safe. I think that's that, that's a good a good last last word but also really appreciate you serving others and continuing to do so.

Liza: this is something really funny. By the way. This is something that change in emailing in Ukraine. A few years ago, they would be like, have a nice day, have a great week, have a nice weekend. Now we write. Have a safe day. Be safe. Stay safe. So yeah, communication matters.

Daniele: So stay safe and thank you so much.

Oleg Koss: Daniele.

Liza: Thank you. Thank you. Same. Thank you Danielle. Thank you.

Climate Adaptation

How can you do first steps towards climate adaptation?

Lucy Stewart— England

A photo of Lucy Stewart

Early principles uncovered

From this conversation with Lucy I stole 10 early Service Design Principles that can help you adapt your service to the climate crisis. Here are my five favorites:

  1. Be clear that shit will hit the fan: Accept that every part of life has always changed and will continue to always change. Be it climate, social life, economic life. Learn to work with the change.

  2. Learn from other sectors and countries: Look for inspiration outside of your industry, country or culture. Others have already figured out things you haven’t

  3. Ask: Are we serving the most vulnerable? Every service can serve those who need it the most.

  4. Don’t leave people behind: Make sure that even when you adapt your service to work in tough times that it doesn’t make it harder for people in vulnerable or marginalized groups to access your services.

  5. Map inputs and outputs: Discover that your intangible service is in fact very by looking at all the things that you need to run it

  6. Balance People and Planet: Being a dick to nature at the expense of humans or the other way around isn’t the way. Care for both.

  7. Don’t just learn the tools, use the tools: Don’t get lost in exploring and finding the latest and best sustainability tools, choose one or two, use them, see if they work and adjust.

  8. Find those who have been there already: Look for local communities, interest groups, associations where you can find other people who have already done the work.

  9. Build hope by working with others: Don’t work on big changes alone or you’ll lose motivation. Build or join a community to stay motivated on the long term.

  10. Make your space more welcoming for small creatures: Make your workspace friendly for things smaller than humans: bees, birds, and other creatures. And remember, kids are also small creatures.

About the human

Lucy Stewart is a design researcher for climate adaption, a community organiser and an urban food grower. She helps organizations to collaboratively identify, define, build and test ideas that confront the climate crisis and enable a just transition.

Lucy is also an educator at The School of Good Services where together with Ness Wright she leads the course “Designing Sustainable Services”.

The full conversation

Chapters

  • 00:00 Teaser

  • 03:24 Who is Lucy?

  • 04:52 Personal Identity Beyond Job Titles

  • 11:18 Discussing Climate Adaptation

  • 21:33 Starting with Sustainable Practices

  • 26:16 Community and Hope in Climate Action

  • 30:16 Addressing Climate Adaptation in Various Professions

  • 32:14 The Role of Community and Resilience

  • 32:53 Challenges in Public Services and Climate Justice

  • 34:47 Integrating Climate Action in Business Practices

  • 39:00 The Importance of Local Initiatives

  • 46:35 Resources and Tools for Sustainable Services

  • 48:10 Call to Action and Final Thoughts

Transcript

This transcript was automatically generated using Descript without any hand-made corrections. So it might be pretty creative at moments.

Teaser

How can you do first steps towards climate adaptation? That's what we chatted about with Lucy Stewart in an interview for my next book on how to create services that serve both humans and planet.

Lucy is a design researcher for climate adaptation, a community organizer and an urban food grower. She helps organizations to collaboratively identify, define, build, and test ideas that confront the climate crisis, and enable a just transition.

Lucy is also an educator at the School of Good Services where together with Ness Wright, she leads the course Designing Sustainable Services.

From this conversation with Lucy, I stole 10 early Service Design principles that can help you adapt your service to the climate crisis. Here are my five favorite ones.

Number one: be clear. That shit will hit the fan. Accept that every part of life has always changed and will continue to always change. Learn to work with the change.

Number two: don't leave people behind. Make sure that even when you adapt your service to work in tough times, that it doesn't make it harder for people who are in vulnerable or marginalized groups to access your services.

Number three: map inputs and outputs. Discover that your intangible service is in fact very material by looking at all the things that you need to run it.

Number four: Don't just learn the tools, use the tools. Don't get lost in exploring and finding the latest and greatest sustainability tools. Choose one or two. Use them. See if they work and adjust.

And number five: make your workspace and surroundings friendly for things smaller than humans, bees, birds, and other creatures. And remember, kids are also small creatures. Thanks so much to Lucy for this lovely conversation.

hello, Lucy. It's such a pleasure to finally see you.

I think, like we've said, we've been following each other for a while, so it's nice to, we're not quite in person, but it's nice to you and see your face and Yeah, get, get to know you a little bit better. So thank you very much for inviting me.

And it's it's such a pleasure because I'm one of these people in the silent majority of people who follow your work, maybe without, shouting this is great and so on every time. But always there is always some interesting bits that I could steal from you in a very discreet way.

And and I hope that today I can give a bit more like to one of the people that I've stolen from for a bit of time.

at least my un my understanding of, of design and Service Design in the work that we do is that unless somebody's using it, what's the, what's the point? So that's like music to my ears. So yeah, and hopefully there will be, well, I hope to provide some more nuggets that others can steal speaking with no level of expertise, but just with exploration.

So it's always really lovely to be given these opportunities to chat about our work and what we're trying to do with it. 'cause sometimes it can feel abstract and so this is a very refreshing conversation.

Absolutely.

Who is Lucy?

And that brings me to, to this first question, which is, when you go to a birthday party, and you have to. Explain to strangers that don't know anything about your field what you are doing in life, what keeps you busy how do you present yourself in a birthday party?

I think, isn't it? Because I, I think what I was trying and do immediately and what, what I found is worked is, you know, when I say I'm a designer and people are like, oh, you know, what type of type of design is that? And I'm, you know, and I futz around a little bit and I'm like, oh, it's, but I say immediately like, how did you get here? Like, how did you get to this birthday party? And they would say, you know, maybe a bus or a train or a drove. And I say, you know, all of that is designed, whether that be where you hang your keys in order to pick it up, to get in the car or, it's conscious decisions around how all of that is orchestrated, how easy it is for you to pay your tap and go card and. I find at a party. I don't say what I do, but I try and introduce and get to know people through, I guess, kind of understanding, their lives within service context. And so I, I think my introductions are, they're, they're pretty putsy and they're pretty long-winded and sometimes eyes really light up and sometimes I totally glaze over.

But I think I try and not introduce myself by way of my work.

Personal Identity Beyond Job Titles

You know, I talk, I talk about myself as, as I would like to be understood beyond what I do for a living, which is, you know, somebody who. swimming and gardening and you know what, this is the last book I read. And, but by way of communicating that natural question that always comes up, which is what do you do? I try and put it back to the people and, and then I find as soon as people kind of can orientate themselves, like, okay, transport is a service, then I can go into what I actually do, which is work across all different digital, non-digital people have to navigate the world. But increasingly, I'm interested in climate change will do for how we have to adapt, how we navigate the world. And that includes how we do it individually and how we do it within the services that we have built around us in order to survive, rightly or wrongly. Right? So. It's hard to introduce myself at a party because I am multitudes I want to get that across to people. And our work is sometimes not, it's not, it'd be I've, my poor parents have said to my mom, just lie to people.

Tell them I'm a lawyer. Like, it's too, we all have stories related to related how we navigate the world, and if I can help people see that, then talking about the fact that currently I'm designing a service to help people understand and information about air quality to protect their health, it's something that they can kind of get around.

So my introductions at parties are a bit I'm not, you know, it takes a couple rounds for me to make friends, but then yeah, then it's a good party. So yeah.

Yeah. Lovely. I really appreciate this aspect, of showing to or acting in the way that we say. The job title doesn't define the person. It's it's one part of the day and for many people there is many more hours in the day. And I've been, and in that same situation where often people ask me what do I do?

And these days, the answer that I give is always, so mostly I'm a dad and because that's the thing that takes most of my hours. But maybe you wanted to ask, what do I do where I'm paid? And for the paid thing, that's the thing that I do to get paid to then have time with my son. And so that's like a strange thing then, especially these days where people are like freaking out oh, you're a man and you're taking care of your son.

That's weird. At least in, in conservative sometimes in conservative aspect. But I like this kind of positive provocation of not saying. Hello. I'm job title, but hello these are passions that are around me. That's like quite a beautiful way.

my, association with people in our world is that, you know, it's not a clear boundary between work and life either. And it's very, it's a, struggled with working in this area personally because it feels sometimes not very tangible and, you know, layered underneath systems that unless they're in them, they're hard to see.

So yeah, I, you know, I've, I've, I fell into this work by accident, and it's been a very interesting, windy path. And I think there's an element sometimes of being a little. Self-conscious isn't the right word, but like, you know, you want, you want, I think we all came into this profession wanting to do good in the world, right?

And feeling like through our practice we could support people in systems that they, they are required to do so because they have a disability or they're simply trying to get healthcare for their child. And sometimes, yeah, it's just so hard when you're in it to feel like you are doing that.

And I think for me it's this tiptoeing around this. 'cause once people get what you do, it's like, oh cool. And I'm like, yeah, it's cool. I'm really lucky I get to poke my nose in things that I never would've been able to do in another profession. you know, I get to be indulgent about, do I work in-house?

Do I freelance, do I work in a design studio? So it's know, I, I'm probably speaking a bit more candidly with you now 'cause I'm going through a period of being like. What am I doing and where am I? but I think that constant questioning is a part of what we do, but of course, that makes it quite difficult to then just succinctly introduce yourself when all of those lines are so blurred.

So, but yeah, I think if we, if we introduce our whole selves, then the, the, the work quickly makes sense in terms of that. Yeah.

Absolutely. And so what is that last book that you read that.

called not at all to do with Service Design or anything, but it's a piece of fiction by Barbara King Silver, who's an American author, very well known, has, and she wrote a beautiful book called Damon Copperhead, was her modern version of, the Charles Dickens book about children in poverty. And this was a book about a beautiful character who grew up very rough in Appalachia, so a very forest stretch of America. I'm was born and raised in America. This obviously has, and I think it was very good to read in the context of politics in America at the moment. And it was a, just a beautiful narrative around experience of this young boy, his his relationships and how he navigates growing up in poverty and dealing with drug addiction, which is, you know, really powerful in this part of America.

Like it's devastated communities. And, so I finished that book weeks ago and you know, it, I guess in some ways it is relevant to because it's about systems that fail people. But I loved it. It was took me a while to get into it, but once I did, I was like very attached to this character and I know it's a good book when I feel that way. So recommend.

Ah, that's lovely. So people are, have already an element to add in their wishlist for reading. That's that that's already one. That's very good. That's very good.

What is Climate Adaptation?

And, I'm curious with often from how, at least I perceive you, you have this expertise in this notion of climate adaptation.

Like how do we adapt to the new reality, to the new systems, to the to, to what is happening at the moment and how would you describe what that is? Because it sounds like one of those complex words. What is this climate adaptation thing and how is that also relevant to people? Who say, I am the owner of a little shop or I am a dentist, or I'm just someone, doing some coaching or therapy.

How does that big idea relate to, to that reality?

is that somebody who works very high up in climate worlds goes to all of the crops, which are the big global summits around climate change. And he said to me, Lucy, climate adaptation, as I talk about it, is everywhere. If maybe somebody grew up by a pond in, I don't know, Scotland say, and or Switzerland's, and. All of a sudden, you know, they, they have vivid childhood memories of, skating on this pondering winter. And but as they're growing older and they go back maybe to see their parents or something, the pond isn't freezing over in a way that they can experience it. Like they have memories of experiencing it. I read this paper about, really about narrative change around climate and the stories that we tell to get people to realize that the environment in which we are working, whether you be a dentist or a shop owner or a therapist, is And whether it's changing because of something you believe in, which is climate change or for other reasons, change is inevitable.

And this has been a really big theme in my work, is that change has always happen and we'll continue to do. So we navigate that is is the question. And so when I

Thanks.

climate change in the context of services or owning and operating a building, it's about acknowledging that whether it be a freak storm or less frost or heavy rainfall, that how we operate is going to be stressed more. already stressed more than it was 10 years ago, and it's going to be further stressed another 10 years from now. And I think unless we start thinking about that, whether we're designing a digital service or, or thinking about how our get from where they are to my dentist seat, then we, we, without starting to think about that, I think we risk business continuity. You maybe can't open your shop for a week. Like that's pretty devastating for a small shop owner, you know? Maybe you have a drop in patients because the road to your dentistry practice floods frequently and people can't get to you. maybe you have an increase of patients coming in as a therapist that are, have climate anxiety because we know this is happening, right?

And all of a sudden you're confronted in helping somebody navigate something that is totally unpredictable, over the long term and intangible. And that's why describing climate climate adaptation is difficult because it's so much about now. But what I also like about it is that it trains me, starts to think about the future. And I think so much of my early practice and Service Design was like delivered to this three month brief. Like that actually climate makes, forces me to think over the next. year, two, year, five, year 10. And so I think for when I talk about adaptation, I wish there was a better way to describe it, but it, it really, I think it's more, less on the climate and more on the adaptation, is like, we all need to find more ways to live.

'cause even if our consumption pattern weren't contributing to a warming world, they would be using resources. And those resources are finite. So whichever way you start to square the narrative is that like we have to kind of change the way that we do things. And I think change is scary for people. And I think a lot of the stuff that I am trying to, I, you know, I'm not, I'm not trained in a, again, climate adaptation is a huge academic discipline.

It's about. Modeling and finance and risk is a big one. And, you know, a lot of people spend lots and lots of times, but, and I, I, I, I don't have a degree in adaptation. I don't, it's something I've morphed into through the different work pieces of work that I've done. But the way I think about it is that any service or any business operation, first and foremost runs on stuff like what we call the inputs and creates stuff as a result of operating outputs. So adaptation, I think, is both about recognizing your role in change and what you're consuming and why, and what that means for a user's experience, but then also recognizing impacts of this change are already affecting your ability to deliver what you do. And that helps me think about what perspective I'm gonna come to a problem with. But really it's about, you know, I think in scientific circles we talk about mitigation, adaptation, and resilience. So mitigation is like reducing our outputs. Like we gotta get carbon off the table quickly. We also need to think a lot more about our water resources. Adaptation is change is inevitable.

We know that it's baked in. Even if we were to stop using petrol cars flying tomorrow, we are projected for climactic change of 1.5, probably two degrees now. So we have to, we're gonna have to adapt, like storms are gonna get worse. These events that we're seeing more and more on our screens are gonna become more frequent. then resilience is about how we equipped ourselves socially. Financially to deal with that change that we're seeing. And I think Service Design or op business operations, you can slot into those things. You know, there are companies that exist to deliver services that help to reduce carbon emissions or retrofit homes.

This is a big thing at the moment in the uk. But the adaptation and resilience stuff is, I'm seeing way more of that now. And arguably people have been studying this for 20, 30, 40 years. But in terms of services, I, I mean, it depends on where you look in, like the UK's NHS, they're doing some amazing work thinking about like the impact of these operations on hospitals and the ability to run.

And, but yeah, I think it, it, it is relevant to, to all of us and whether you're a service owner. government or in a charity or running a small business. I think it's a worthwhile practice. And I say practice because it's hard to think long term and it's hard to think in the abstract around weather. And it's also hard if you're just struggling to put food on the table for your family. Right. And this is where I think services design becomes interesting because of the co benefits. know, if you are more sustainable, sometimes there is a financial benefit, your costs are reduced or, I'm trying to explore these co benefits in my work as well, but it's all quite hard, especially like in places where I'm working at the moment because it's not necessarily what people are asking for. And yeah, there's a little bit of me that worries that we're, we're still a little bit, we need to meet our financial targets this year focused. While missing all of the stuff that's happening kind of in the background, that will mean those targets will become kind of redundant in the future. So that was a bit of a long-winded answer, but hopefully ties to those audiences that you introduced.

Like I really think goes back to my original point is that adaptation is everywhere and we all need to be doing it. and I can refine that too. We all need to become better versed in navigating change, and I think that has a very strong service and

Absolutely.

perspective to it.

It reminds me how in, in some countries, people, when they explain what Service Design is, they use the word risk management where they say basically it's about reducing the risk that if things go to shit that we still can. Do the important things that we want to do. And and from what I hear of what you're saying, things will go to shit.

That's, we are all clear on that. If you believe in it or in climate change or not, we all see that there will be issues. That's and there will be more. And I think it's quite an interesting way to, to, i, I like how you frame adaptation and not just as climate adaptation, but adaptation in general.

Saying if we build that muscle of thinking about the future of what could go to shit, then suddenly we are better at making the service also today it, things can go to shit just for people, but things can go to shit also just basically in the weather and so on. So that's quite a beautiful way.

And I'm curious how. So if someone says, oh, this adaptation thing, that's that's quite powerful. I need to build that muscle, that practice, as you said.

But where do I start?

Starting with Sustainable Practices

I think it's a question that I get a lot and I, so that's why we develop this sustainable Service Design training through the School of Good Services. And I, there are, I guess there's a couple train trains of thought. One is like, do I start? Okay, so you can start measuring things, right? You can in the wind like, okay, I run this business run this. need this and to see the benefit of running this business, to take this out of it. and I think when you start seeing a services more material than we're maybe accustomed to thinking about it. Again, it goes back to kind of those inputs and outputs and, and one train of thought of where to start is identify where in that process of mapping those inputs and outputs, you can measure something.

Because if you can measure something, you can understand it and you can work to reduce it. And when I said measure something, that could be the carbon emissions of whatever you need to use to get stuff to your shop. that be you fly it from elsewhere or you source it locally and it's delivered by bike and then, or it could be energy usage.

Right. And I think I really see the benefit in measurement because it gives you a baseline from which you can see, okay, well if I change that, oh, funnily enough, like my bills have gone down and I'm reducing a less, a less electricity. Like that's interesting. But measurement can be really hard and really abstract, and that's not necessarily always where I suggest people to start.

I think it, where I suggest people to start is that further upstream of what I mentioned of like, well, have you thought about your business as a, or your service as a, as, as a, as materials, like as something that you can grasp or and I think, you know, there's, there's, there's books to be read and there's, but I, I think one for me around to start is I think it becomes a little bit more personal. And this is where the individual in the service, in the system, that whole is, you know, what, what? If you wanna start thinking about adaptation, it's like, well, what is important to you? What do you care about? What do you want to see and I think it's gotta come from some emotional place because it's too hard to pursue otherwise, like it's very hard to convince senior stakeholders to invest in this or it's still, there's a lot of ESG, you know, environmental sustainability reporting and that.

But it bogged down, I think, in a lot of bureaucracy. It's very hard to do. It can be quite expensive. But, know, we, we talk a little bit about how to maintain personal resilience in the training at the, at the end. And I also think that's probably where you need to start is like, think making climate change relevant to your operation.

So understanding what it, what it is. And where it's come from, you know, extraction, colonization, like and then thinking, using that knowledge to empower yourself to think about, well, what, what is important to you and what is worth making changes for? So I, I, there's an element of humanizing the measurement and the science, and I think when people grasp what is at stake. Then applying that and starting that in your work becomes a little bit easier. of course then there are so many tools now to help with carbon measurement and there are lots of courses out there for people to kind of educate themselves around what this means to I wouldn't be surprised if every business is probably having to do some form of, if they're, if they're for a bid or some sort of climate.

You know, we're starting to see legal requirements, I think catch up with business operations. And all of that is an exercise of bringing something that is quite abstract to, and I think it would be in any service owners or business manager's best interest to see these patterns emerging and understand what it, what it means to you.

And I would reach out to people. I think where I normally start is like reaching out to people and saying like, I run this and I don't know. I don't, you know, I don't really know where to start with it. If I'm trying to do, if I'm trying to reduce my carbon emissions, there are business groups focused on this now.

Like it's not a case of people facing this alone anymore.

Community and Hope in Climate Action

And I, that would probably be long story, that was a long thread that would probably where it start is like, find your community that is also trying to figure out where to start because they exist everywhere in every sector. I think anyone would quickly find, you know, there's probably a small businesses for climate group in their region or, and then all of a sudden you're not alone and it doesn't feel so so that would be my, I found it.

That would be my where to start. And then I think it's just a case of figuring out what, what that means for your context and your financial position and the skills and capabilities you have to navigate that, you know.

I like this approach where you say there is already someone who has gone through the past. Just find them and ask them. What did you do in my context, which is specific in my country, my legal system and oh, these are the people to talk to. These are the resources that can help in that language that I can understand. unfortunately, I think we and that makes sound that.

If only it is that easy. I think unfortunately it is very context specific. Your laws in Switzerland are different from mine in England, which are different from mine in Scotland. Our goals around our targets around reduction are different.

So, but yeah, I think we have to take comfort in community at this juncture because, or else it just feels way too hard. And it's scary, you know, like it's not, you don't pick up a paper and, and read it around climate change and, and put it down feeling optimistic or like, so I, it goes back to what we were discussing before and there's a slide in my training, which is like, unfortunately we have to talk about risk at the moment because it's a way to wake people up.

It's like, boom, here's the bottom line. If you don't do this, but hope is what has to sustain us. Like we cannot address this on risk alone. We have to imagine that a world that we could create in addressing it now is gonna be more just and fair and we're not gonna leave people behind. Like this is a growing interest at the intersection of accessibility within Service Design and climate adaptation. What we don't wanna perpetuate is, you know, the rich being able to adapt at the expense of. disabled people who won't be able to escape if the building floods. And I'm really interested, I haven't managed to sink my teeth into that type of work yet, but I, think that's, you know, very interesting. Yeah, I think, I don't know where I was going with that thought, but it, it kind oh, the risk and the hope stuff.

And the hope also, you can sustain that a lot longer if you do it in community rather than on your own. and I think in any government department, well now in government, in central government, in the uk you know, there's a whole sustainability community. There's people working in digital services that are like, oh God, you know, this is my job and I like, wanna feel like I'm doing something within my job that helps this, it, it might be little, but there's communities there.

And then in local government they'll be different. So they are there, and if they're not there, then you can start one.

Absolutely there, there's this very beautiful thing that you said of adaptation shouldn't leave people behind. I think there is something quite strong for our generation, which has lived COVID and has seen how adaptation was quite fast for the digitally savvy, et cetera. It was very easy. And then you suddenly looked at other groups of people and you said, oh shit.

For them, it's like they completely lost relationships. They completely lost contact and so on. And and I'm wondering when it comes to. Making, thinking about adaptations that don't leave people behind.

Addressing Climate Adaptation in Various Professions

What are ways of thinking tips that you have to make sure that we don't leave people behind?

Because we might say, I'm a dentist. I think about the heat waves. Okay, we could do these and these things in our service that makes it possible to continue our service. But how can this dentist or this coach or whatever think about but if I adapt in that way, maybe I'm gonna leave these people behind.

shift. I mean, I, I, I think in any of those professions, regardless of climate change, people, I, I would hope that people would want to serve people that need it. If, if somebody can't afford to get their tooth fixed, like, I would like to imagine that most dentists would try and find ways to, think this is really important where we don't separate climate isn't. not, it doesn't need to be separate. And I think actually it goes back to the principles of co-design, participatory design, who is designing these adaptation pathways for us. Like, it cannot be me in a little design studio being commissioned for three months. Like, I think this demands a different way of how we involve people in decision making, whether you're running a dentistry or not.

You know, I, I think a dentist, a dentist practice could ask the question now of like, are we serving our most vulnerable, regardless of whether they're experiencing clinic I think that's a really important question that to interrogate, you know, digital design. In the UK we're pretty good at accessibility, of course.

And what I mean is people that need to navigate digital technology with you know with, assistive technologies or they're blind or and there's a lot of chat around this and like community organizing around having to print posters or whatever in multiple languages because that, that is who your community is. And this goes back to the point about resilience.

The Role of Community and Resilience

And I think this is kind of why I'm starting to land on resilience as an interesting space because it builds on community in the way that services, if they're like a, dentistry is part of a neighborhood, it's part of a wider community. And I think what this demands is like, well what, what is that role of this dentist?

And there's loads of interesting articles about emergency response and the big saviors are not coming for you. It's your neighbor. Like, so we need to get, it's, it's back to first principles. And this is I think why it feels quite hard in an environment of.

Challenges in Public Services and Climate Justice

Budget stripping, and I don't know if this is the case where you are, but there's very little money in the UK at the moment to run public services. They threaten to cut the personal independence payment, which is a quite a big disability payment of afforded to people who into work. And this, to me is like a climate, this is a climate justice issue. I think where a lot of climate stuff has failed isn't just being like and the bees, which don't get me wrong, is really important and needs a voice in the room as much as but it also comes at the, at the, at the expense of people.

And so going back to the dentist, I, I, don't think dentists are being asked, well, what's your role in the community? They'll be like. We're just here to fix teeth. But actually they're probably a bit of a community hub. You know, they have a, A means they have a distribution list. They have a means of what, they have a physical building where people could come and organize, you know, so they actually have a lot of strength potentially, if hits the fan, there's a huge climactic event, but none of us are prepared to see our dentist as that. And so I like, I think where the interesting work is going on in adaptation and resilience is in that community, neighborhood based work that climate adaptation, not as a replacement, but extension of the work that they already do. Unfortunately, I don't think this is what's funded, certainly not here in the uk and I think that's where we need to inject. know, there's huge, rifts between the left and the right here. You know, pro-immigration, like all of these wider societal issues are creating really big crevices I think in our ability to be able to be resilient.

## Integrating Climate Action in Business Practices

And part of me is like, maybe I just need to drop this whole climate thing in my, the way that I present myself and actually just go back and do youth work or like, you know, start at those principles, right?

And stop working on about services and 'cause it, again, I can only speak from a UK context, like services are being really stripped back here and I think we have to ask what public services I should say, you know? And that's not to say that private services are or any of that. I think it's just recognizing questions around access and around whether we are actually addressing user needs.

So. Yeah. You know, I think there's a lot of climate advocates that I follow that you know, are, and it's something that I'm thinking about increasingly. I don't wanna go to more climate events if it there isn't a justice angle. Because oftentimes, if I'm being very honest, is people like me, pretty white, middle class loves to garden, you know, and the room is full of people like me, eco Warriors.

I can afford my refill shop. Like, you know, I can, I can afford to choose not to have a car, really. But we're not gonna, we're not gonna win any of this, this. Huge parts of my community here in East Sussex are angry at immigrants because they think they're taking their houses. You know, like it's the narrative dissonance is, and I think we have to, I think we have to, there's a responsibility for those services to think about climate, but then I think there's a responsibility for people who think about climate to also back.

And I think it's a big reorganization, but it's really, and I think that's why the climate work is so hard in this era of austerity, you know, services in the uk. And I speak a lot about public services 'cause it's primarily where I work. and I think it's quite a big foundation of Service Design. And so it's very hard to come from a place of building community resilience when it's so broken. Anyway. But it goes back to our original question is that it's inevitable. So, what are we gonna do about it? So it's it's I'd like to empower everybody to feel like they have a responsibility for addressing climate adaptation. And I think, you know, I actually think a lot of people know the ground, the nurses that are having to show up, like the NHS has clauses now. If you cannot come to work because there's a flood or a climactic event, this is what, so there are already, you know, policies in place that help people navigate this.

But yeah, I'd love more, I'd love more money to flow into make connecting these dots. But it's not what's funded at the moment. What's still funded is digital transformations and, but I think, you know, climate activists and climate people and those of us, we have a lot to learn from disability activism and. You know, a lot to learn from people who have always lived on the margins. And I think that goes back to making sure that when we are designing any sort of intervention, we, we just make sure, like really adamantly, I know there's a lot of talk about co-design and participation, but really dig our heels into that.

'Cause I think that's all related.

Yeah, it's it's beautiful how, this idea of saying if we serve. One side, same planet. Let's not forget the other side. The human, if we, for, if we serve the human, let's not forget the other side that says you. Yeah, you said that in a quite poetic way with the it's nice to tend to the bees and the birds, but if there's someone on the floor who has an issue, has a broken leg or something,

Yeah,

we can attend to that person too.

So I really appreciate that the,

about the bees and the birds too, and without them like, forget everything,

yeah.

they really underpin that, yeah, that disconnect feels feels very very high.

The Importance of Local Initiatives

But, you know, going back to a dentist practice, they probably exist that their building in which they operate exists in a spot where maybe they could put a couple flowering plants up front, you know?

And I think this is doing what we can with what we have. that doesn't mean you need a agro diverse food forest in your back garden. If you're a dentist, it means like you can collect water. You can put water butts on your property and use that to feed the plants that you grow, that help pollinators at your entrance.

Like and there's a big movement in the UK at the moment, what, what people are calling like, more than human narratives involved in policy making. And I don't know whether you have this same trend in but it's very, very big to like, you know, in a decision making space, bring a representative from the local river into the, and it, I don't know the impact of what those initiatives have been.

But it's interesting to see a lot of resource going into that at the moment around PhDs. And someone for you maybe just to check out is the work that Phoebe Tickle is doing with Moral Imaginations. 'Cause she would argue that, you know, the reason why policy and decision making is so stuck is because we. We fail to imagine otherwise. And I think this imagination work is, it's not the work that I do, but I think it's very important. so I think, yeah, that the, the challenge is ours to incorporate the justice part with the birds and the bees. Like that's a lot to weigh our options for, but I think we have to, we just have to figure out how to do it.

'cause if we neglect one, we, we will neglect the other and then, yeah. What we can afford to do is just everybody who can afford it retracting into the background where these are dying and somebody else, you know? So, and that's why I think it is really important for all of us, especially if we work on our computers a lot and in our little cool studios in the setting out, we have got to get out and like some holes and touch some soil and do community water testing and build an affiliation to your. Natives. It doesn't need to demand that much, but I think we do need to, especially in the West, we need to, we curate our relationships to nature. I just sometimes wonder how much we have to do that individually in our own lives and how much that, comes into our work with these explicit like tools that we're designing. So yeah.

So if. You had a business owner in front of you who says, oh, that sounds interesting. This this idea of bringing the, let's go back to nature moments into my work, because I imagine, it, instead of doing a one of those team building events, that is a nonsensical, we could do something else which is both pur, purpose driven and at the same time, makes people go back from the screen.

What are initiatives where you say, oh, these are things that business owners could more easily say to their staff, Hey, this is part of work now that we, each week, each month we could set some time for such actions. What would your wishlist of actions be one will share with them?

of that is predicated on probably defining new business models where we give staff time to, to do this with intention. And I think I, I mean the intention part really earnestly. 'cause I think it's very easy to be like, oh yeah, we went on a team day and we, you know, helped a local, the group and then you never see them again. Like, what is that actually? And that's probably more of something that I would encourage is. You know, adopt a site or figure out a relationship locally and hold that over the longer term, because I think that both helps stretch our capacity for longer term relationship building and also keeps the benefits of what we're trying to do, where we operate and where we work, which is where I think the change needs to come from.

Governments are not, like, that's not gonna be the way that we, and so I think when I, if I'm faced with that business owner, you know, I would, would probably have conversations about the, like where they operate and do they operate in different places and who, who their staff are and, and what skills do they want to gain And, oh, there's that in sheds group over there that can teach your employees how to build that stuff that they said they, and I'm interested increasingly in like local economies and you know how services like so much wealth gets extracted because. Of the way that we commission and procure things. And this has been my kind of like thread of, you know, how we don't incorporate sustainability into new contracts very well. And therefore, and, and, and I think where I'm going with this is that if I were to, would first encourage any business to adapt to the place that they operate to be more, know, can you put a pond in to help wildlife?

Or can you invite people to your space that maybe wouldn't have access to it? And and, and then yeah, what, or, and out with that, like what is needed in your immediate local community. Like interesting. In that field over there, they're, they're wanting to fundraise to build a community orchard. So I, I think a lot, sometimes I feel like a lot of, especially from maybe a business perspective, depending on the size, there's a lot of looking outwards, right?

Like, and all of these initiatives are necessary fundraising to save coral in Australia. Like, you know, Amazon, like, please don't, don't get me wrong there. Like, we need to invest in that stuff. But I think especially in a country like the uk, I think we're the lowest ranking in terms of green space and tree cover in Europe. like, I think we've gotta do, and I think that's a double-edged sword of actually doing stuff locally, whether it be planting a tree, but make sure it's the right tree in the right place. Or adapting our spaces of operation to be more, to capture more water or and then using that to build stronger ties with our neighbors and our, so you're adapting and your building resilience all the while giving your stuff. A little bit more time to, I mean, that would be the dream. I know there's a lot of chat about day weeks, universal income, and I get it. Like, I think that, I think that is a huge systems lever if we could get that moving to help with some of this stuff. but, you know, I know most businesses who try to build governance structures that afford their staff to do this, it's not easy. So we need more examples of that and, and that working financially for a business. But man, it's hard to run a business at the moment. Certainly a small one. Which is why they're getting bigger and more and more dissociated with place. And I think that's our, that's our challenge. So again, depends on the business, depends on the, but yeah, I think if we can think about where we're. It goes back to where we're getting our inputs from, what we're doing with them while we're there, which affects what we spew at the other end. there's a narrative thread in all of this somehow.

Thanks so much. If you had to give, let's say it like that.

Resources and Tools for Sustainable Services

We've covered already a few a few things. And and I will do an I not shameless plug which is, there is a very good course that you are part of around the more sustainable services. It's from the School of Good Prince, how

of

Good Services is, how is the name again?

and Sarah Drummonds on. Yes. So Lou wrote the Good Services book Good Service Design. I remember what it's called. That's not a good plug, is it? SIS or yeah. Designing Good Services is the name of their book. And yeah, they developed this training screen of which they kindly asked me and a very dear friend of mine, a very, very, deeply knowledgeable person around adaptation and resilience ness, Wright who lives up in Glasgow.

Like, I wanna give out a shout out to Ness because she was pretty instrumental in helping design this course. Yeah, so Ness and I worked with Sarah at Sno. It's where I started my whole like, services climate stuff. And, and yeah, we run the designing sustainable services one day training through the school. Mm-hmm.

And so there are these resources which I'm sure many people will want to follow. And there is also a lot of good writing from back in the days when SN was not what it is today was a bit of a different company from what I could see. But there's still a lot of good medium articles that you guys wrote around that's, that I found particularly useful.

So that's also a very good resource.

Call to Action and Final Thoughts

But outside of those resources, is there something else that you say that would, you would like to put as a reminder, as a bit of a call to action for people who are either working in the service industry or who are service designers where you say. When you think about climate justice, climate adaptation, climate, everything think about that.

This is a last input that I'd like to give you guys.

hmm. I mean, two things pop into my head immediately. I don't know how they pertain particularly to services, but the first one is the, and it's UK specific, so maybe it's not the best example, but Cambo is the latest advocacy to stop an oil field being developed in the north of England. think just being aware of that is very useful because they very well articulate the narrative around, you know, what what extraction of oil means and why it's so detrimental. I think from a service perspective. So there's a couple things that I will point out that I am playing with at the moment, which is in, again, in the uk DEFRA has created greener service principles, which are their principles for greening Service Design. Maybe more candidly, probably not to, articulate in the book. I'm a little critical of them. Like I don't think they're the best principles, but they are there and they are guiding some decision making for how to bring in sustainability into government Service Design So needed. I'm not gonna fault it.

So that's that's another resource. I think, the design council in the UK is doing a lot of work around skills for planet where they are trying to identify where in design as a very big discipline are the levers for change to incorporate sustainability and planetary health into what we do.

They've got a new book, I think it's called Skills for Planet. It's like a PDF. It's very long. Some of this stuff I'm like, oh, we're really not helping ourselves here. But there are, there are a lot of resources out there. Obviously our training and my advice would be to pick up a tool and try and apply it in context. And very quickly you will be humbled because I've tried to apply some of the tools that we develop and offer those that come to our training in the context I'm working now and seems really hard to just fill out an input output map of a service. But you know, just getting the right people in the room can take months.

And I think that's what's really humbled me. I think we are very guilty, especially in Service Design of creating lots of tools. And frameworks and we are, I think we're drowning in them a little bit, but what we're not doing is saying we tried it and it didn't really work. And that's no criticism of the tool.

And I think this is what we're a little scared of. It's like tool doesn't work and mine legit but I, yeah, I would look for the case studies of being applied in principle. And for me, that's also meant going, stretching my ideas of beyond Service Design. So some of my best work lately was work that I did working in a big environment company. That was around using the tools of Service Design to think about community-based flooding infrastructure or develop new stewardship schemes for water management. And I would encourage service designers if they're working in healthcare, to look out with just the Service Design discipline the way other industries are trying to adjust to this change, I think can be really insightful.

So you can look at like the suds plus work that I worked on at when I was at a and, so yeah, I, you know, that's just me rattling off what comes to my head immediately. We, if, if I think of something, something else, I will definitely let you know, but I'm interested in seeking out the kind of attempts to try it. And yeah, and more ways to, to share our learnings. So I hope that's helpful. I'm not great at these call questions.

Absolutely no worries. Yeah and that's, it's to me it feels like you giving pointers to people and. Obviously everyone will have then to look for them, what makes sense in their context and so on. So that's obviously very different in every context, every language the resources are not the same, but it always helps to have a few pointers because then you can

for

then

And I'd

around and find what's useful.

I'm feeling very trapped in a UK mindset at the moment, and I know other countries are looking at this differently or, and I, yeah, I, you know, other countries are much further ahead in thinking about this than we are in the uk. So I think there's a lot I would look to gain from learning from other countries and their constraints and their so yeah, it'd be great to see how your resource list evolve.

Absolutely. And you gave a lot in this short conversation that we have. I think many people will come out of it with, oh wow, this person really helped me a lot. Like Lucy is really a gem. She shared so many things that I can use that can help me think differently. What can people do for you?

If they arrived at this moment in the conversation and they say, oh, I'd like to give back in some way or form to Lucy because she's been so nice with me, what can they what can listeners do for you?

looking for more work. I'm freelancing at the moment. My existing contract is open. And it'd be great, you know, I think the way to spend, I'd love to meet new people and have chats like this a little bit more openly and. Of course if that leads to amazing projects, working with great people, great.

But I think where I'm taking a lot of comfort at the moment and where the benefit of freelancing is, is these opportunities to meet new people and challenge, challenge that. So, you know, if you've asked me what people can do for me, I guess it's to get in touch. Like I'd love to. I, I, this is a learning journey.

I, it's a very, we're, I feel so lucky that my job is also, it's, it, it feeds me because it keeps me learning. And a way to learn from that is also to speak with others. And I guess that invitation is extended far beyond people who maybe do Service Design or I guess anyone who's ma found this conversation, know, like, I'd love to understand what it means in people's context.

So, yeah, I guess what people could do for me is just like, reach out and say hello, because honestly, everything that you've said in terms of. Following my work, and especially when you're freelancing, it can feel quite lonely. You know, I talk about all this like building community and dah, dah, dah, dah, dah, but it feels harder to do that in the current working structure that I am.

So if anything comes from this where I a couple new people and then that would, that would be amazing.

It's been really a pleasure to finally get to hear the voice behind the good words. So a big thank you to you for taking the time.

I yeah, no, Thank you so much for

the opportunity. It's been a really lovely way to start the day I can't thank you enough, it's a real pleasure to be here.

thanks you and enjoy the rest of your summer.

Thank you very much. you too. I will, I will see

Go further

These are resources and people that were mentioned during the interview that can help you go further.

Courses and tools

People to follow

Endings

How can we create an end of a service that doesn't suck?

Joe Macleod— Sweden

A photo of Joe Macleod

Early principles uncovered

In this conversation, we uncovered 10 early drafts of Service Design Principles:

  1. Ask how does it end

  2. Do an ending audit to see what isn’t needed

  3. Show how it will end at the start

  4. Help people get the emotions out when it ends: help people find resolutions

  5. Don’t be a dick in the end. Be generous.

  6. Make sure the way it ends is like it started.

  7. Use the end to let people experience your values a last time.

  8. Remind people about their right and responsibilities at the end.

  9. Don’t create ending that bring people back.

  10. Check what the law says.

About the human

Joe Macleod is the expert of endings.

He wrote two books about it, helped companies like Fairphone implement beautiful ends and trains the next generation of designers to be endineers: people that are as strong in designing the end than the start.

The full conversation

This transcript was automatically generated using Descript without any hand-made corrections. So it might be pretty creative at moments.

Teaser

Daniele: How can you end your service in a way that doesn't suck?

That's what we talked about with Joe Macleod in an interview for my next book on how to create services that serve both humans and planet. Joe is the expert of endings. He wrote two books about it helped companies like Fairphone implement Beautiful Ends, and he trains the next generation of designers to be endineers: people that are as strong in designing the end than the start.

With Joe, we uncovered 10 early Service Design principles that can help you better design the end of a service.

Here are my five favorites.

Just ask, how does it end?

Show how it will end at the start.

Don't be a dick in the end. Be generous.

Make sure the way it ends is like it started.

Use the end to let people experience your values at last time.

Thank you so much to Joe for this lovely conversation.

## Joe Macleod's Journey and Philosophy

Daniele: hey, it's a pleasure to see you again, Joe.

Joe Macleod: And ju thanks very much for inviting me to talk on this.

Daniele: It's a, it's such a pleasure because we've been working together on, on other projects related to HSLU, which is this design university in Switzerland. But today we're here to speak about other things also related to Service Design and about the work that you do. But before we get into all of that, I have a.

A little starting question for you. When you go in a, in a birthday party, how do you usually present yourself?

Joe Macleod: I usually say like I'm a designer on a very basic level, I might start saying I design a specific part of the consumer experience and I look at endings, and then I talk about my work around that. And, and then people are interested in the course and the training program in the books, and so the conversation often opens up more from there.

Daniele: can you maybe tell us a little bit what is kind of like the big idea around the, these two books and also the courses that come with it?

Joe Macleod: I guess like many things that you go on a journey of investigation and for many years I was making products and starting experiences, so making new things attracting people to that product. Making something innovative that's new and would solve some sort of problem in people's lives.

And that could have been anything from, most of the time it was digital things and after a while I started looking into the end. Of the consumer experience. I first started looking at closure actually as an experience closure experiences, but then expanded that into endings. And then I really got deep into that, looked at the sociological sort of context around that.

And that was the first book, the Ends book, which that came out in 2017. And, that was really eyeopening. And from that foundation of knowledge, I started to build up a sort of a discipline around how to design the end of the consumer experience. And I called it engineering. And second book came out in 2021. And now I've built a business around that and a training program, and people become engineers of which many people from HSLU have become engineers. And yes, that's how this story has started. So it wasn't just a, oh, I think I write an ends book. It was very much a journey of experience that's happened over 15, 20. Or even more years of learning. And now I feel like I, there's something. There is, yeah.

The Importance of Designing Service Endings

Daniele: In the few times we met and in the few talks that they could join from you there was always kind of like one shift that I really appreciated in how you, you explain this, where there is this notion of. We put so much energy in bringing people in a service.

We are very good at selling it, making it look shiny making it seamless, that it, that we get started, you know that's kind of like the whole marketing bit where we are very good at that. And then in Service Design, we're quite good at the maintaining bit, you know, making sure that people, you know, enjoy all parts of it.

And then you ask this question, which I think is a very provocative and good question, which is. What if we put as much energy that we put in the start for marketers and in the service for service designers and service owners for the end, what would happen if the end would have as much love, as much energy, as much passion, then the rest of it?

And I think that was for me, kind of like a, a very interesting bit where as a service designer, I include the end in the work, you know, but. Still as a important bit, but not as, oh, this should have at least as much love and energy as the other parts.

Joe Macleod: Exactly. I think I always find it fascinating how when you go into a business and you. You observe anyone in that business talking about the product that they've created, whether that be a physical service or digital product, and they're incredibly confident of what it is and how it works and how it functions, and anyone can talk with new nuance and confidence about that. To that point is that if you ask them the simple question of how does it end, it's incredible how ignorant, even people who've built the product really see how it ends and when you don't look at the end. In those, just on the very simplest thing it becomes very paralyzing to start creating that ending. And because we have so much catching up work to do in many companies and businesses I find it how quick that move from the end of the consumer usage period to the. The fallout, which isn't really an, a planned ending. It's a capturing of the end by society, the environment, and that's essentially where everything falls.

It turns from, bought this amazing thing to now it's some dimension of plastic that I am as a consumer responsible for, and I've been abandoned from the rest of the experience.

Daniele: thinking about the end of a thing, that I buy a product,

It's very clear why we should care about it because we say, oh, if it ends up in the trash,

Joe Macleod: yes.

Daniele: that's lost, you know, nothing happens.

But why should someone who's creating a service, which is something more intangible also care about that ending because it's, it's something that isn't tangible. So it didn't really exist before. Once it's ending, it doesn't exist anymore too. So why are endings important in that?

Real-World Examples and Insights

Joe Macleod: I think this, let's look at a couple of examples. So from. Point of a membership business, for example, which essentially services like a commun some sort of club or group or, so it is amazing when I look at, when I engage with services like that, that they will look at the solution of the, of somebody, the ending, the experience, not as, let's design a better ending, but let's double down on. Trying to sell more beginnings. And those are two different questions really. So I think we're, when when I go into businesses of all sorts, when I, in fact financial services, when I talk to people in financial services like banks, their perception of the end isn't one of isn't one of a place to do good work and create a. Consumer experience, it's one of fear and blindness and paranoia, and it's then it drives them to not say, let's design a better ending. Let's design a new beginning. And one of the funny things I get when I go into businesses they say, oh yeah, if we have a good ending, then we'll have a good beginning. And I use that as a litmus test because if. If all they see the ending for is a transition from the state of usage to the new beginning, they haven't thought about that at all. And it really gives me a sense of their I and the absence of this discussion. And and I think also. We have this as a problem in a society, a community problem in design because over generations we've got to this place where usage, onboarding, and usage are important. And endings, we are blind to.

Daniele: I like this, this litmus test of saying are we doing an ending so that we can. At people into something else, or are we designing the ending of the proper end? And, and, and I think that's quite an interesting way to see, oh, am I really doing an end here?

Joe Macleod: Exactly. So if you do a, if you create a very good ending. you are building is a longer term relationship and a, a reputation, which is gonna be better for your. product experiences in the future. It's also when you look at the end, you really start to understand what you've missed in other parts of the consumer life cycle.

Because when you start to tie things up, you can see lots of threads that you haven't resolved in a practical way. So data, for example, is a massive problem at endings because we just let it linger. We create very complex databases. And we look at the scenario of them in usage and that we don't create scenarios where consumers can unravel that type of their reputation and their, or their data in those databases and remove it.

Daniele: So by, if, if I get you right by thinking about the end, it's not only just thinking about the end, it makes us realize elements of our service or the experience that. Our design that well because we, we have a hard time ending then.

Joe Macleod: Absolutely. An analogy of that could be writing stories and films or, and any narrative structure. Humans love narrative structures. We've been using them as ways to tell stories and communicate with over generations for thousands of years. And. If you said to anyone about a story, the end of that story brings resolution, meaning and and conclusion to, to the experience that you've had.

But what we've tended to do in consumer experiences is create a status that is in the middle, and you're constantly in this story without resolution. And so if you look at that analogy and think I. If I remove the end of the story, would be the purpose of the other components in the second act or if we have the three act, play first, act, second?

Act, third act. Third act brings resolution and meaning to all of those other things that you've got in the, in previous acts. So when you remove the end and don't think about the end, you actually haven't really thought of it through. What the finality is of those components that you've created for the risks of consumer experience.

Daniele: It feels like you know, these, these films or stories where it ends and you're like. But they opened the thing here with the umbrella.

Joe Macleod: Yeah.

Daniele: And where's your umbrella now? What happened with that thing?

Joe Macleod: The,

Daniele: and, and you're like, oh.

Joe Macleod: it is the continuity problem, isn't it? If you've got so, and you're just at the end, you see so many problems where they haven't thought things through and yeah, it's, it is a massive problem and spending years doing it, you see the problems all over the place and think how did you even get this far? yeah. I think it's also worth co coming back and giving you another couple of examples. In healthcare, for example, which is obviously a massive and a very important service aspect, is that we when we do healthcare, we think about diagnosis. So this person has this problem. We then think about, cure. So we then it engage with that problem and then solve it. And we never really offboard the human from those things. So you'll have lots of situations where people have been tutored in to communicate bad news to a, a patient you have this problem. There's actually a lot of work that goes on around that.

I'd say that's an onboarding experience into this bigger service experience. you have lots of work around, okay, we are going to inform the person about these things that we are gonna do to make them better again. there's lots of work that goes on around that and it's surprising how little work after it's all done and it's solved. How little work there is really around, the goodbye bit, it isn't about, obviously everyone's gonna be pleased about the resolution of their problem and they've solved the problem. But how we say goodbye is a really important thing in the human way as well. A good example of this is a thing called the End of Treatment Bell in and they've been using this in cancer wards for a good couple of decades now, and it was the story I got told of how it got introduced into the UK at least, was this, there's this little girl and she had a pretty severe type of cancer and getting treated in the UK in amongst this other children's ward. of poor kids. And she ends up going to America for some special treatment and she is lying there in this children's ward. And then she sees this kid get up and ring this massive bell at the end of the, at the end of the ward. And she's then absolutely fascinated by this and asks the doctors and nurses what that was. And they say It's the end of treatment Bell. Once you've finished your treatment, you can get up and ring this bell. And she was thought this was really exciting. So she told the, when she went back to the uk, she told the doctors and nurses at her hospital and they installed one and she was the first person to ring it. And the great thing about the end of treatment Bell is that. What's happened over many periods before that is complications if or complicated lots of really difficult situations of having treatment and all of these really difficult things and doubts and concerns. And what is amazing about the end of treatment belt is that how it cuts through everything is be you've been restricted in this very complex system that has loads of processes and you haven't been able to give yourself out and shout about it.

But this is a loud thing. rings around. It is very visual as well because it's very different from everything else and it's has a really good statement about this is the end. And and now there's a charity that puts end of treatment bills in loads of children's wards all around the uk. And I think they have them in lots of countries now because it's such a good conclusion to a very different situation.

I, I think those are really good examples of how endings can have emotional meaning beyond the best carer, other periods and the things that you've got this really powerful, very emotive ending and punctuation.

Daniele: Yeah, I, I really love this aspect of the ending as also kind of like a ritual aspect, you know and, and a transition. Maybe to another part of life.

Joe Macleod: Yeah.

Daniele: so from sick to healthy, from hospital to back home from so there is a lot of emotions, a lot of, of, of rituals in there that help the human.

I'm asking myself, how does that relate to other parts? So there is obviously a, an aspect which is serving the human well. And I know that you're someone who is very interested also in circularity and all of these thoughts. So how and it's quite clear to me that taking care of the end of a product has a lot of value for the emotional.

Side of the human and for the practical side of the planet. But what would be the positive sides of a good service ending for not just the human, but maybe the system in general?

Joe Macleod: I think, yeah, so it is a very human experience. The end of treatment Bill. I think something like membership organizations where they've built all of the other aspects of that experience and haven't really considered what that means to, to say goodbye. And it, it reminds me of a. Somebody who I talked really early on when I was doing endings they had a company, they were a, some sort of media company, so essentially offering a service of doing design or something marketing, I think it was. And one of their big clients announced that they were gonna leave and go to a competitor. and he thought to himself I'm gonna try out this endings thing and see what happens. So he spent loads of time and effort. building the best off boarding experience, pulling all of the resources together, building a great big sort of database for them spent and then giving them a, an amazing presentation and conclusion and farewell party and, so he spent a lot of time doing this, and he is, and they were really impressed by this, even though they were leaving and they didn't have any work off this company. they said goodbye and they thought it was really amazing. Gave this work to a new company, and then a couple of months later, they come back to him with a bigger project than they ever had before. And because they were so impressed with the ending, I think there's a lot to be said about. Doing a good ending isn't about immediate business, but it's about delivering your reputation and your reputation lives on in a different world beyond where you are. And that is true of humans and businesses. But if you are proud enough and confident enough to say goodbye confidently and emotionally coherently and I think generously as well. That, that will come back to you and your business and your benefit and learn from it, and I think it will create me, make you feel more proud as well.

Daniele: It feels like like a good divorce, you know, where, where people obviously have four reasons, you know, to, to separate, but then where, you know, they get to another stage of the relation where, you know, they, if they have kids, you know, they can still function as parents together. Maybe not as, as, as a couple, but then they still function in different ways.

If there is, I love this aspect of generosity. That's a thing that I often hear in, in divorce, you know, where one side maybe said like, I, I wouldn't have had to offer this. But I've made this generous gesture and this brought a resolution of, okay, this person doesn't want me to be in a bad situation. And then that allowed for the relationship to continue in some other way.

That was still beneficial for, for all involved.

Joe Macleod: I think that's a good example. Divorce is a really good example of a lot of this where you see these relationships and I write about that a lot in the first book. Especially around the aspect of religion and how religions frame some of this stuff and make actually a lot of complications around people who have been bonded together in some way.

Marriage and, and can't depart. And when you can't depart, there's there's a lot of evidence that say in the US there's different types of divorces you can have around the world in many progressive countries, and which is a fork divorce or a no fork divorce. So no fork divorce has allowed both partners to come together and say this isn't really working.

We want to divorce. And a fork divorce which happens to be in the uk requires one party to say that they've done something. And in the UK there's five different things that you can say that you've done so they can be, they've been absent. So my mum went through a, she wasn't really married, but in, in a legal sense.

She had property and ownership with somebody. Disappeared for two, three years. And that all then came to her. My father had to say that something was, he took one of those four. So also it damages you as an individual.

Daniele: Mm.

Joe Macleod: haven't done anything bad, but you have to say something wasn't right.

And so they, he said something wasn't right for him. And. So you are immediately into this negative scenario. I, in terms of that future life that you are talking about. Thankfully neither of those examples had kids. But if you've immediately gone to a ground of somebody's to blame, then that isn't a good foundation for a future relationship. So then you go to countries that have, no fault divorces and couples can get a, have a divorce and be a lot more confident in in having a future together, and working on things together, whether that be kids or equity or whatever. so in the US there's states that have divorce against states that have no fault divorce.

And in the no fault in the fault divorce states. There's a higher incidence of domestic violence, murder of partners and so there's this incredible, tangible evidence of how divorces need to be matured into an a nofor divorce situation.

Daniele: And how would you. Say we could create some no fault divorces in services. What makes it that an ending feels like an a place where it's not about the blaming, it's not about,

Joe Macleod: Yeah.

Daniele: that element, but more about, okay, this is not working. It's okay. Let's move on.

Practical Steps for Designing Endings

Joe Macleod: So in all of the work I do I try and think about providing models and techniques that can be applied to physical, digital service sectors

Daniele: Yeah.

Joe Macleod: in consumer experiences. That's where I work. But I think that everyone, as a business, you've got to ask that first question is how does it end?

Daniele: Mm-hmm.

Joe Macleod: that's super practical and it's super. Accessible for anyone to ask. And once you start looking at how does it end, then you start seeing in a crude boring way, what's your local legislation for disposing of your product in a physical sense. What are the laws around data in? There's some really boring background stuff, but it

Daniele: Hmm.

Joe Macleod: understand. Where that sort of starts to emerge in the foreground, then it's worth doing like some just very practical stuff of going through the offboarding experience of your products. So what happens when, and then trying to work that out yourself. But then doing the practical research of asking people, real people, like what it was like to leave our business. And it's not a matter of. We can certainly say okay we'll ask some questions on the way out. Would they recommend us to a friend? a really very shallow version of what really goes on. So we've got to get deeper than that. You've got to ask more than would you recommend our business? And and once you start digging into that, then you can start to see the real problem space and that emotional experience of people offboarding and. Once you've got to bear, you've now started to really dig into the problem and to find tangible information of what it means for your business and your customers leaving. And then you can start to look at some models of how to improve that. Because up until then it's you hardly have even conversations around it. So you've gotta ask how does it end first?

Daniele: Hmm.

Joe Macleod: And then applying those models that I've created in the, for example, one of them is about. Types of endings. So

Daniele: Mm-hmm.

Joe Macleod: timeout, ending a product a credit out ending task, event completion ending, those eight types of endings are worth looking at because they help you narrow down what are we talking about and how can we like dig into this with more insight.

So there's lots of those in the engineering book.

Daniele: Yeah. So a first step is asking how does it end? Then maybe looking at is, is one of these eight types the type that would make most sense for, for our service? What, what else do you have in, in, in, in the world of, you know. You, you said it's very practical when it comes to endings, obviously. Do you have any other practical insights?

You said, Hey, it's also good to look at what are the laws and legislations, because usually there is stuff in there that's quite clear on what you should do, but maybe you didn't know.

Joe Macleod: Another enormous dimension of it is how much effort it's gonna be to deliver. So

Daniele: Hmm.

Joe Macleod: talking about a physical product company, the reverse logistics of getting that product back and delivering that project product to your dis or your dismantling center or your waste center. That's an incredible ask.

And so there's a lot of work to be done there where that's arguably, if you are building the offboarding experience to an app that has no other responsibilities, then what you're doing is tidying up a data background. So you are asking the consumer to understand the. again, depending on your region the legislation around data deletion, how long that's gonna last.

Often I think for, Europe now it's two years. You can hold onto it, but you could also build it into, really delete it at that time and what does the consumer want? And I think there's a real, also a responsibility, especially in the data world of, teaching as well. There is such a lot of complicated stuff around the the longing and the ownership of data, which most consumers are really ignorant about, and I think there's a. And should be a pride if you've offered a good product earlier on that if someone's leaving, you need to inform them about the, their risks and their responsibilities and the local legislation and your responsibilities as a provider as well.

Daniele: I, I, I really appreciate this aspect of. And it comes back to one of the ideas that you said before, but this. Once you think about how does it end, then suddenly you realize, oh, maybe we should change how we do things so that it's easier to make them end. And so maybe you even say, we might stop doing a few things so that it's easier to do the end.

For example, you might say. And if we don't collect that piece of data that we don't really use, but we thought it's good because, you know, we always have this idea of more data might be useful sometime. And then suddenly we are in a situation we're saying if we don't collect that piece of data, we don't have to, to dispose of it at the end.

So that makes our work a little bit easier.

Joe Macleod: One of the aspects I do workshops around is

Daniele: Mm-hmm.

Joe Macleod: ends onboarding because actually we tell consumers a lot about we don't tell consumers a lot about the end of the onboarding yet. Those are important aspects to consider if you are. Daniele Pink, the sales guru says this really good phrase, if you're trying to make a sale, it's a lot easier for the customer to take the on ramp when they can see the off ramp. And actually, so when customers to sign up for things and 'cause they've been stung so much in the past. Once they sign up for things, they want to see the end of that on how do I get out of this contract? How do I get out of this relationship? And actually, it's surprising how little we do that in a lot of fields. Another aspect of Enza onboarding, if you think about the over the last sort of. 20, 30 years in terms of food products in certain regions, giving traffic light scheme things for this has got lots of salt, this has got lots of sugar, this has got lots of calories. That really helps people. So we do good work in other aspects of consumerism around, indicating the end. when I come to businesses and they wanna design endings. One of the biggest failings that they've done in the past is that they haven't talked about the end at all. the end then comes as a surprise for the consumer. And so if you are. As a business aware of how it ends in your particular customer offering. If you design for that at the end, but also acknowledge that in throughout the rest of the consumer lifecycle, you're gonna have such a better product in terms of being holistic and mindful and and especially when it comes to the end, it'll be so much more smoother.

Daniele: Absolutely. The, the, this reminds me of of a thing that many Christian communities do where, where they have, at the start, when you commit to membership in a community, they quite clearly say, okay, this is a commitment for so much time, and then we'll review if it's still something that you feel makes sense for you.

And, and in the places where I've seen this work and be implemented, you see really a big difference between places that have that and places that don't have that. Places that have, that have members who are committed. Where we say, I'm here because I chose to be here and I had the chance to escape it.

And then there was other communities where people are like a bit. Yeah, I'm coming because, you know, it's tradition and because I have to, and and I thought about, about leaving, but you know, it's kind of hard to have that conversation with someone saying, you know, I've been here for 20 years, and what will happen to my friends?

You know, maybe I will lose friends if I leave. And we're giving the opportunity for a possible ending again and again and again, suddenly. Makes it clear that it's not gonna be something that you, we will shame you on. It's not gonna be something that you will lose rights and access. It's just that it's natural to think about that.

But it gives also the opportunity to the service owner to say, I think you're not a good fit. Which is also an interesting bit. Whereas it gives the opportunity to both sides to recommit to the relationship.

Joe Macleod: Absolutely. I think it's really interesting in sales where we do a lot of allowing people into a certain. Region of the product offering, and then you can try this out for a period of time. And I always find it interesting, those boundaries are essentially endings that, what types of boundaries do they put up to offer in a, customer to give them a free version of it for X amount of time.

So these can be a periodic thing. So you get it for one month. a tangible ending. This is, you've got access to this for one month. You can have it in terms of access to features. So you've only got access to these features. If you want to go further, then you are gonna have to sign up for the bigger one.

And there, there's lots of stuff where we've really played around with some of those things of. Of endings at the beginning and as a market employee to encourage and move people forward. And as you say, the in a similar sense, it's if I have to, if I've got no other option than signing up for a hundred quid a year and then I find out actually this really isn't what I thought it was gonna be, I'm gonna be as soon as I can trying to get out of that. And I had a thing which was, there's a piece of accountancy software they just had such poor thinking around, or they had such poor customer thinking and you could feel the, aggression of the sales team saying, we've got to do this one and we've got to, we sold it there and we want to sell it.

No, they can't get out. And it's such a old school 1950s way of looking at the world. So I think a good way of looking at the world, especially in the last sort of. 10, 20 years say that we've digitized so much of our customer lifecycle on many, whether it be digital or service sector stuff.

We've digitized so much of that. So I don't have to speak to a human being at all. When I'm looking at a product, I look at reviews online, they're impartial by members of the public. at what the features might offer, so I have incredible knowledge that I'm doing at my own pace. And then I start to make a value judgment about do I want to get this product?

And then I sign up for it on the website. And I'm a member of that business, that product, et cetera. And then I use that product. I never speak to a human at all. So this whole system has been digitized. And everything about it's digital, whether it be on the desktop or the app. And then all of a sudden when I wanna leave, we turn into the 18th century. We start to use a phone that was created in like late 78, 18, early 18th early 19th century rather. And and we start to use human beings again. And we ha And then all of a sudden this sales tactics from the 1950s emerge alongside it. Which what we should be doing is digitizing the end of the customer experience as we have done the rest of the consumer lifecycle. And then all of those people in the call center. Don't need to have those horrible conversations with people to try and sell 'em another month or six months of a service they can get on with building and making the rest of the service a good product. So we, we have terrible perception of the end as being a place where we should go back to the previous century.

Daniele: We could even say we could do it in the opposite way. You know where, where if it's something that is a very luxurious experience of pure human concierge onboarding, to say the end should have the same flavor and shouldn't be just one. Tap button exit thing where it'll feel at odds with, Hey, your whole experience is very tailored.

Soft human made. Then I expect the end to also be it. But if the onboarding was very digital, one click get in, then I expect the same one. Click get out. Thing.

Joe Macleod: So look at on the brand level, if you said to a company tell us how you do this and what we start with our brand and we do this through our brand principles and we deliver it through this color palette and this way, and that goes on for everything around the company, whether that be entering the office or their website or their branded business vans or whatever. But when it comes to the end, so many of them just adopt a let's try not to let anyone leave type of mindset. So brand principles that are, they're proud of at the beginning of the customer life cycle. For example, a cliche would be we are transparent and we're honest. The, these. to be not recognized at the end of the customer lifecycle. So they end up being not transparent, not honest, trying to avoid you leaving. So we should be looking at the end as a place to be brand first as well. Be honest. Companies say brave and which they should be more brave about the end and generous like we talked about earlier as well, that these people. People leave your product for two reasons. Either they don't like your product for a number of reasons or external factors. And when businesses think about the end, they think we've got to trap them here, and that is, that solution has. Neither answers the external factors thing or are products not good for them. so you, you end up with this terrible scenario where customers leave and they won't go back to businesses and businesses go on and try and find another customer.

Final Thoughts and Farewell

Daniele: I'd like to to switch gears for the few last minutes we have with, what's something unexpected? Weird funny, you know, that you learned about endings. Do you have a story or anything where you say, oh, this is really something that most people, think A, but in fact it's B or something that you say, oh wow, this is really special about the way we, they should think about ending, or an example that you say, oh, this is very inspiring because it's, it's just another way to do it.

Joe Macleod: Oh, one thing I did think when I was researching the first book, I was doing stuff on credit cards and because of the changes of payment periods. And so I was looking at that and reading the history of Diners Club. In fact, maybe I'll do too. So I'll do this one. The history of Diners Club card. And the people who got that together, they literally started it by just saying, I want a credit line at these at for having lunch. And they were doing this in New York. And ever since in the credit card industry, that meal that they had, the first one with the Diners Club card was called the First Supper. And I thought that was a really funny little bit of consumer history. Another one, which I think is I find really terrifying and is how long ago Coca-Cola introduced two liter plastic bottles into the, and it was like 1973. They had a big press conference in, in, again, actually in New York. Big press conference. Loads of people come. They do a q and a and tell everyone about this incredible product that they've created. And they promised they're gonna roll this out. And they're, because it's recyclable, they're gonna create all of these recycling centers around the world. Wherever they distribute products, they're gonna create recycling centers. of course when we, now, I find it quite frustrating when we talk about plastics in the sea. Instead of talking about the offboarding experience, we talk about the material capability of the thing. And this is, I think one of the fundamental mistakes that we have in sustainability or around the, that problem space of pollution is that we talk about material capability. No, customers are really interested in that. That's a different conversation it really stems, I think back to a conversation that was happened when they launched recyclable plastic balls. That the material doesn't really matter. It's the capture that matters. And the capture is everything to do with the consumer off boarding experience. And the more we have conversations about. The capturing method, not the, and the consumer experience and not the material experience, I think we'd get a lot further and it frustrates me when I see so many novel new materials coming out when it doesn't really matter. We don't capture the most recyclable plastic bottle that's been around forever.

It won't matter if you make a new material. Because we won't capture it anyway. We just dump it in the sea like the rest of it, the capture is where we need to work.

Daniele: Absolutely. And so if people are, are, are curious for becoming an engineer what's. The first tiny step he recommend for the ones that are just saying, I just want to dip my toes into it. And what's the, the, the recommendation that you will give for people who say, oh, I want to jump in the water and learn to swim right now?

Joe Macleod: really good way of putting it, I think. If you just wanna dip your toes in the water you can visit the website and n.co. I think also at work, just ask the question, how does it end? In fact, ask that question in a product development meeting 'cause everyone finds it really annoying and no one will have an answer.

And that'll be even funnier for your product, your day at work. you really wanna dig into it, then I very much suggest you start with the ends book. It's where I started and that is my journey as well. To start asking that question about why we don't do endings in consumerism. And the story really goes back, many centuries and it's I find it a fascinating story and it changed my mindset then really engage in this subject matter.

And thereafter, I hope you come along with a journey and do the second book, and then become an engineer and get in touch.

Daniele: it's always lovely to learn from you each time. You know, you are at HSLU or, or I see some of your work online. It's always a, a big pleasure, you know, and and over the years it has, it has really slowly but surely changed the way I perceive ends.

And I'm really thankful to you for that. I'm also thankful. Because, you're taking time some very precious time to help me in the research for, for this tiny upcoming book that I'm writing at the moment. And I really, really appreciate it. As I told you before we were recording this you always have this amazing quality of the simplicity of how we can, make things happen with you is something that I've always been impressed. You're not just a master of how to make things end but also on how to get really relationships started. So that's a thing that I deeply appreciate.

Joe Macleod: Thanks very much Daniele. It's wonderful. It's been wonderful getting interviewed by you. You have a lovely manner in your interview style.

Daniele: Really appreciate it. Hey, thank you so much and wish you a lovely rest of the summer.

Joe Macleod: Thank you very much. See you later.

Project Management

How can you launch a sustainability project within a big organization?

Michel Sterckx — Switzerland

A photo of Michel Sterckx

Early principles uncovered

In this conversation, we uncovered 12 early drafts of Service Design Principles:

  1. This is just another project: Sustainability and Service Design is a project like any other: use your past project management experience

  2. Give the tools to people to self assess: use an eco-bilan that can be done on multiple sites

  3. Separate the organizational layers: organizational, site and individual and give the right power at each level (individual has power on what)

  4. Use the change culture that already was there: look how big change happened before

  5. Look for the smart ones who already know:
    find the people who already are motivated and did some stuff

  6. Look for those who act: Seek less those who say "this is what needs to be done," and rather look for people who say "this is what we're doing!"

  7. Adapt to the different speeds: Accept that there are people further on the process and don’t make them come back: instead make them share their expertise. 

  8. Mix top down and bottom up based on the different entities and departments

  9. Show the people who already do the work: so that others see change is possible in their context

  10. Make people exchange what works for them instead of you sharing how it should be done

  11. Get a partner to help you: if your organization is large but has a focused service or product portfolio get help from an external partner 

  12. Give multiple projects to decision makers: so that they can pick and choose instead of making it all a big thing that can be refused in one big block

The main visualisation

During our conversation Michel shared one of the slides he uses to show the focus of the project to stakeholders.

About the human

Michel Sterckx is a coach, supervisor, and Project Portfolio Manager at the Salvation Army in Switzerland, Austria, and Hungary. With over 30 years of experience in this organization, he has held various roles — from music director to marketing manager in an institution, before specializing in the management of strategic and cross-cutting projects, particularly in the areas of organizational development and ecology.

Alongside his activities at the Salvation Army, Michel is a BSO-certified coach. He provides individual coaching for people in their professional or personal journeys.

The full conversation (in French)

This transcript was automatically generated using Descript without any hand-made corrections. So it might be pretty creative at moments.

Introduction

Comment est-ce que tu peux faire avancer un projet d'écologie dans une grande organisation complexe? Comment est-ce que tu peux lancer un tel projet après plusieurs essais ratés et des années où peu de chose bougent? Comment est-ce que tu peux créer un cadre dans lequel l'écologie n'est pas un paquebot immense et impossible à faire avancer?

J'ai causé de tout ça avec Michel Sterckx, coach, chef de projet et responsable d'un projet écologie. Cette conversation fait partie d'une série d'interviews pour mon prochain livre: Principe de service design 401 à 500 qui explorent comment on peut créer des services qui servent à la fois les humains et la planète qui les héberge.

Michel Sterckx est coach superviseur et project portfolio manager au sein de l'Armée du Salut Suisse, Autriche et Hongrie. Avec plus de 30 ans d'expérience dans cette organisation, il a occupé des rôles très variés de directeur musical à responsable marketing dans une institution avant de se spécialiser dans la gestion de projets stratégiques et transversaux, notamment dans le domaine du développement organisationnel et de l'écologie.

En parallèle de ces activités à l'Armée du Salut. Michel est aussi un coach certifié BSO. Il accompagne des personnes dans leur parcours professionnel et personnel.

Dans cette conversation, Michel a levé le rideau sur son approche très concrète pour faire bouger les choses dans une grande organisation diverse et plutôt complexe.

La conversation a été super riche. Mais si je devais mentionner que quatre choses super inspirantes voilà ce que je mentionnerais:

La première idée:

Décomposer la complexité.

Que ça soit en décomposant un sujet immense et le casser en petit morceaux ou en décomposant les niveaux d'action avec trois niveaux, organisation, site et individus.

La deuxième idée: Clarifier pour soi-même.

Prendre le temps de savoir exactement de quoi on parle pour soi-même d'abord, avant de pouvoir convaincre les autres.

Idée numéro trois:

Aller chercher les savoirs là où ils sont déjà.

Repérer les personnes qui font quelque chose à l'intérieur de l'organisation, s'en inspirer et les impliquer.

Idée numéro quatre:

Assurer la direction en laissant chacun avancer à son rythme.

Le rôle du chef de projet, c'est de garder le cap et de veiller à ce que les choses bougent. Certains avancent à la vitesse de la marche, d'autres courent et d'autres prennent même une fusée.

Un immense merci à Michel pour sa transparence et cette conversation super pragmatique et inspirante.

Et mais ça me fait super plaisir, Michel, de t'avoir ici aujourd'hui . Ça me fait plaisir de, un, de te voir, et puis de, deux, de pouvoir faire ça en français avec toi aujourd'hui. Et le plaisir est de mon côté aussi.

Rencontrer Michel

Nous, ça fait quelques années qu'on se connaît déjà, mais pour ceux qui ne te connaissent pas, comment tu te présentes quand tu vas à une fête d'anniversaire ?

Quand je vais à une fête d'anniversaire, je dis surtout que je suis coach, parce que c'est un peu mon coeur qui, qui y est.

Je suis un coach indépendant partiellement, mais je travaille surtout pour l'Armée du Salut, qui est une grande organisation, une vaste organisation, et au sein de cette, cette organisation, je fais le développement organisationnel, donc les gros projets, stratégies, etc. Les gros projets d'Armée du Salut qui vont un peu au-delà d'un département ou d'un, d'une branche, c'est des projets qui, qui viennent, qui passent dans nos bureaux et puis le projet écologie, effectivement, a passé dans nos bureaux et c'est, j'en suis le responsable pour l'instant, voilà, c'est ça.

Et pour te dire que, en fait, c'est déjà le lancement du projet après quelques années, donc c'était un peu comme un cycle, il y a, je pense qu'il y a 15 ans, il y a l'idée des, une idée qui est ressortie, donc plutôt la durabilité est un sujet, les finances ont parlé, les immobiliers en ont parlé. Il a fallu quelques années, il a fallu quelques années pour relancer le truc.

Puis finalement, je pense, le troisième, le troisième lancement était le bon. Donc voilà, là, maintenant, on a, on est dans une réalisation, dans une phase de réalisation du projet écologie pour l'armée du salut en Suisse.

## Approche de gestion de projet

Là, je pense qu'il y a déjà une leçon qui est hyper intéressante pour tous nos collègues qui travaillent dans des grosses organisations.

Je vois déjà un truc de, Ça vaut la peine de commencer une fois, sachant que ça va peut-être pas marcher la première fois, va falloir relancer un truc. Toi, ça serait quoi les leçons que t'as apprises dans le fait de, d'avoir plusieurs moments où vous alliez commencer un truc et après vous avez fait, ah non, c'est pas le bon moment.

C'est un peu quoi les leçons que t'as retirées de ça? Bon, il y a deux choses. Dans la gestion de projet, il faut toujours que ce soit le bon projet, donc un projet de bonne qualité au bon moment. Il faut les deux. Tu peux avoir un super projet au mauvais moment, ça va pas aller, ou tu peux avoir au bon moment un mauvais projet, ça va pas marcher.

Donc c'est toujours, um, une bonne mise en question quand t'as une direction ou des chefs qui disent, um, on n'est pas très sûr.

Un projet clair est un bon projet

Voilà, donc voilà, c'est vrai qu'il faut de la patience, il faut trouver le bon moment, et il faut, il faut créer, il faut créer un projet Ça veut dire aussi ou surtout que ce soit un projet qui soit clair.

Il faut un projet clair, um, avec un bon cadre pour que le décideur puisse dire, oui, là, on est d'accord, d'y aller. Et je crois que la clarté ou le cadre est très, quelque chose de très important et peut-être que les deux premières fois, on n'a pas réussi à clarifier la chose ou ça allait dans tous les sens.

Je crois qu'un sujet important, Ce qui est important c'est le fait, on parle de durabilité, durabilité c'est tout, c'est l'écologie, c'est l'économie, c'est le domaine social, etc. Et le fait de parler de durabilité, ça n'a pas, ça n'a pas crochet. Et puis c'est vrai parce qu'on est, on essaie d'être durable tout le temps, mais le moment où on a cassé la durabilité, puis on a dit, on parle seulement d'écologie, qui est une des trois parties de la durabilité.

Là, il y a eu un certain cadre qui a été assez, qui a été reconnu, voilà. Et le reste, c'est comme la politique. Il faut de la patience. Il faut, il faut, il faut de l'endurance. Il faut, il faut aussi trouver le bon moment.

Là, tu me dis. Je comprends bien, il y avait un peu un côté de le, c'était peut-être le bon moment, mais la formulation du projet pouvait être assez grande et pouvait faire un petit peu, ouh là là, c'est une grosse, c'est un gros bateau, puis avec un focus un peu plus, plus clair, tout d'un coup, ça a fait, ah, ça, c'est, c'est gérable.

Absolument, absolument. Et aussi question des coûts, etc. Donc, le fait de, de, de voir un peu jusqu'où ça va aller, de voir un peu le cadre a été, je pense, l'atout principal pour un oui de la direction de l'arbitre du salaire.

Comment créer un bon cadre

Ce cadre là toi tu le crées comment pour, est-ce que tu le teste à l'avance ? Ou tu vas dire ah en backstage je vais parler avec les gens, je vais tester un peu mon cadre.

Tu fais comment pour trouver ce cadre où tu te dis ça pousse suffisamment le projet pour que ça soit intéressant, et en même temps c'est suffisamment, euh, clair et focus pour que ça crée pas un sentiment de... Ou ça va être un autre gros, euh, machin, euh, qui va nous prendre douze, douze mille années. Alors moi, personnellement, je passe beaucoup de temps à réfléchir, à, à, à acquérir une clarté pour moi.

Donc je veux savoir de quoi on parle. Je vais les mettre dans des petits box, box, la caisse A, la caisse 2, etc. Je vais le séparer, je vais le remettre en même temps et je vais le dessiner, je vais visualiser quels sont les critères, quels sont les atouts, quels sont les domaines qui sont compris. Et puis je vais essayer de présenter, comment dire, un carton comprimé avec une bonne, voilà, un bon cadre.

Donc c'est un travail que je fais personnellement, je fais de la recherche, je regarde un peu quels sont les autres projets. Je fais un peu du best practice, mais je dois, moi, être au clair, ça c'est mon objectif et ça c'est là où on va travailler et en même temps dire, ça, ça ne me regarde pas directement, c'est pas dans mon projet, sinon j'arrive pas à avancer.

La faisabilité est toujours quelque chose de très important pour moi. Il y a cette belle phrase du poète qui disait, ce qui se conçoit bien s'énonce clairement et les mots pour le dire viennent aisément. Il y a un peu ce truc de. Si déjà c'est très clair dans ta tête, parce que t'as, t'as investi vraiment du travail là-dessus, après t'as plus de chances de pouvoir en faire un truc qui est vraiment clair pour l'autre.

Donc le fait d'investir dans ce temps de clarification personnelle, ça c'est vraiment une clé pour toi. Absolument, et je, je suis pas très sûr, mais je pense, mon hypothèse c'est que le, le décideur va, va, aura plus confiance. en moi et mon, ma, ma façon de faire, que si ça va dans tous les sens. Le, le décideur doit me comprendre moi, pour que, pour, pour dire oui à un projet.

Donc c'est un peu ma, ouais. Moi j'ai besoin de carter, et quand c'est un tout gros projet, je le casse en mille morceaux. Et puis j'ai choisi les cinq morceaux qui sont faisables. C'est bien cette idée de casser en mille morceaux, et puis après de reprendre quelques morceaux. Hmm. C'est très fort ça. Oui et puis en même temps ça prend du temps je crois, j'ai, j'ai, j'ai, j'ai, j'ai...

Je pense que j'ai passé quelques semaines à voir un peu de quoi on parle en fait. Et puis je pense que je vais en parler aussi parce que dans l'écologie il y a plusieurs stratégies, il y a l'écologie dans plusieurs niveaux, donc dans l'organisationnel, local, l'individu qui est concerné, donc il y a, c'est vraiment, c'est une matrice qui a, qui a plein de, il y a plein de, d'aspects qui sont importants à, à pouvoir, pas séparer, mais de les voir en structure.

Tu disais, il y a cette question de... Pour pouvoir avoir un projet d'écologie qui avance bien, c'est comme n'importe quel projet, bonne qualité de projet, donc bonne clarté, bon focus, et bon moment. Est-ce que, comment on crée le bon moment ? On peut faire ça

En tout cas pour le projet écologie c'était le bon moment parce que c'est, c'est un sujet, c'est un trend, un immense trend, un des cinq grands trends de notre futur, donc la société est concernée, donc l'église ne peut pas juste passer à côté, voilà, ça c'est une chose, la deuxième chose c'est que les membres du décideur ont quand même une certaine affinité pour le sujet, c'est-à-dire qu'il y a une certaine affinité pour le sujet, c'est-à-dire qu'il y a une certaine affinité pour le sujet, Au-delà de, c'est pas, c'est pas, c'est pas une offre principale de l'armée du salut, mais en même temps, ça passe un peu partout.

Ça, ça peut-être, euh. Ouais, ça a une influence sur tous les processus, donc, c'était le bon moment parce qu'il y a une certaine, euh, les gens sont attentifs au sujet, il y a une certaine pression, il y a, euh, le futur dépend de nous, enfin, enfin, il y a, il y a plusieurs, plusieurs éléments, je pense pas que, si tu veux, si tu poses la question, est-ce que j'ai fait du lobbying, je crois pas, pas cette fois.

Pas cette fois. J'étais peut-être un peu à l'écoute en partageant ou en parlant de l'écologie, mais j'ai pas essayé de, de, d'influencer les personnes de la direction. Pas cette fois, non. J'étais vraiment plutôt avec, avec ma, mes, ma présentation, le, euh, j'ai, ouais. Quelque part, c'est de toute façon le bon moment.

Sur ce sujet-là, c'est assez facile de dire que c'est le bon moment. C'était assez facile de dire que c'est pas seulement le bon moment, c'est, euh, euh, comment dire, c'est, c'est, c'est, c'est, c'est midi et quart, c'est pas midi moins quart, tu vois, c'est un peu ça l'image, euh, et je crois que tout le monde le ressent.

J'avais fait quelques interviews il y a environ dix, dix ans ou douze ans. Et là j'ai demandé les pasteurs, mais l'écologie, qu'elles sont, et puis là j'ai quand même eu quelques réponses qui me disaient « Mais pour nous c'est pas, c'est pas notre boulot, c'est pas important pour nous, on a d'autres choses à faire, enfin, dans le bon sens.

Et ces réponses-là, on ne les a plus à l'Armée du Salut. Peut-être ici et là, mais c'est pas, je ressens quand même, étant membre de l'Armée du Salut en même temps, je ressens que la, la, quelque chose a changé pendant ces dix ans passés. Ok, c'est vrai, c'est devenu le bon moment, le temps a fait son oeuvre.

Oui, et puis je veux aussi dire qu'il y a des sites ou des unités, ils sont déjà beaucoup plus loin ici, ils parlent de l'écologie, ils agissent déjà écologiquement, déjà depuis des années, donc ils sont à l'avance du projet, absolument, ouais.

Visualiser un projet et son cadre

Du coup, je sais que t'es un mec très visuel, est-ce que t'arrives un peu à nous donner une image, enfin me donner un peu une image de, il y a ce grand projet, il ressemble à quoi ce grand projet, vous faites quoi dans ce grand projet

voilà, c'est un peu ma, ma, ma land crowd, tu vois, tu vois la, le, le tout. La cartographie. Donc on a commencé avec la durabilité et là, c'était trop gros. Donc personne, la direction n'a pas, on n'a pas vu un domaine d'action, un champ d'action pour aller dans la durabilité parce que c'est la durabilité, c'est tout, c'est tout, voilà.

Et dans la durabilité, il y a ces trois domaines, donc il y a l'écologie à gauche, la science à droite. Société sociale et l'économie, donc là, déjà, j'ai fait une séparation et dans l'écologie, j'ai descendu, je suis descendu, là, on a, j'ai regardé un peu quels sont les sujets, donc il y a la mobilité, production, consommation, consommage, vie quotidienne, bâtiment, donc là, on a défini de quoi on parle, en fait, dans l'écologie, on a créé certaines définitions pour pouvoir les utiliser quand on parle avec les choses, c'est aussi l'idée de la, De la communication et ensuite on voit à gauche de ce carré le comportement donc les actions possibles ou les stratégies possibles à droite et en bas il y a comme toujours le top down ou le bottom up ou voilà est-ce qu'on, on récompense les gens ou est-ce qu'on les punit s'ils ne font pas enfin toutes ces stratégies je les ai mis sur un slide pour voir un peu mais on est où et quelles sont nos possibilités et une autre chose c'était les.

Les Sustainability Goals, les objectifs de développement durable, ici en haut à droite, qui sont internationales, donc là, on a, j'ai réussi à dire, mais écoutez, on n'est pas les seuls, tout le monde le fait, enfin, j'ai créé le lien avec ça, donc voilà, j'ai dessiné un peu tout, tout le projet en un slide pour pouvoir, pour savoir dire, écoutez, on parle d'écologie, c'est la démocratie sur l'école des réserves.

Et on est aussi des personnes qui travaillent de l'interne dans l'outil, qui sont des groupes qui travaillent de l'interne sur les réseaux. L'écologie pour nous, c'est mobilité, production, etc. Et puis ensuite, de là, on a sorti un peu quelles sont les stratégies qu'on va utiliser dans notre projet. Je peux déjà te dire, c'est que le top-down, on a laissé de côté.

Donc, on a, on ne va pas faire du top-down. On ne va pas, on a essayé, mais on ne va pas changer les règlements, etc. Donc, voilà, j'ai créé un peu cette, euh. l'entraide et puis pour pouvoir aussi expliquer un peu et présenter ça, présenter ce projet.

Approche bottom-up

Là, tu m'as tout de suite titillé, pourquoi pas du top-down?

Ça, c'est une expérience qu'on fait, c'est un savoir-faire. L'armée du salut, dans l'armée du salut, pour l'instant, c'est très, très difficile de faire du top-down. Donc, l'armée du salut, qui est une armée hiérarchique, à beaucoup de peines.

À obliger ou à mener tout le monde, tous ses membres, tous ses sites, tous ses employés à faire quelque chose. Donc voilà, c'est un peu comme un, un peu un marché, l'Armée du Seigneur c'est un peu comme un marché. Et là, je savais à l'avance, ou bien je pense que la direction aussi a accepté de dire On va pas réussir à faire du top-down.

En principe, je vais parler un peu plus des projets partiels, mais là, le principe c'était pas du top-down. Et c'est un peu le, j'utilise ça aussi pour communiquer avec les sites, donc à la commission interne, je dis écoutez, on va pas vous obliger à faire quoi que ce soit. C'est à vous de choisir ou de décider des mesures à prendre.

Ça c'est une stratégie qu'on a choisie pour ce projet. Donc tu donnes plus de liberté, tu viens pas tout de suite en attention nous sommes les méchants qui vous disent quoi faire, mais plutôt voilà un catalogue de choses. Que vous pourriez faire, choisissez ce qui fait sens pour vous.

Avant tu as demandé pourquoi on l'a fait comme ça, je crois que, je, l'a, je crois qu'on n'avait pas le choix en fait. Hum, intéressant. Avancer ce projet, ou mettre ce projet, réaliser un projet d'écologie, on est obligé de le faire du bottom up. Je pense que c'est pour l'âme et du salut, c'est juste, mais je serais peut-être proche de dire que mon hypothèse, c'est que l'écologie, c'est du bottom-up.

Mais je ne suis pas très sûr de ça, donc voilà. En tout cas, dans cette organisation-là, pour te changer les choses. Dans cette organisation, changer les choses, ça vient du bottom-up, ouais. Ah, puis j'aime bien le fait de dire, mais... Dans les projets précédents, on a appris que ce genre d'approche pour créer du changement fonctionne.

Donc on va fonctionner plutôt de ces manières-là, et puis on va s'apprendre des mécanismes qui fonctionnent déjà. Plutôt que de dire, on va, on va aller avec, à la vitesse, en essayant un truc qu'on n'est pas vraiment sûr qui va marcher. Oui, et c'est peut-être aussi le fait que les sites de l'Armée du Salut sont tellement différents les uns des autres, on ne va pas faire la même écologie, en fait.

Hum. On n'aura tous, on n'aura pas tous, on pourra pas tous avoir la même approche. écologique, que comme dans une, um, oh, dans une banque où toutes les, toutes les cellules sont exactement, ont exactement le même processus. Déjà en ce qui concerne les stakeholders, c'est tellement différent, de, voilà, une église à Genève est complètement différente qu'une église à Tremblant, par exemple.

Donc là, il y a déjà deux situations différentes. Et du coup, ils ressemblent à quoi, vos, vos projets ?

Sous projets

Parce que là, tu m'as dit, ça c'est un peu le... Le gros bateau, c'est un peu ta grande carte, puis que dans ça, si j'ai bien compris, il y a un peu des sous-projets que vous faites ? Absolument. On a, on a choisi 4 sous-projets.

Et ça aussi, c'était ma stratégie de proposer des sous-projets à la direction pour que la direction puisse dire, euh, oui, oui, oui, non. Tu vois, qu'il y a plusieurs projets, donc. Un projet important, c'est les, les immobiliers. C'est le projet le plus important, le projet qui aura le plus d'impact, c'est les immobiliers de l'armée du salut, donc l'unité des immobiliers ont un objectif stratégique qui est zéro, comment on dit, zéro carbone, en français on dit ça comme ça, et ça c'est une partie de mon projet, donc l'unité des immobiliers, ils vont revoir tous les immobiliers, et On va faire une rating list et puis investir dans l'écologie.

Donc, revoir les façades, refaire les façades, changer les chauffages, etc. Donc, ils vont créer leur liste et puis ils vont commencer à travailler avec les immobiliers. Donc, ils auront une liste d'immobiliers où c'est vraiment important d'un point de vue écologie. Donc là ils vont, là, c'est un projet partiel.

Là je laisse faire les immobiliers parce que c'est eux les experts, ils vont justement faire son rating list. Ils vont aussi créer des standards de construction, mais aussi de rénovation, des standards de, uh, uh, uh, reprise d'immobilier, etc. Parce que l'armée du salut reçoit de temps en temps des immobiliers.

Et ces standards, sont, doivent, ou sont également écologiques, pas seulement économiques. Et ça, je trouve intéressant. Eux, ils avancent comme ça. Ensuite, la deuxième, le deuxième projet partiel, c'est un projet éco-bilan. Donc, on a créé, je dois dire d'abord que l'Armée du Salut ne voulait pas travailler avec un partenaire pour toute l'organisation.

Parce que une brocante est complètement quelque chose de différent qu'une, qu'une église de l'armée du salut, qu'une grande institution, une petite institution, etc. Donc là, la direction, ça, je savais à l'avance, ne voulait pas créer un footprint pour toute l'armée du salut. Ça, c'était une question qui était un peu présente.

Mais là, l'armée, euh, là, euh, Ce que le décideur a dit c'est que ça ne va pas. Donc, ce qu'on a créé, c'est, um, um, um, um, um, un éco-bilan assez simple, rapide à faire. Qui permet aux sites de remplir un questionnaire et d'avoir comme un spider qui leur dit dans ces domaines-là On est plutôt bon, et dans cet domaine là, on est plutôt moins bon que la moyenne, enfin, ça c'est un peu une autre question.

Voilà, ça donne la possibilité de voir un peu quels sont les domaines où on aimerait avancer. Donc on crée un outil, un questionnaire, ils reçoivent un peu cette analyse du site. Et après, c'est à eux de voir un peu quels sont les objectifs où ils veulent avancer. Et là, on est dans du bottom-up, parce que le site local à Tremblant ou à Genève va devoir financer, gérer et aussi, euh, Assurer ou assumer aussi les changements qu'ils vont faire, donc c'est pas à nous ici central, au central de leur dire ce qu'ils doivent faire, parce que c'est eux qui vont devoir le payer et de l'assumer aussi, donc si par exemple on leur dit pas de voiture, vous avez plus que du vélo, c'est eux qui vont réaliser ça, donc c'est pas à nous de décider Et là, c'est un peu le top-down qui, la difficulté du top-down qu'on a essayé de, de, d'éviter.

C'est-à-dire on vous donne un rating, un outil pour voir un peu, avec des idées, etc. Et mais c'est à vous de créer des objectifs ou de voir un peu dans quel domaine vous voulez avancer. Ça c'est le deuxième projet partiel, on a un projet partiel qui était plutôt là, dans le domaine de sensibilisation, là le décideur a dit non, pour l'instant on a d'autres choses.

Tu sais que l'Armée du Salut on est dans un plein, on est, on a décommencé une nouvelle stratégie, donc ça prend beaucoup, beaucoup d'énergie, beaucoup de ressources, donc là l'Armée du Salut a dit, Ça c'est un peu trop, on a beaucoup de choses, d'autres choses à présenter, à sensibiliser, donc voilà, ça on laisse de côté.

Et le troisième projet partiel c'est un peu, on parle, on, on fait des campagnes. Donc on fait, la prochaine campagne c'est la campagne mobilité. On va faire un ou deux webinaires, on va inviter des gens, on va partager des idées, on va, On va voir un peu si les gens ont des idées qu'on peut, qu'on peut aller présenter à un décideur, est-ce qu'on peut changer ou lancer des projets.

Donc on va parler campagne. La première campagne, justement, ce sera le sujet mobilité. Et là, on va essayer de créer ou de permettre ou de donner un espace pour que les gens puissent partager ensemble et dire ouais, mais nous, on a déjà fait ça, ça, c'est super. Ah, mais nous, on n'a pas encore. Voilà, enfin c'est, ce partage horizontal c'est quelque chose qu'on aimerait créer.

On va juste donner quelques impulsions, quelques, Quelques idées, quelques, voilà, et puis c'est tout. C'est hyper passionnant cet aspect de dire, je trouve que tu refais le même truc que ce que tu disais au début, de dire, je prends mon gros machin, puis je l'éclate en petits bouts. De dire, même dans un domaine, tu vas pouvoir dire.

Euh, je prends mon domaine de, dans la durabilité de l'écologie et je le découpe en petites campagnes où je vais dire, ben, pendant un certain nombre de mois, on va parler de mobilité. Comme ça, on a un clair focus, les gens savent, ah, Michel arrive, ou, euh, on va parler écologie, alors pour l'instant, on parle mobilité, puis du coup, ça crée un peu un focus où il n'y a pas le, ah, on parle de ci, on parle de ça, on parle de ça, on parle de ça, mais on, pour l'instant, on échange là-dessus.

Sous-titres réalisés par la communauté d'Amara.org Oui, il y a deux choses. Enfin, j'ai deux réponses là. La première réponse, c'est qu'on a toujours parlé de, par exemple, M. Muller doit pouvoir réaliser que le gobelet en plastique est le mauvais choix, le, le, le mercredi après-midi quand il va faire du bénévolat dans l'institution, donc la petite chose, doit changer, ça doit changer chez l'individu.

Et la deuxième chose, c'est d'être compréhensible, c'est la communication, c'est du service design, c'est d'être compréhensible, d'assurer que les gens comprennent de quoi on parle. Donc il faut juste pas remplir le sac, sinon personne va comprendre quoi que ce soit. Donc c'est un peu, être un peu clair ou de parler des choses bien encadrées.

Enfin voilà, ça c'est la communication.

Donc là, si j'ai bien compris ça, c'est l'entièreté des paquets que t'as, que t'as dans ton, dans ton, dans le projet EcoVillant, l'éco, écologique. Plus, plus la communication, on a parallèlement, on a créé un claim, on a, on a essayé de trouver une image, comment visualiser ça. On est en train de, de faire de l'intranet, enfin, voilà, de la communication.

On a présenté ça dans des rencontres régionales avec, On a, on utilise la pomme comme, euh, comment dire, comme représentant de cette, cette, cette écologie, ce besoin de changer les choses, enfin voilà. Ça c'est un peu la communication qui parallèlement dans les projets, dans les projets partiers, euh, va, commence du début et puis voilà.

C'est aussi quelque chose à bien gérer, à bien, à bien développer aussi. Parce que c'est dans le projet, la communication, c'est, sans ça va pas, donc ça c'est aussi quelque chose qui est là, donc on a un cœur, oui. Il y a une force que je vois chez toi qui est assez hallucinante, c'est, pour moi, t'as toujours été une personne, c'est qui, qui est le, le, un excellent coach et un excellent chef de projet.

Puis on voit le, ces deux qualités dans ta manière d'aborder le truc, c'est assez intéressant. C'est de dire, il y a, il y a vraiment tout un aspect de. L'écologie est un projet comme un autre, donc c'est la qualité du projet, le bon timing, l'engagement des stake, des différents stakeholders, etc. Donc, il y a vraiment cette approche-là.

Il y a toute l'approche communication, donc de dire, voilà, qui vient aussi du chef de projet qui dit, ben, si les gens sont au clair, après c'est plus facile de les motiver. Puis après, il y a toute la partie coach qu'on sent dans ton aspect de dire, mais... Il faut que ça vienne en bottom-up, il faut que les gens puissent échanger aussi leurs connaissances parce que nous on sait pas tout et puis sûrement eux ils ont aussi des connaissances.

spécifique à leur petit contexte qui peut aider un autre contexte à un autre endroit que nous on connaît pas, mais eux peuvent s'échanger ces tips et puis ça sera beaucoup plus fort que si ça vient en, en, en, en, en top down, donc là il y a une vraie force je vois chez toi de, d'utiliser tes skills de, de, de professionnels pour cette approche écologique aussi.

Mouais, je crois que ce qui me dérangerait le plus, c'est si le projet n'avance pas, donc j'ai besoin qu'il y a quelque chose qui avance, donc je vais aller chercher là où il y a du potentiel de changer les choses.

Global versus focus

Maintenant, moi, personnellement, je crois qu'il faut, c'est un, l'écologie, la durabilité, c'est quelque chose de global.

On devrait avoir, on devrait décider globalement. Sinon, sinon ça va pas quoi. Mais dans, dans le sein de ce projet là, je suis persuadé que l'armée du salut ne serait pas capable de décider de, de, de, ou de changer le règlement, changer certaines règles, je sais que la seule chose que je peux faire, c'est aller dans, chez l'individu, ou dans le site même, pour essayer de faire changer les choses, donc j'ai, j'ai une approche de coach, mais sachant que, L'écologie, c'est un monstre problème, donc je peux, comment dire, j'essaye un peu de rester dans ce domaine influençable.

Mais le domaine of concern, ce cercle-là, dans ce projet, je peux pas, je peux pas, ça va pas, je peux pas y toucher, ça va parler. Donc voilà, donc je sais, voilà, peut-être, et peut-être autre chose que je découvre souvent, ou assez souvent dans les projets, C'est qu'il faut bien faire attention, il y a un niveau organisationnel, donc l'organisation.

Il y a un niveau du site, donc le groupe, et un niveau individuel. Et là il faut essayer de ne pas faire le mélange, donc c'est pas l'organisation qui doit décider. Um, il faut, il faut partager le papier et le plastique. Ça c'est au niveau du site qu'il faut que ces décisions soient prises. Et, euh, voilà, donc, et, et le, l'individu ne peut pas changer le règlement, parce que ça c'est quelque chose qui se passe, donc voilà.

Quels sont les sujets où se doit, où ces sujets doivent-ils être, euh, euh, attachés, réfléchis et changés? Voilà, donc, et moi je suis plutôt, mon, mes stakeholders de ce projet sont plutôt les sites, donc les responsables des sites, mais mon espérance c'est que les individus commencent à dire, oh mais je vais fermer la fenêtre, c'est dommage, enfin voilà, c'est ça.

Donc cette clarté dans tous les domaines de changement, les grands domaines, éthique, il faut toujours faire un peu la différence entre l'organisation, le groupe et l'individu. Parce que c'est des processus qui peuvent être différents. De ne pas donner la charge d'une responsabilité à l'individu pour le site ou pour le, pour l'individu au site et puis créer après la confusion.

Ouais, la prise de, prise de conscience, la prise de responsabilité, ouais, c'est juste. Ça c'est des choses, des choses différentes, ouais. Pour toi, si tu regardes un peu des différentes choses que vous êtes en train de mettre en place, que vous avez apprises, c'est quoi des choses où tu dis, c'est des choses Par rapport à cette thématique écologie, d'autres organisations pourraient vous voler ça.

Vous savez où il disait, positivement, c'est dans ce côté de dire, waouh, mais ça c'est, ça c'est un truc qu'on a appris, ça serait cool que d'autres, en fait, répliquent ça. Nous, ça nous a pris pas mal de temps pour le comprendre, puis en fait, là, on... Moi je crois que on a aussi tout volé en fait. Donc tout existe.

C'est pas quelque chose qu'on a créé nous-mêmes. On n'a rien inventé. On n'a rien inventé. On est allé regarder un peu qu'elles sont, qu'elles sont. On a trouvé des gens dans l'armée du salut qui étaient déjà, avaient déjà fait un certain chemin. Il y avait des, des expériences ou une volonté ou une, comment dire, une motivation de faire quelque chose, on est allé chercher un peu les idées, donc il y a, on n'a, on n'a rien fait de nouveau, on n'a rien inventé dans ce domaine là.

Donc tout ce qu'on a fait, c'est du copier-coller aussi, donc moi j'ai aucune difficulté. À le présenter. Là où j'ai un peu eu, au contraire, en fait, on a eu tellement, quand on a commencé à parler d'écologie, il y a le responsable de ce domaine là, il y a le responsable ici, j'ai reçu tellement de, de recommandations, il faut aller voir là, il y a l'armée du salut en Amérique a fait ça, là il y a des trucs super chouettes, il y a des trucs super chouettes.

Enfin, en Suisse, il y a des domaines, il y a tout ça. J'étais, j'étais comme ça, puis à un moment donné, j'ai dit, OK, maintenant, je dois arrêter, je dois regarder un peu mes, mes, mes quelques problèmes. C'est moi qui dois choisir, quoi. Il y a tellement de choses, tellement de choses. Le, c'est quoi le... Peut-être ce qu'on a pu, ce qu'on a bien réussi, c'est de trouver un niveau de spécificité, de détail, qui est assez, qui est assez bien choisi, donc on n'a pas trop, on ne se perd pas dans les détails, puis en même temps on a, on a réussi à ne pas, euh, euh, Impliquer toute l'armée du salut, tout le monde entier, toute la société, etc.

On a essayé de faire notre chemin sans trop regarder, voilà. Ça c'est peut-être aussi une stratégie, donc, de trouver le chemin dans ce monde où il y a tout, enfin, il y a toutes les solutions, il y a tous les problèmes, donc il faut juste prendre un peu. Mais ça, comment tu fais ce... Ce shopping quelque part parce que moi je vois ce que je vois c'est souvent ce que j'entends de avec les gens que je parle sur sur ces thématiques là qui sont des gens qui sont dans des organisations, des grosses organisations ou même des petites organisations qui disent ça m'intéresse.

Mais dès que je me suis intéressé, j'ai vu, il y a tellement de trucs que je devrais faire. Tout le monde me dit, fais-ci, fais-ça, fais-ci, fais-ça. Et après, il se crée un peu, tu vois, ce côté classique de analysis paralysis, tu vois, le, le, il y a tellement d'informations, il y a tellement de choses que finalement, je fais plus rien parce que ça m'angoisse presque.

Comment toi, vous avez dépassé ce truc-là ? Bah, je pense que y a, y a les deux extrêmes, y a, une extrême, c'est aller avec un partenaire, dépenser de l'argent, et puis faire ce que le partenaire nous dit de faire, quoi. Ça c'est, et puis l'autre extrême, c'est on va pas écouter du tout, on va faire que ce qu'on, on trouve bien faire.

Une extrême, je crois que l'armée du salut ou le décideur avait. signaler assez clairement, on ne veut pas un partenaire pour toute l'armée du salut. Ça ne va pas aller. On ne veut pas de footprint. On ne veut pas, enfin, on ne veut pas travailler avec un partenaire. On a, je sais que mes prédécesseurs ont eu certains contacts avec Mike Lyman, enfin des gens comme ça.

Et chaque fois, on avait l'impression, mais c'est trop compliqué pour notre complicité. Enfin, on est trop compliqué. Donc, chaque proposition compliquée, ça ne va pas aller. Donc, c'est ça. Donc, s'il y a une entreprise qui est. Assez encadré, le processus et les produits sont assez encadrés. Moi je dirais, il faudrait peut-être dépenser un peu d'argent, puis avoir, aller avec ces partenaires qui ont vraiment beaucoup, beaucoup d'expérience.

Um, moi je suis, ben moi je suis, je me suis tenu à mon dessin en fait, j'avais un peu de doigt. Les, les mille petits cailloux, je les avais mis ensemble et j'avais, on avait choisi que là, et puis j'ai, j'ai fait un peu, j'ai été regarder un peu partout, on a fait des listes, on a regardé les best practices, on a, on a été aller à des conférences, enfin on a fait plein de choses, puis à un moment donné je me suis dit ça va pas, on ne va pas avancer comme ça, on ne peut pas aller à la micro puis acheter, euh, des corneflex, un pain et puis un peu de viande, etc.,

ça ne va pas marcher, donc on doit juste retrouver un peu notre, euh, Et c'est là où je suis pas le seul, mais avec l'équipe, on a dit OK, on va créer nos projets partiaux et on va les faire un peu comme on veut. On a le savoir-faire, on va le chercher. Enfin, voilà, on a essayé. Je pense qu'on a cité une étape ou une décision de dire.

Non, c'est trop compliqué de travailler avec un ou deux ou vingt partenaires. On va essayer de faire notre chemin, au risque de devoir, d'avoir un peu plus de travail, parce que les solutions, il faut quand même les trouver, quoi. Ah, c'est comme, ah, tu vois, c'est comme, uh, une nouvelle application, tu achètes une application, uh, eh puis avec les, les, les, les inconvénients, ou bien tu, tu, tu, tu, un programme, une, toi-même et puis, tu, tu, tu as l'inconvénient, enfin, tu, tu es responsable du support.

Enfin, c'est un peu ça, c'est un peu quand même. Acheter une application ou installer une application, c'est ce choix. Je pense que là, je ferais pas de recommandation pour l'âme du salut, on a choisi un peu ce chemin. J'aime bien cette notion de dire que le, La complexité de l'organisation définit le type de, de support que t'auras besoin.

Si t'es une organisation qui est très top-down, avec un type de service et de produit assez homogénisé, où tu dis, voilà, chaque site, chaque lieu, Euh, se ressent plus ou moins, tu vois, euh, l'exemple le McDonald's, on sait que plus ou moins tous les McDonald's ont les mêmes produits, les mêmes services, ok, là tu peux dire, je vais prendre un partenaire qui va faire une belle analyse, qui va nous donner des recommandations très claires, qui va nous guider tout le long, Ça, ça marche très bien.

Par contre, si tu es une organisation qui est complexe, avec plein de services différents, plein de, de produits différents, plein d'approches différentes et de cultures différentes, alors là, tout d'un coup, tu dois, tu dois plutôt, ben, faire ta propre petite liste, et puis, définir un peu les quelques priorités que tu veux mettre.

Ça, je trouve assez intéressant, ce, ce shift-là, de ne pas penser que chaque organisation a besoin de la même chose. En fonction du niveau de complexité, tu peux,

Ouais, tout à fait, il y a des domaines où c'est, c'est très, l'armée du salut, par exemple, l'informatique, c'est clair, top down, c'est l'armée du salut qui décide, les applications, etc., là on a le cadre qui est placé, on a quand même des domaines, les finances aussi, le marketing, on essaie aussi d'avoir un peu des, des, euh, des unifications, des, voilà, des messages, de l'image de l'armée du salut qu'on donne, mais c'est Sinon, c'est très, très difficile, donc avec un nouveau projet, l'écologie, je ne vais pas pouvoir, sans équipe derrière, dire à tout le monde comment il doit faire, quoi.

Maintenant, toi, si tu regardes là, maintenant, sur un peu ce qui s'est déjà fait, puis ce qui est en train de venir, c'est quoi, Si tu devais choisir un ou deux trucs où tu dis ça c'est les choses, c'est les quelques clés qui ont eu, qui d'après toi vont avoir le plus d'impact sur un peu le changement de perspective vers l'écologie, est-ce qu'il y a des actions concrètes où tu dis mais en fait le fait qu'on ait fait l'éco-bilan, ça c'est vraiment un truc qui fait beaucoup, est-ce que t'as des, d'autres choses où vous dites ah mais ça on a fait un choix quelque part, on a fait ce choix-là, top down.

Puis, en fait, celui-là, vu la, la taille de l'organisation, il va déjà avoir un bel impact. Est-ce qu'il y a des trucs que tu, que tu as repérés comme ça, où tu dis, ah, mais ces quelques trucs-là, ils vont déjà faire un, un, un beau, un beau truc. Dit autrement, ça serait quoi le Pareto en écologie ? Dans une grande organisation.

Mais ça dépend à qui, ça dépend à qui tu demandes. Si tu me demandes moi comme chef de projet ou si tu demandes au décideur, ce sera deux réponses différentes, je pense. Pour le décideur, c'est vraiment les choses, un investissement avec un gros impact écologique, économique, ça c'est quelque chose qui va, qui sera important.

Donc les immobiliers, les rénovations, les changements des façades, etc. Pour moi, je pense que,

Les responsables des sites qui changent un peu de leur attitude. Je crois que ça c'est l'impact le plus important. C'est les gens qui commencent à dire, mais dans notre site, c'est vrai qu'on a trop de plastique, il faut, il faut la nourriture. Enfin, l'énergie, on va essayer de, on va essayer de regarder et créer dans, au sein du site, avec les pensionnaires, peut-être aussi avec les membres, avec les, les gens qui viennent visiter, les offres, etc.

Commencer à changer un peu le quotidien, la culture, les, les, l'attention, le, voilà. L'écologie c'est toujours au coût de quelque chose d'autre. Donc si je demande, vous êtes venu en voiture, les gens vont dire oui, mais c'est parce qu'on est quatre, c'est parce qu'on a, on a pas assez de temps, il fallait se dépêcher, et parce qu'on a plein de, on a plein de bagages.

Donc voilà, donc il y a trois raisons pour lesquelles les gens vont prendre la voiture et pas le train. Donc il faut toujours, il faut investir plus de finances, ou plus de temps, ou c'est compliqué de prendre le train. Sous-titres réalisés para la communauté d'Amara.org Ça c'est un exemple, donc, et j'aimerais que les gens commencent à dire, mais c'est pas seulement les finances qui comptent, c'est aussi l'écologie, dans mes décisions du quotidien.

Donc, euh, est-ce qu'on, voilà, et ça c'est quelque chose, ça c'est un changement d'attitude qui est, qui est du très long terme. Même, j'espère que l'Armée du Soleil, enfin je pense que l'Armée du Soleil a de la patience de changer les choses lentement et à long terme. Hum. Pour moi c'est les responsables des sites, les responsables des groupes, au niveau du groupe justement, c'est pas le niveau organisationnel, mais le niveau du groupe que là, il y a quelque chose qui va changer.

Et puis dans ce, alors si tu dis le, le, pour toi c'est vraiment cet aspect de changement d'attitude qui est la, quelque part le plus bel impact, est-ce qu'il y a quelque chose... Ou tu dis que ça c'est une clé pour créer ce changement, ou pour motiver ce changement, stimuler ce changement

Les responsables, l'attitude de certains responsables qui a un impact sur d'autres responsables. Donc un peu plus que le best practice, mais quelqu'un qui vient. Pour moi, c'est important, et puis les autres ils disent, ah, mais si pour lui c'est important, moi je pense que je vais devoir. Ah, si les deux autres sites le font déjà, je pense que, c'est un peu le nudging, c'est le, le fait que les gens commencent, que les uns commencent à faire quelque chose et que les autres, vont se dire, mais peut-être c'est quand même assez important de le faire aussi.

Je, je, je crois assez bien à ça. C'est vrai qu'on a fixé des objectifs, mais c'est des objectifs qui sont pas, qui sont assez quantifiables, donc combien de, combien de sites vont faire cet éco-bilan, mais c'est pas ça qui va changer, hein, parce que quel est l'impact, ça c'est quelque chose qui est, qui est, qui est du long terme.

C'est intéressant parce que ça, ça revient aussi à cette idée de, tu mentionnais le fait de dire, Dans une organisation, dans une grande organisation, t'as pas besoin de réinventer la roue, tu peux aussi juste aller demander à ceux qui ont déjà de l'expérience, quelque part dans les sites, dans les différents départements, et puis d'aller chercher ces voies-là, d'aller chercher ces expériences-là, puis là ce que tu rajoutes quelque part pour moi c'est le fait de dire, de prendre ces voies-là et puis de les remettre en avant, de dire hé regarde, Jean-Paul Delimaud, euh...

Pour lui, c'est, voilà ce que lui dit, qui lui a donné cette scène. Oui, j'aimerais bien, si j'ose utiliser la métaphore des, des voitures c'est peut-être pas bon, hein, parce que c'est pas très écologique, mais il y a des, il y a des gens qui sont déjà en route, ils ont pris la voiture, direction la France, le milieu de la France, etc.

Et il y a des sites qui sont déjà assez loin. Et il y en a d'autres qui ne savent pas encore par où passer. Donc déjà c'est, c'est, c'est s'entraider à trouver les bons chemins. Est-ce qu'il, est-ce qu'il, le problème c'est que je vais pas oser dire à ceux qui sont déjà très loin de, mais revenez parce qu'on veut aller tous ensemble.

Et ça c'est de nouveau un atout ou bien une raison pour laquelle on va, on va pas, faire tous la même chose, on va pas faire du top-down parce qu'il y en a déjà qui sont déjà presque en Camargue. Tu vois ce que je veux dire? Et je vais pas leur dire mais revenez en arrière parce qu'on va aller tous ensemble et je vais, je vais essayer de, de leur montrer ou de leur, de créer un espace de partage, de partage d'expérience, voilà.

Ça fait un peu, ça, c'est une raison de plus pour, pour essayer de, de, de travailler, travailler au niveau des, des unités, des voitures. Ou des trains.

En tout cas pas en avion. Ceux qui sont en avion, on va pas, on va aller les oublier.

Travailler avec une direction

Quand je t'ai dit, allez, ça me ferait plaisir de parler avec toi par rapport à ce sujet, j'imagine que t'as eu un peu des idées, des trucs que t'aurais eu plaisir à partager, ou des questions que t'aurais aimé que je te pose, est-ce qu'il y a des choses que t'avais imaginé pouvoir partager mais que mes questions ne t'ont pas encore permis de partager

Oui, il y a une chose qui m'accompagnera pour ce projet, c'est que le décideur n'a pas dit « Ah ouais, c'est important, heureusement qu'on le fait, on est là de toute force, on va te soutenir, etc. » Le décideur a dit « D'accord, merci de reprendre ce sujet, c'est important, mais fais-le un peu toi-même. » Donc, il y a un peu ce décideur qui a dit « Écoute, c'est important, mais on a juste...

Pas le temps, on n'a pas les ressources, on n'a pas l'énergie pour te donner le soutien nécessaire. Donc là, je suis un peu mitigé. Donc je dois aller, je suis assez, j'ai, j'ai un réseau, j'ai une équipe, j'ai un groupe de pilotage. Mais j'ai ce lien avec le décideur, il est, il est, comment dire. Je peux aller tant que je veux, je peux aller leur présenter, ils vont me dire oui c'est bien, merci beaucoup pour ton travail, mais c'est pas eux qui vont me donner de l'énergie ou du, du, voilà, de l'énergie pour avancer.

Donc ils vont un peu attendre ce que je fais. Donc maintenant ça me donne une certaine liberté. Je peux prendre le tempo, j'ai les objectifs que je veux, je peux avancer là, je peux freiner un peu ici. Mais en même temps j'aurais bien aimé avoir plus de pression, plus de pression de la part de la direction, enfin du groupe de décideurs.

C'est à toi que tu gères comment ? Parce que du coup t'as une pression positive en moi. J'ai une pression négative en moi, c'est un peu mon attitude quoi. Je...

Je pense que pour l'instant, il y a les choses qui avancent, donc je suis motivé. J'avance, je fais avancer les choses. Il y a du résultat, il y a des retours qui sont positifs. Tant que ça il y a, mais si tout d'un coup ça devient très calme, il n'y a plus rien qui avance, j'irai à la direction et j'ai d'y écouter.

Maintenant, qu'est-ce que vous voulez ? C'est pas à moi de porter ce projet, c'est, c'est pas, là on est, on parle de l'ownership du projet, c'est pas, c'est pas le chef de projet qui, qui, qui est, qui est propriétaire de cette, cette volonté de ce projet quoi. Mais pour l'instant ça me va bien, je suis, je, je, je profite un peu de la liberté qu'on me donne, et le, disons le soutien émotionnel.

J'ai vraiment, vraiment l'impression que la direction trouve que c'est du bon travail qu'on fait. Ouais, puis c'est, c'est, la réalité aussi c'est que c'est... Comme tu disais au début, c'est un des quelques, des peut-être cinq grandes reines du moment. Mais c'en est un. Alors évidemment, c'est un truc très fondamental, etc.

Mais c'est pas le truc le plus, euh, c'est le truc le plus important, peut-être le plus urgent d'une certaine manière. Mais il y a des trucs urgents et importants quand on est à ces niveaux de direction-là. Il y en a un paquet. Ben déjà, il y en a quatre autres. Donc ça fait cinq, cinq trends qui sont importants, on est complètement dedans, on est impliqué.

Et il y a le, la mission de l'Armée du Salut, qui est quelque chose de très important, qui doit, donc maintenant, c'est vrai que c'est en relation avec l'écologie, il y a une relation, il y a un lien très fort avec l'écologie, parce que s'il n'y a pas de durabilité, la mission de l'Armée du Salut, elle ne sert à rien non plus.

Donc voilà, c'est clair, mais c'est vrai que, Pour la direction, il y a plein de choses importantes qui sont en route. Tout à fait, tout à fait. Je me pose encore une question par rapport à, à quelque chose qui est très spécifique à l'Armée du Salut, puis que, qui est très spécifique à chaque organisation.

Chaque organisation, pour moi, a sa, sa petite culture, sa petite histoire, sa manière de, de contextualiser les choses. Puis des fois, ce qui est dur, c'est quand on vient, puis on dit, ah, il, ça serait bien de faire ça. Puis qu'on a, on n'a pas le... Le lien culturel pour le, pour le faire bouger. Toi, comment est-ce que t'as contextualisé ces questions de durabilité, d'écologie, dans le monde de, d'une organisation qui est à la fois une NGO et à la fois une église?

Ah, t'as, t'as fait ça comment? Mais je crois que je me sens pas tellement occupé, en fait. Je fais confiance. Je fais confiance à, ben, y a des, y a des processus dans tous les domaines. On en trouve, y a les églises, y a des églises qui commencent à vraiment bouger dans la direction. Je fais confiance à la pression externe, au, au...

Au mouvement externe de l'Armée du Salut, qui est là, qui est, qui est palpable, donc si dans le domaine de l'Église, l'Armée du Salut, il y a, les gens vont réaliser qu'il y a d'autres églises où il y a d'autres, il y a des processus qui sont mis en route pour les églises, donc voilà, je, je, je m'occupe pas tellement de ça, je fais confiance à, aux besoins en fait, je fais confiance aux besoins.

Et sinon, je me trouve déjà de nouveau dans ce cercle de concern où j'ai pas tellement d'influence.

Résumé de Daniele

Tout d'abord, un gros, un gros, gros merci pour moi, c'est toujours intéressant. Um, ce que je te propose, c'est de te donner un peu quelques points qui m'ont, qui m'ont titillé, qui m'ont, qui m'ont, qui m'ont fait avancer. Um, comme ça, un peu comme, comme une espèce de petit résumé.

Et puis, et puis, je suis sûr qu'après, il y aura, il y aura un truc où tu vas dire... Ah, il y a encore ça qui manque, ça, ça serait encore absolument important, puis après de toute façon on pourrait continuer cette conversation pendant trois jours, mais peut-être que tu as un dernier truc où tu me dis, celui-là ça me ferait plaisir de le rajouter encore au résumé, ça te va comme ça

Non, mais en fait je suis curieux de savoir ce que j'ai raconté pendant cette heure, donc c'est bien que tu me fasses un peu le, de mettre un peu le miroir là. C'est cool. Je suis très curieux. Du coup, moi, je me suis noté quelques trucs, un aspect que j'ai trouvé particulièrement passionnant, c'est cet aspect de clarté du projet, dans le sens qu'on a parlé de bonne qualité au bon moment, le bon moment, quelque part, c'est le bon moment, il y a quelque chose qui est en train de se passer, chaque entreprise, chaque organisation doit trouver ce bon moment, puis il viendra, mais cette clarté, et puis là, pour moi, tu as quelques aspects qui sont passionnants dans ce que tu as amené, le fait de...

Déjà chercher cette clarté en soi-même, dans le sens de, si moi je suis clair, je vais pouvoir retransmettre cette clarté. Et puis après, de, de, de proposer un focus, de dire, voilà, dans ce grand truc, voilà où on peut déjà commencer. Et après, cette approche que j'aime beaucoup aussi chez toi, où tu décris ce, ce, ce prendre le gros truc, paf, le casser en plus petits morceaux, puis choisir quelques morceaux avec lesquels...

À commencer, une autre chose très forte dans ce que tu mentionnes par rapport à ces cultures de grandes entreprises, de grandes organisations, qui est le fait de d'avoir un regard vers quels sont les processus de changement, de grands changements qu'on a déjà vécu, puis dire comment est-ce qu'on les a faits.

Est-ce qu'on les a fait avec, avec le bâton ? Est-ce qu'on les a fait avec le sucre ? Est-ce qu'on les a fait en mettant les gens en avant d'eux-mêmes ? C'est quoi les mécanismes qu'on a utilisés qui ont déjà marché ? Puis de réutiliser ces, ces, ces mécanismes-là aussi. Ou ceux qui n'ont pas marché, ne pas les répéter quoi.

Exactement. Après, il y a, il y a tout un aspect sur, très passionnant dans ta relation aussi au décideur, de dire, plutôt que de venir avec un... Avec une grosse machine en disant voilà ça c'est tout est interconnecté si soit on prend tout soit on prend rien plutôt de dire voilà ça c'est là tout ça est interconnecté mais voilà les différentes pièces du puzzle on peut commencer avec une on peut commencer avec deux on peut commencer avec trois on peut toutes les faire qui donne aussi l'opportunité aux décideurs de dire par rapport aux ressources qu'on a en ce moment par rapport à la mission à visiter.

Voilà où on va dire oui, voilà où on va dire non, donc de redonner aussi ce pouvoir, euh, mais sans... Tout en évitant le fait que, uh, tout le projet puisse être mis de côté, parce que tout est tellement interconnecté. Je pense que ça là, ça revient aussi avec cette clarté que tu, que tu proposais. Ah, ouh, mais on en a aussi des choses, hein, c'est, c'est, c'est chouette.

Ouais, je te dis. On avait mentionné aussi des choses de permettre aux gens de réaliser par eux-mêmes ce qui se passe bien, ce qui se passe moins bien avec les éco-bilans. On avait cette notion de campagne, de focaliser aussi la communication sur des thèmes. Donc vraiment aussi en termes de communication sur ces thèmes-là, de, de casser ça avec des campagnes très claires.

Au moins, il y avait cette beauté de dire, mais c'est un projet comme un autre. Donc il y a des capacités professionnelles qu'on a développées toutes à chacun, sur lesquelles on peut construire, donc on part pas à zéro, ça je pense que c'est aussi une très belle, belle chose. T'as ce modèle où tu dis, uh, organisation, site, individu.

de mettre les bonnes choses au bon endroit. Donc c'est assez... Oui, et puis on a aussi une organisation de projets assez classique, avec un décideur, un groupe de pilotage, un chef de projet, une équipe. Donc, j'ai souvent parlé de moi, mais je travaille avec 3 ou 4 personnes qui sont dans les projets partiaux.

Tout à fait. Et là aussi, c'était dans cette, dans cette organisation, dans cette structure, c'était aussi l'occasion d'intégrer l'équipe. Voilà. des gens, des sites, d'avoir des représentants aussi, comme, comme, personnes de référence aussi. Donc on a réussi dans notre groupe de pilotage d'avoir deux personnes qui sont, qui sont experts dans leur domaine, dans leur situation, dans leur site.

Voilà, ça c'était aussi chouette d'avoir, d'impliquer les gens aussi. Et puis ça, ça nous amène vraiment à ce côté de trouver les personnes qui sont déjà en chemin. On parlait de cette histoire de voyage, ceux qui sont déjà à des centaines, des centaines de kilomètres. Ne pas les freiner, mais plutôt les prendre avec pour qu'eux puissent, quelque part, tirer le groupe en avant avec eux, mais sans aussi les freiner.

Ça, c'est toujours quelque chose que je trouve, que je trouve très, très passionnant. Et puis après De, de dire aussi, de comprendre que dans une grande organisation de ce type-là, le changement, il se passe à plusieurs étapes. Certains sont plus avancés, d'autres sont moins avancés, d'autres commencent à se poser des questions, puis du coup de pas, de pas dire on doit juste travailler sur ceux qui sont tout derrière, mais on peut soutenir aussi ceux qui sont tout devant, puis d'avoir un peu cette vue un peu plus complexe du processus.

Trois points clés

Si je résumais maintenant peut-être en trois éléments, il y a, pour moi, quelque chose de très riche que tu fais, c'est que tu décomposes, hein, donc tu fais cette décomposition à la fois du projet, de niveau de l'organisation, des gens, où est-ce qu'ils sont, donc il y a tout un élément de décomposer le problème et sa complexité.

Il y a toute une question de... Clarification, hein, qui, qui, qui, qui est très riche, et puis la dernière, si je devais en choisir que trois, ce serait pour moi ce fait d'aller chercher la connaissance là où elle est, hein, que ce soit dehors, avec un partenaire, puis si, euh, si le type d'organisation le permet, et si le type d'organisation ne le permet pas, d'aller chercher aussi à l'interne et dehors, euh, en disant, mais c'est qui les voit, qui sont les plus passionnantes par rapport aux différentes entités, styles et cultures.

Qu'on a. Donc ça, ça serait mes, mon, mon petit top 3 de la conversation.

Point bonus de Michel

Pour toi, ça serait quoi ton top 3 ? Mais c'est pas mal, t'as bien commencé, je crois qu'il y a un, pas un top 3, mais peut-être le quatrième, ce que je, ce qui me vient à l'esprit, en fait, c'est, on parle du changement, um, du change, uh, et je crois que mon approche est plutôt celle d'un coach, c'est de, d'assurer qu'il y a la direction, que les gens aillent dans la bonne direction, et d'assurer qu'il y a quelque chose qui bouge.

Donc moi, je vais pas, je vais pas, comment dire, influencer le tempo, le rythme du changement. Je vais surtout m'assurer que dans, au niveau d'un site, par exemple, ou d'une offre, qu'il y ait cette, cette, cette direction qui est claire et qu'il y ait quelque chose qui bouge. Donc, pour moi, les gens ne doivent pas absolument prendre la voiture pour aller au milieu de la France, ils peuvent aller à pied, tu vois, et je fais confiance au processus.

Et le fait qu'ils vont à pied, c'est pas seulement une question, la question qu'ils n'ont pas de voiture, mais c'est peut-être qu'ils ont besoin d'aller pas à pas. Donc peut-être la notion du changement, peut-être une recommandation que je ferais, c'est pas on va tout changer, on va, on va, voilà, ce change management qui est quand même euh, Qui peut, qui peut créer des, beaucoup de tensions, des peurs, et voilà, qui est, qui est de temps en temps qui est nécessaire, il faut le dire.

Mais là, à mon niveau, j'essaie de dire, OK, voilà, vous voyez, c'est là-bas que vous allez, et puis c'est à vous maintenant d'avancer. Moi, je viens juste pour voir si vous, si je réalise que vous n'avancez pas. Et ça, c'est un peu ma notion, cette notion de coaching. Et je, j'utilise un peu cette stratégie comme chef de projet en contact avec les citoyens.

d'assurer qu'il y a quelque chose qui se passe. Et de le, comment dire, aussi, de le signaliser, de dire, d'être reconnaissant envers des gens, de dire, waouh, vous êtes en train de changer, c'est super, mais vous êtes à pied, puis vous êtes pieds nus, mais ça, c'est, c'est super, vous êtes, vous êtes plus au même endroit qu'avant.

Donc ce fait, le fait, c'est ça pour moi que le changement c'est quelque chose aussi d'individuel. Voilà, c'est peut-être le point que j'aimerais, mais je suis d'accord avec tes trois points, j'en mets juste un quatrième, quoi. Il est peut-être un peu plus méta, je sais pas. J'aime bien, j'aime bien. Eh, en tout cas, merci beaucoup.

Appel à l'action

Ça me fait hyper plaisir d'avoir, d'avoir pu... apprendre de toi encore une fois de plus, uh, s'il y avait quelque chose que les gens peuvent faire pour toi ou pour l'armée du salut, parce que là t'as donné beaucoup, uh, toi personnellement t'as donné beaucoup aux gens qui, qui, qui ont écouté ça, uh, mais aussi l'armée du salut l'a partagé des choses, uh, qu'est-ce que les gens peuvent faire pour toi personnellement ou pour l'armée du salut, uh, pour rendre la pareille

Wow,

wow. J'ai combien de temps pour réfléchir, là ? Autant que tu veux. Les joies du montage, c'est que les tambours, on peut les enlever. La réponse la plus facile, c'est que l'armée du salut fait un super boulot dans plein de domaines et a besoin de ressources, donc de ressources financières, ça c'est très facile.

Je, je reviens d'un atelier que j'ai, j'ai, j'ai participé hier soir et on a fait un peu l'analyse d'un quartier, d'un domaine, quels sont les besoins ou l'armée du ciel pour avoir une réponse et puis dans mon petit groupe on a réalisé que la solitude, la solitude est un immense problème, les gens n'ont pas besoin d'être seul, c'est un problème élevé.

l'énergie de faire quelque chose ou d'aller chercher de l'aide et ça c'est un immense problème et euh, voilà ce que mon souhait c'est que les gens puissent changer le monde quoi c'est, c'est un peu ça donc là je suis un peu dans le méta hein, j'espère que l'armée du salut réussisse à atteindre ces gens qui n'ont plus d'énergie.

Et si quelqu'un peut contribuer à cela, d'une façon ou de l'autre, avoir des contacts avec les voisins, ou s'entraider, ou dire, mais écoute, à l'Armée du Salut, il y a quelqu'un, ou il y a, va dans une église, ou va... Il y a de l'aide. Voilà, si les gens commencent à avoir, pouvaient avoir un peu plus d'énergie pour aller chercher de l'aide, ce serait super.

Voilà, on me demande toujours qu'est-ce que je souhaite pour mon anniversaire, c'est la paix sur le monde. C'est ça. Ouais, mais c'est très beau comme, comme appel à l'action de dire, accompagne quelqu'un qui n'a pas l'énergie vers quelque chose qui peut lui faire du bien. Quel que soit cette chose, mais d'accompagner les gens qui n'ont plus l'énergie pour qu'ils arrivent à quelque chose qui peut les ressourcer, qui peut leur faire du bien, ça c'est...

Qui peuvent avancer.

C'est un beau cadeau, hein ? Ouais. Trop bien. C'est du bon. Voilà. Eh, merci beaucoup. Ça m'a fait hyper plaisir. C'est un plaisir. Et à une autre fois, alors. À fond. Et puis, bah, toute bonne soirée.

Planetary Centric Design

What are core mindsets that we need to change?

Samuel Huber — Switzerland

A photo of Samuel Huber

Early principles uncovered

In this conversation, we uncovered 9 early drafts of Service Design Principles:

  1. Ask: What's the planet for you?

  2. Remember we've made huge transformations in the past

  3. Use both democratic and top down approaches

  4. Bring back the responsability to the wider organization, industry and systems

  5. Move from quantity to quality

  6. Move from short term to long term

  7. Remember mapping is priorizing

  8. Go for steady pragmatism over clashes or don't be a dick

  9. Don't get stuck in the dick-otomy

About the human

Samuel Huber is a founder at For Planet Strategy Lab. It's an experimental organization situated in between leading businesses, interdisciplinary research and artistic creation. 

The lab helps redesign the status quo by experimenting with alternative futures.

Samuel is also a lecturer in multiple institutions like the University of St.Gallen, the HSLU, Lucerne University of Applied Sciences and Arts, ZHDK, Zurich University of the Arts.

The full conversation

This transcript was automatically generated using Descript without any hand-made corrections. So it might be pretty creative at moments.

Welcoming Samuel and Initial Thoughts on Planet Centric Design

Daniele: Hey, a big welcome to you, Samuel. It's a big pleasure to see you again and to explore today a few questions [00:02:00] about Planet Centric Design, Service Design, how can we mix those things together. But before we get in all of this, I'd like just to welcome here. Thank you so much for being part of this.

Samuel: Yeah, it's great being here. Thanks.

Prototyping Strategies and Planet Centric Design

Daniele: And the first traditional question I have in these, thing is, when you go to a birthday party and you have to present yourself, how do you do that usually?

Samuel: Yeah. It's a tricky task to be honest. Depends a bit on who I'm talking to, but I've had quite a lot of fun to just tape tell people I'm a strategy consultant because usually then people go what you really one of, one of the baddies and so on, but it's yeah, it's quite fun. Start into the conversation because yes, I work with strategy, but I've dedicated a lot of my work to prototyping these strategies.

So that's usually the next thing that I would add. I'm a strategy consultant, but I do it with [00:03:00] prototyping.

Daniele: Super interesting, especially because I feel that you're doing something very smart, which is using a word that people have a feeling for, which is strategy and then adding a twist to it with the prototype. So I assume in the birthday parties, people will then, if they're not already completely drunk, say. Okay, what's the prototyping part of that? Because I know strategy, this two year long thing that then ends up in a drawer what's the difference in your take?

Samuel: Yeah, prototyping is an amazing thing. All of us do it. The thing is you already realized it, right? We're talking about prototyping and not just prototypes, the thing, but prototyping is, I would almost say a way of life and it comes from, I realized, I was working a lot with, Strategy. So I worked in design a lot, but I actually have quite of a mixed background.

We can talk about that later where I came to. But I worked a lot with strategy and I realized there that how we're doing strategy in organizations is very broken. We really separate [00:04:00] the mind from the hand. So we have the mind in one room, traditionally the executive management in the corner office, and we have the hand completely somewhere else that is interacting with the, I like to call it the interface of the organization where things are actually made and enacted.

But the feedback loops are missing in between. So really have these two things almost separated. And this idea of prototyping. brings it together again. It's crafting kind of what you know, and you don't need to prototype actually only when there's a lot of uncertainty, which people and organizations normally don't like.

But if you turn it into prototyping, it becomes a lot more fun, a lot more explorative a lot more potential driven. So you turn actually this uncertainty into an opportunity area. And I think that is really the basis of all good design. And luckily, then also. Strategy.

Daniele: I know about you. There's another term that I have seen [00:05:00] use a few times, which is obviously strategy, prototyping. And I've heard you say, Stuff like planet centric design is this, is that the right word that you use these days or what's the right term that you add that after prototyping?

Samuel: Yeah. I say I, I prototype for the planet, right? Prototyping for the planet. I have indeed moved a bit away of calling it just planet centric design because the moment I got into it, I realized if this is what you're trying to do, what you're trying to take into account as you are designing. It's not just about design alone anymore, it's also about finance, it's about HR, it's about logistics, it's about so many other things.

And we have that realization also when we talk about service design or when, whenever we basically zoom out a bit. So these days, I'm talking more of planetary perspectives because I also realized the planet or what entails the planet is very different from organization to organization and very, important first step is actually defining, okay, if we're designing or [00:06:00] strategizing for the planet, what's the planet?

And that's a really good and important question for a lot of organizations. Yeah, I still work with the planet a lot because I really think we have way too much focused on humans and increasing the value for humans and humans alone. And lost the planet out of view. And that in our processes, right?

We have user personas, user journeys, user stories, user research. And what happens if you don't include the planet in these processes is not that it will not be affected, but what will happen is that most likely it will be affected in a negative way, and it's really about changing that perspective,

Daniele: Really resonate with this question, what's the planet for you? because, when I speak with smaller service owners or creators, they, there is sometimes, this thing where, yeah, sustainability, super interesting, but. For me, we don't do any [00:07:00] harm, we don't do anything that uses lots of resources and stuff, and so asking the question, what is the planet for you, is a very smart way to say, ah, okay, in our case this is what it means for us, maybe for us for a small cafe, it's like a community around,

Samuel: exactly.

Daniele: place for a touristic place, it's it's really like the nature, the forest and the stuff, and so this is a very smart question. How do you help people, answering that question? Do you have tips and tricks that you share so that people because it's a very philosophical question at the same time. How

Samuel: Thank you.

Daniele: you help them to get an answer to that?

Mapping Perspectives and Planetary Actors

Samuel: What we usually do, one of my key practices is we call it mapping perspectives, right? Cause we usually rely too much on certain dominant perspectives which I don't say they're not valid at all, right? The business perspective is important. A human perspective is important, but realizing what other perspectives are there is really important.

And I'm very much a geek for maps and mapping. I really love it. Just to bring a [00:08:00] short thing, like maps are really an interesting thing. So there's this book, and sorry for getting too nerdy on this, but Latour wrote a book where actually a group of researchers is going to the Amazon forest and they're trying to map the forest.

And it tells a bit how they're bringing that forest and back to, I believe it was, Their their office in Paris or their lab in Paris. And with mapping, the intricate thing that we're doing is if we had the perfect map that is exactly as complex as the jungle, the map is useless because you don't see anything there.

So mapping is prioritizing certain things over others, getting the outlines because only then you can get to insight. But who prioritizes? Who says this tree is more important than the other and this stone is big enough so that we have it in there? So this just as maybe a primer of how we can help with that, because these questions directly translate into the workspace.

And there we do a method that I call Planetary Actors. It's a stakeholder map, but I I [00:09:00] really like to think of all these things as actors. And the thing is you, yeah, you start with the question, okay, what's in the middle? Some organizations put themselves in the middle or a product or their customers.

That's absolutely open. Sometimes you have to do multiple maps and then compare what are the differences. And then you start thinking, okay, what are actors that are directly in contact with us? and indirect in contact with us. So for example, when you have, I always do it with the, I explain it with the example of a little pig.

Let's say we have a little pig in the middle. We have direct actors, that's the butcher, for example, very direct. But then there's also vegetarians, they're indirect actors, really important actors that have an impact on That little pig. And with putting the pig in the middle, you already realized we have non human actors and they can be alive like a pig, but they can also be not directly alive like soil or an ocean, or what I also really like to have is objects and things.

And now very trendy at the moment. [00:10:00] Yeah, agents like AI agents, algorithms. We are just not aware of how much algorithms of any kind, and not just since 2022, when JATCPT was released, even beforehand, the impact agents, algorithms as actants have on our services, on our lives it's huge.

Just think of how, for example, Google Maps, there's an algorithm behind it showing us basically where you have to go. So this really has an impact on your perception on who's coming across your business and so on. So having these things mapped out is extremely important. I know I've been talking for a long time, but there's one thing that then usually gets lost.

People are happy once they have the actors. But planet centric design, planetary perspectives, they move from the boxes to the arrows. So much more important than the actors, the entities are the relationships between these actors. So I tried to make it a point that if we do this, we spend at least the same amount of time on figuring out the [00:11:00] relationships between these actors than it took us to Collect them all.

Is it on both ways? Do they want different things from each other? Opposing things? Is there a connection where there shouldn't be one? Or isn't there a connection where there should be one? And that just is amazing to, to do this task for any kind of service organization, product. You can use it for so many different things and it will instantly give you a different perspective and kind of the map you need to start discussing.

Which relationships are key and which ones are not of what we're trying to achieve.

Challenges and Insights in Planet Centric Design

Samuel: all for coming and I look forward to seeing you all in the next session. Bye. Bye. Bye. Bye.

Daniele: got Asia in the middle of the map, or if you look at the map from the top it changes completely how the map looks, and I find it very interesting, to play also with this idea of saying, okay, [00:12:00] What if we put in the middle, our business and how does it look different if in the middle we put something else? And how does it change our view? What is the right perspective? Or not the right, but the perspective that helps us the most. I think this is also a very interesting question, saying, oh, it has to be in the middle of this thing, and we're just going to go with that, but we can make several of them, and then see which one is the one that gives us more value, helps us the most. Is it something that That you push people to do also, like you try to not just do one map, but many maps.

How do you

Samuel: Yeah, for sure, because usually then the insight that I tried to generate with these groups is that they're actually not different maps, they're the same map, here it gets really difficult. If you do this digitally, you could do it imagine this network where you click on a node and then everything arranges around it.

That's what we're doing, but in, in like the constraint of our physical [00:13:00] environment on a whiteboard it just, yeah, it's impossible to pull off, but seeing how this is all connected and how if you want to be mean you would say blind, and if you want to frame it positively, how focused people are on certain things we don't, we start missing these connections and yeah, this has two, Two kind of outcomes or two kind of results.

The first one is, yeah, we don't see actually potential harm or negative impacts that we do, but we're also missing a lot of really interesting stuff that we just haven't had on our horizon yet. So it's really quite balanced out. And Yeah, that's what I tried to get these teams or these organizations to, to start seeing that.

And sometimes they go no, actually for us, it works perfectly fine if the customer's in the middle and then I'm a little bit sad, but at least they were discussing these trade offs. And it's not just something that happens like that by default, because everyone's following the same methods or [00:14:00] processes that are taught.

Daniele: prioritize these relationships? So you said very clearly it's good that we map the different actors, the different elements that exist. we should spend at least as much time from the mapping to what's the relationships. Then you said, and then you prioritize that, right? And make a priority, which I think is a very good and welcome thing, for many people who are smaller business owners and say, yeah, I can't do only so much, how do you do that?

Samuel: Yeah, that is the key point, right? And the tricky thing is I, myself, I can only prioritize from my own perspective. I can try to be empathetic with others, but essentially I just cannot take certain perspectives. And that's when this thing comes in. I think a lot of designers, when they start out, they first think they have to want to use all the services or products they design, but as you move on in your career, you realize actually that quite often you're not.

The designated user of such [00:15:00] a product and service. So your own judgment doesn't really apply to that specific task. So I'm fascinated with that. I'm a super curious person and I love it, but what do we do? So we don't have to reinvent the wheel. That's when we start into research, but the map is our guide.

It's almost our research guide of. what we have to ask. If you look at the map, you have all your questions are basically together because you, you start exploring what is there. And then once you've done that research and either validated or falsified your assumptions, that's when it's the first time you're actually in a position to start prioritizing that.

And yeah, this kind of shows these maps, they're not an exercise that you have to do and then check box, it's done. They're really, they're living. Artifacts that are changing. And it's also just because you then deprioritize something doesn't mean you cannot bring it back later. But if you have everything there all the time, [00:16:00] it's overwhelming.

And that also leads to a very difficult time in the projects because people don't really know then what to do. What to focus on and what to figure out.

Daniele: So if we imagine is a. A pay owner in Cedars, Sierre, Switzerland, in the past summer we had just a flood. And fortunately, the flood didn't get to his place, happy guy but maybe, this flood made a wake up call for that person that, oh, there's a few things that maybe I could do. And maybe he has done a bit of a map, on a napkin, because obviously he has napkins as a cafe owner, and he's thinking, okay, now I should do this research. How does a cafe owner do his research to prioritize?

Samuel: Yeah. First map the entities, then the relationships, and then go out and talk to them. If it's a cafe owner, you have a very local context, right? But the interesting is when you zoom out, suddenly you are in supply chains. So if you have cafe or coffee, then you have coffee [00:17:00] beans. And then you have to go there.

And in the end, we do need a pragmatic stance sometimes on these things. So for a single small coffee shop owner, I wouldn't expect them to travel all the way to Ethiopia or I don't know, Costa Rica, wherever they get their single origin beans from. But they should do the effort to actually figure that out or to at least see, Hey, there's an impact.

That's it. But you bring up a very important point, right? One single cafe owner is not going to change anything about floods in the valley. Yes or no. And that's the big insight that a lot of designers have once they start working on the topics of sustainability or regenerative design. It's Oh, already before I thought I had nothing to say and I wanted to see that at the table, but now it's even worse and that's frustrating.

And I understand that. And that's a whole history on how this. Has happened. The whole story that I think it was the petrol industry in [00:18:00] in inventing the personal footprint pushing all the responsibility on single people. We do a similar thing with human centric design, which is very on the Individual decisions of users.

And I think the big shift that we're doing with planetary perspectives or planet centric design is taking away that responsibility on a single user and we take it or bring it back to the organizations. Because they're the only ones that can deal with that. But it doesn't stop there. The moment you do projects like that, for example, in the construction sector, right?

Then you can also have these cycles, life cycles of buildings from planning, building, running it ideally renovating it, and then maybe at some point, bring it back again. There's no single company that covers all these different steps in the life cycle of a building. So not even a single company can pull that off.

And that really changes. The way you have to design, you have to design for translation, for collaboration for temporality, [00:19:00] and that gets quite complex. So I have, yeah, everybody that is trying to get into the space and realizes, Oh my God, this escalated quickly. You have my full understanding and empathy but it's the beauty at the same time.

Daniele: So for someone who goes through that and is in that momentary panic attack mode, of oh shit, this very fast and now it's very complex, and what am I doing here, what are your thoughts? Tips of, maybe based on your own practice, how do you handle, that, that anxiety of, okay, now I see the problem. I have a bit of an understanding for it, but I'm just this tiny ant in this huge thing. How do you create a sense of hope again, that it's just not, you're not just a drop in the ocean. You're, you can do something.

Samuel: Yeah.

Four Movements for Planet Centric Design

Samuel: So I know that I'm asking a lot from people, right? Planet [00:20:00] centricity in itself is a paradox. It's basically focus on the big picture. But I do provide in some of the talks I give, and also some of the things I've written, these four movements, and I called them movements for a reason because it's you have to, first, you actually have to move your practice from one way of operation to another one.

But it's also, you almost have to create a movement. These are not. individual practices or things you do, you have to do them together with others. So the very first thing you have to do as a designer is realize I'm not special. We're very good. And I think designers have one of the best skillsets to work in these big challenges we have right now, but they're not special.

You cannot do this alone. And I think that's very important because I've come across way too many designers who think there's some type of semi god or something. Check that and put it away. And then there's these four movements that I talk about. And I think it really helps to break down all [00:21:00] these things you have to do into more simple steps.

And the four steps are moving from human to planet. So that means that mapping that we. talked about before. The second one is moving from quantity to quality. So we're obsessed with quantitative measures and quantitative ideas, like the cake that's always getting bigger. But the thing is, we can also just make the cake tastier, right?

The single piece, why does it have to get bigger? So really understanding the quality instead of more customers, can we have deeper relationships with customers is an example. The third one is moving from the short to the long term. A lot of time in our decisions and even our design decisions, we're running quarter to quarter.

That's just a bit how it's implied by the system we're in. But while this might be important or is important, so I don't want to downplay it, we have an option to think ahead as well. And why is that important? A very simple example. So I just lived in Berlin for quite a while and I was really shocked coming from Switzerland that when I [00:22:00] moved into my apartment, there was no kitchen.

So basically every tenant has to buy a whole kitchen. And the thing is, most people just buy the cheapest appliances they get in, right? Because yeah, when you're a student or you just started working, a whole kitchen, that's quite an investment. But the thing is these things break rather fast, right?

So the, actually the better way would be to do the higher upfront investment and it lasts you much, much longer. And these mechanisms you have so often. So I've actually been surprised multiple times that the sustainable way or regenerative way of doing certain things is the cheaper way. But you need that timeframe.

If you don't have that you won't calculate for it and your business model will not work out for it. Yeah. And you already said me or heard me say the word I think we have to talk about cost as well and be honest with that. So the fourth movement is moving from a market fit to planet fit. And I do [00:23:00] have a pretty, how can I say positive view of.

Of economics and business, I think it's in its essence, it should be about how to keep great ideas alive, how to sustain them. Now, I know business practices are quite often used to get as rich as you can. Which I think is the wrong application of that, but let's really think about it, business is about resources and resources are scarce.

Also sustainability is a lot about resources and using some of these ideas to really Use these resources in a thoughtful and deliberate way that really makes a difference. So yeah, why not account for the true cost of things and the true value of things, right? So it's not just the externalities.

Everybody talks about the bad things as well, but there's also next to value like money There's maybe value like time, connection beauty, stuff like that, we should find and make ways to start accounting for that. [00:24:00] And I know this sounds really weird to a lot of organizations, suddenly have a KPI on beauty, but why not?

We have to start thinking about it and discuss it. And I've done that. And I've had a lot of weird discussions, but I've also had a lot of people realizing, yeah, there is actually more. To value than just money. So these are these four movements. Don't do them all at once. Some people want to do them all at once, but pick one and do it in your next project and your next idea.

Just say okay, this time we're going to do quantity to quality and see what changes. It's a very small step, but it can have a pretty big impact.

Daniele: These are extremely interesting, Even prompts in a way, where you can say, oh, what happens if we move from human to planet? What happens if we move from quantity to quality? Definitely very interesting provocations, to change the way we think. And I like this idea also that it's a movement, these are movements, you can't do these things alone. That's definitely also a thing that that I deeply resonate with. Just to make a bit of [00:25:00] a joke. We have a practice of in businesses to have, accountants who are very good, at making sure, the money goes somewhere. We know where it goes, we have this double sided accounting thing. It goes very deep. Wouldn't it be fun, to have the same kind of oh, I'm an accountant of beauty, I'm making

Samuel: Yes.

Daniele: Beauty stays, oh, I'm an accountant of time, that's the time we take from someone that we give it back and would be

Samuel: Okay.

Daniele: a fun way to say, oh, you're not just an accountant of money, you're an accountant of all the resources. Yeah,

Samuel: Absolutely.

Daniele: job.

Sustainability Reporting and CFO Involvement

Samuel: Yeah, no, you're actually very close to where I think it will be going. We see more and more that the system is sustainability reporting becomes part of the CFO office, right? Of the finance department of companies, because reporting finance financials and reporting sustainability is very close together.

There is an opportunity there. Currently, however, it's just who is the most accurate and deliberate in in reporting gets [00:26:00] really good scores. It doesn't really connect yet to doing actual good or having or creating regenerative value, but I'm fully with you. That's what I mean.

We have to get a lot more creative working with the roles there are.

Learning from Digital Transformation

Samuel: Also I think we can learn a lot from the digital transformation. That is still ongoing, but, um, both of us probably have fought to, to get the budget to do user research, right? So that was really hard to get 10 years ago.

And then it got easier and now it got harder again. But I'm just saying that it was just really hard. Not part of how companies start also this very basic thing of creating value for humans was not so much in the DNA of companies, not at all. I remember working with insurances that ask us not to ask their clients because they might.

Be remembered that the insurance exists and either cancel it or file a claim. That's really where we were. [00:27:00] And then we had the digital transformation.

The Role of Human-Centric Design

Samuel: It really helped to have that method of human centricity because it cut through all the complexities. Suddenly everything was a lot more connected.

A little company in the valley, for example, suddenly had competitors on a global scale. And it really helped to focus on that, but it, to be very honest, it needed somewhat of a catastrophe in the form of COVID to really get the the last company to understand digital is happening. You will have a video call at some point and so on.

I hope that for the sustainability transformation, which is just about to start, we don't need a catastrophe because it will be much worse than COVID, but we can learn from how back in the days we were, yeah. Working with companies. So we, sometimes companies had a digital strategy and the normal strategy.

Like today, when I think about it, this doesn't make sense. There's no strategy that's not digital. Some companies had digital units, which now we know, no, this has to be distributed everywhere. The same happened a bit to [00:28:00] design, right? Where we had innovation teams. The trend really is also now to have dispersed teams.

Now we have sustainability departments. Very soon we'll see sustainability being integrated in how organizations work. And that's just how the way goes. And we learned with the digital transformation, which is important as well and changed a lot, but let's take the best of these learnings and make sure the sustainability transformation got, goes a bit smoother and it's not looking that great currently, but I'm so optimistic that we can pull it off.

Daniele: There is an optimistic touch in what you say, the fact that, looking at the past, and you where were we 20 years ago, when, with questions of human centered, you say, oh we. It wasn't just evident answer to say, yes, we, this is something we want. If you ask the question today, in any organization, I think 99 percent of the organizations will say, this is important for [00:29:00] us, we're trying to do it, at least try, which is already good, and we're trying to put money for it obviously we could always do more, but we are on that path.

And, seeing that you, we can do that in a few dozen years now, it's also possible to do the same for something else, which could be sustainability,

Daniele: and I think it's good to remember that has, can happen, and also looking at how did that last change happen, what can we learn from that? we steal the same techniques, steal the same tricks, and obviously also for each [00:30:00] business, each business has made a few transformations in its life. back and say, hey, we did the transformation already 20 years ago when we moved from mom pop owners to a group of friends. Ah, this was a transformation.

What did we do? How? What did we learn? So being optimistic, I feel, is a very interesting addition here, but being optimistic by looking at the past is a kind of a very very poetic way of bringing it.

Samuel: Yeah, I think that's what humans are good at, actually. It is transformation, even though we pretend we're not good at that. But we have to be sometimes, I'm not usually the most patient person, so I also have to remind myself. But especially, yeah, today we're talking about sustainability.

It's the one trend that I'm pretty sure of. It's going to happen and it will even happen if none of the humans do anything or kind of climate will change, like it's not even up to us so much if we want this to change or not, cause it, it really lacks with what we're seeing now is basically what we [00:31:00] did 20 years ago or so, so, Yeah, it will stay relevant and it will need the smartest people to work on it.

And it's also really fascinating. It opens so many new ways of collaboration of ideas that suddenly come out and also of purpose for a lot of people.

The Need for Pragmatic Approaches

Samuel: But I do think we have, to do this in a pragmatic way. And I don't usually get or make a lot of friends, especially in the sustainable, say sustainability field.

And I say Hey, we need a pragmatic approach because a lot of people say Oh, we're running out of time, the house on fire and their truth to certain extent, but I think steady pragmatism works much better than having these huge clashes sometimes that then. Have to happen. That's a bit what I tried to advocate for.

Not saying that everything's perfect as we have it now, and I wouldn't change anything, but, as designers, we work with constraints. My nightmare is the blank [00:32:00] page. I find this so hard. So I love working with the constraints, hacking them, bending them, overcoming them, reframing them. That's design in the end.

And that's pretty much what we have to do now. Also with the system we're working with the organizations, with the economy, there is ways how to do it, if you dare to try.

Steady Pragmatism in Service Design

Daniele: How do you do that static pragmatism when it comes, maybe, things like service design? What is a static pragmatism? In that world,

Samuel: It's about listening what other people also have to say and what they're What their worries are, right? So quite often, I think the opposite of this static pragmatism would be, Hey, I have this key solution and you all should do this now. And if you don't do it, you're stupid. The good thing is I don't have that solution.

I have a perspective that works really well for me and that I've learned over the past years really applies to a lot of, to a lot of areas and really helps me to do better and better work. But I see it as a question and I see it as a question that I have to solve together. With [00:33:00] others that might not be convinced yet.

And there's one thing I learned is. Yeah, I'm not the proudest of my military history, but in Switzerland we have to do all our little military service and on long nights on guard where I work, where I talk to people from all different political backgrounds and ideological backgrounds, I realized we still have more in common that separates us.

And if you're willing to see that and also take this as kind of a. I don't know, like a given state of the people around you in your design work, you get much further than when you think Oh, now we have to convince the finance dudes. And they're sorry that I say dudes, but it is a lot of dudes, but advocating for more women also in that profession yeah, we're against them.

And so on. It's just, it's not going to cut it. They have their process, they have their problems. You can turn. their challenge into a design problem as well. That's what I mean with steady pragmatism. So they become part of your design [00:34:00] challenge and how you get there. And you'll be surprised. They have a, they're a lot deeper and they have a lot more to say and are sometimes extremely creative.

Once they are given the space to do that. So that to me is this ready pragmatism, not picking fights when you don't have to, but picking them when you have to, that I wouldn't give up, but really working with these elements. Yeah.

Daniele: in one of the previous interviews with with Heidi we came up with the thing just, why to make change happen, but don't be a dick. And I think I hear it like the same idea here, which is this notion of yes, it's urgent, yes, it's important, yes there needs to be some change that has to happen. It doesn't mean that we need to be dicks. We can still listen to each other, we can still, debate but we don't need to be in a pure outrage and and be be painful to each other. And I think this is a very good reminder in these things.

Samuel: No, it's [00:35:00] important. It's really something we can only pull off together.

Post-Heroic Management and Decision Making

Samuel: So I'm also a big proponent of it's called post heroic management, right? So we have a thing with loving our leaders and saying she's the greatest, he's the greatest. They know exactly what to do. It's, I think, in our human nature to really live up to these leader type figures.

But I think it's a really outdated way. It's the world has become too complex so that one leader can actually grasp it and make the right decisions. I still wouldn't say that everything has to be democratic because if you do that, you end up with average decisions, which sometimes then are missing the urgency that you need.

But how we do it, now this is a bit going towards this strategy practice that I do, but we always very much separate. We do collective or participative sense making. We make sense of what on earth is actually going on here. And we do that with whole companies, with hundreds of people. But we do focus decision making.

So when it's then about [00:36:00] making certain calls, we

Daniele: joining

Samuel: only five people, sometimes 15. But the big difference is

Daniele: I

Samuel: part of that sense making process that sometimes takes half a year, so they will make Decisions as in a role of stewards and fueled by that collective sensemaking process, which is completely different

Daniele: future.

Samuel: executives that I mentioned before sitting in their corner office and not having that kind of exposure and embodiment with their organization.

And that really changes a lot. But yeah, I think it's, it really depends. So I'm not saying everybody has to decide everything. It's It's impossible and it will not lead to good outcomes, but you need to find ways how to do that when it's collective and when it has to be focused and you need someone who can orchestrate this.

And here I said, designers are not special, but I think designers are pretty good at using these things as tools. So that's where I [00:37:00] really think a design early practice comes in as well, creating this process, facilitating this process, and also pushing this process.

Daniele: It's this view of, which is very Swiss in a way, we we were, we're both Swiss. So we always like, like the neutral part, when this is a Swiss culture thing where, people we have in Swiss German a word, which is the contraction of yes and no, which is jaen. So this is a typical Swiss thing. And I like also this kind of in, in this view of saying Why choose between democratic and and and top down, why should we choose? We can do both. We can have a very democratic listening, and consultation and still use the power of a bit more top down to take more, maybe more courageous courageous stance. Which have been very hard for the average. And

Samuel: Yeah, absolutely.

Daniele: again, the beauty of using both qualities instead of saying one or the other.

Samuel: Yeah. It [00:38:00] boils down, I can build up on, you said before, be the change, but don't be a dick or something like that. We have, and yeah, I have to say sorry now before I even say it, cause it's a very academic joke, but we also say don't be a dickotomy and the dichotomy is this black and white thinking this there's the social, there's the material, there's democracy.

And that's pretty much the one thing I learned. Everything's contextual or on the spectrum. And sometimes it's this, and sometimes it's the other thing. And it's also a lot of jokes made about designers who always say it depends. And that is because it does depend, right? So really understanding how that works together is.

Very deeply ingrained in how I see the world and how I work these days.

Planet-Centric Design Perspectives

Samuel: I don't make a clear distinction between human made things and nature. That's why I work with the planet. I think it's horrible. In the Oxford dictionary, I think it says nature is everything but excludes humans, right?[00:39:00]

Except people. And that's just the wrong view. It's not us collaborating with nature. It's us working within. Nature, within the planet, all the things that are human made are by now heavier than all the biomass on this world. This is insane. In the early nine 1903, I think is when they started, it was a 3%.

Now we're at 110 percent and this doesn't even include waste, just the human structures in use right now. So we have become the planet or nature and we are very much in there. And that's why I have a, yeah, that's why I really like this, uh, planet centric design approach or these planetary perspectives, because it really allows us to Appreciate is the wrong word, maybe, but to say yeah, there is an impact of these things and we have to make that show up again.

And what I realized a bit is when I completely exclude, for example, non human actors that are not alive. Like a [00:40:00] building or a square. It gets really tricky to actually use these methods when you try to design, because as a matter of fact, I look outside the window, I have, I'm lucky I have a little garden out here.

But most of the things where we live, our habitat is, it's not that we live in the mountains, even though that would be very nice, but it would not even be possible for all of us to live in the mountains, right? So that, that's the thing again. So we really need to find a way where we realize, Hey, there's a We're within this and only when we see us within nature, that's when we start acting and designing accordingly.

So don't be a dichotomy.

Daniele: I love that one. I'm going to steal that again. What's for you, something that we haven't covered yet, you feel is important or you feel should be part in the conversation.

Samuel: That's a different question or difficult. First of all, there's so many things I could talk about with you, but let me wrap up what we talked about. We talked a bit about these planetary perspectives what the planet actually means, how you have to, [00:41:00] um, figure out what, yeah, what the planet is in which context.

So I think that's really important. We talked about the movements, we talked about the role that designers can play in that and that they're not that special, but they are important nevertheless.

Daniele: Welcome.

Convincing Organizations to Embrace Sustainability

Samuel: thing maybe that we could talk about is I often get asked how can I convince my colleagues, my organization to

Daniele: I wish

Samuel: are motivated to do that. And most people would say yeah, of course I want to be sustainable in that sense. So there's very few people that say no but very few people do it actually.

Daniele: for

Samuel: An interesting thing is to me, one thing I learned is that,

Daniele: and

Samuel: we focus very much always on the technology.

So what do I have to invent? What do I have to build to become more sustainable? But the thing is we have, I think we have pretty much all the technology we need to be more sustainable and technology can be as simple as a tree.

Daniele: bye.

Samuel: thing that [00:42:00] captures. Carbon. We don't need huge carbon capture plants in Iceland that are extremely expensive.

We can also just have trees. So I'm just saying that's this one thing. So it's really about how we change that behavior and behavior we change not only through individual action, but really how our organizations work, because that's important to me. My definition of design over the years has become very simple.

To me, design shapes behaviors. No matter if it's service design or graphic design, if it's graphic design and you design a beautiful poster, it will shape people's behaviors towards going to that exhibition or that concert. If you have a hot dog, a 1 hot dog at the end of your experiences, like at the Ikea, it will shape or make people eat more hot dogs than they actually should or would.

Really, design shapes behaviors, and we have to make sure we shape them. And now when you ask, okay, how can you do that as an organization, one thing that I learned that works very well for [00:43:00] me is not talking about sustainability directly, but talking about value because every organization, no matter if it's a museum, a university a resource trader, a bank, all of them want to create value and that really opens up a lot of discussions and very similar, like with the planet, you can start to create value.

Working with them, okay, what kind of value, right? Before we talked about that already, to a certain extent, are we creating beauty? Maybe we are creating beauty and that is an important thing. First question. Then you ask them, okay, for whom that connects to the method we talked about this planetary actors map, where you start understanding, okay, for whom are we actually creating value?

And we've had, or we've seen in the past 20, 30 years that the question to this as well for shareholders. And we're all a bit guilty of that, at least in Switzerland, cause part of our retirement system basically builds on the necessity that shares, share values increase. So there's nothing you can do about it if [00:44:00] you're employed in Switzerland.

But not so far back, there were a lot of companies that didn't want to retire. did see their importance for the families of their employees, for the city they're in. They would invest in schools, they would invest in, the University of St. Gallen where I did my PhD was basically an investment of all the big companies that were there working in the textiles industry because they needed people.

So it's not such a. It's actually quite natural, and it's not so long ago when we did that. And their last question, we talked about that as well, is when. When does this value unfold and how does that work? And through these three questions, I think you get really nice conversations started with your colleagues, with your boss, with the company, the organization you're working with.

And the worst thing that can happen is that they don't do anything, and ignore you. That can happen. I cannot predict you from that. The second thing that can happen is that you have these conversations and they still go [00:45:00] on as it has happened. That's an okay outcome. At least there's awareness that is an important step and then you can try again.

And the third outcome is that, that actually they change certain elements, maybe smaller ones, but they start creating that awareness.

Daniele: Thank you so much, I think this is a very helpful last tip for people who want to convince their boss or their team to, on the, on that journey.

Final Thoughts and Wrap-Up

Daniele: Thank you so much for all of it and especially for the wrap up. Which was also a very good summary. We usually I have to do a summary at the end, and you did this for me, so thank you so much for that also.

I really appreciate it.

Samuel: you.

Daniele: My last question for you is there something that the people who have listened can do for you? Because now you shared a lot with the community. there something that the community can do for you?

Samuel: Good question. I've never been asked that at the end of a I mentioned before, I'm very curious. So if you. If you want to reach out, tell me about projects [00:46:00] you're working on, that is always amazing. If you feel like, Hey, you should meet that person, put me in touch with them. And the best thing you can do is really also ask in your next project or task you do, where is the planet in this?

Just for a brief moment. And maybe you can ponder on that, or you just leave it at that, but just add that question to your repertoire.

Daniele: Awesome. Hey, thank you so much. I had a really lovely and insightful time with you. So thank you so much for spending that time and investing the time with me today, and I'm sure you will receive a few LinkedIn invites and other recommendations to speak with other crazy

Samuel: Let's see.

Daniele: around the world.

And I'm excited to see

Samuel: people unite. Yeah.

Daniele: Absolutely. We need to be like that. So again, a big thank you to you and I wish you a lovely rest of the week.

Samuel: Yeah. Thank you so much.

Regneration

How to embrace complexity without anxiety?

Igor Jimenez — Mexico

A photo of Igor Jimenez

Early principles uncovered

In this conversation, we uncovered 4 early drafts of Service Design Principles at three different scales

  1. Personal: scale: Stop and accept that it’s a crisis

  2. Organisation scale: Build the motivation for change

  3. Industry scale: Use a certification like B Corps to guide you

  4. And finally to link this all together don’t forget to be part of a community as it will help you move beyond the crisis, rebuild your motivation and learn from others who made progress before you.

About the human

Igor Jimenez is a Service Designer, Digital strategist, Systemic thinker with focus on regenerative projects.

Igor founded CoDeck, an innovation for regeneration consultancy in Mexico, which helps businesses use innovation skills to create life-centered projects.

Igor is also a community lover, who leads the local Interaction Design Foundation in Mexico.

The full conversation

This transcript was automatically generated using Descript without any hand-made corrections. So it might be pretty creative at moments.

Daniele: Making services sustainable is not that simple. But that's okay. That's what we chatted about with Igor Jimenez in an interview for my next book on how to create services that are lovely for humans and the planet that hosts them.

Igor is a service designer, digital strategist, system thinker with a focus on regenerative projects.

Igor founded CoDeck and innovation for a regeneration consultancy in Mexico, which helps businesses use innovation skills to create Life Centered Projects.

Igor is also a community lover who leads the local Interaction Design Foundation in Mexico.

With Igor, we uncovered four early Service Design Principles at three different scales.

At the personal scale, stop and accept that it's a crisis.

At the organizational scale, build the motivation for change.

At the industry scale, use a certification like B Corp to guide you.

To link all this together, be part of the community, as it will help you move beyond the crisis, rebuild your motivation, and learn from others who made progress before you.

Thanks so much to Igor for this lovely

Wave Link MicrophoneFX: conversation.

## Introduction

Daniele: Hey Igor, I'm so excited to finally meet you. We had a few conversations over LinkedIn about sustainability and service design. And as the conversation went longer over LinkedIn, we were like, Oh, we should go deeper in those subjects.

And that's why we are here today. And I'm so grateful and thankful that you accepted that we continue the conversation today. Yeah, it's my

Igor: pleasure, Daniele. Thank you very much. Of course, it's a, it's my subject, my preferred subject, so I'm so happy to share with you and to recognize your effort to, to spread the word about service design, which I think it's pretty, pretty necessary for all of us.

Daniele: Thanks so much. And I really recognize that we try to do the same things here.

## About the series

Daniele: And for people who maybe don't know the series, the idea here is to explore ideas about how can we make services nicer for the humans that use them and the planet that hosts these services. So that's basically what we are exploring in this conversation.

But before we go into the nerdy stuff. I have a tiny question for you.

## Who is Igor

Daniele: If you have to, or when you have to present yourself in a birthday party, how do you present yourself?

Igor: It is a question that I am waiting all the time and trying to avoid, but finally after some years of do different punchlines, it's, I prefer to say that I do Innovation for Sustainability, which is like a one short sentence that I I hope everybody understands.

Of course, after that, people always ask, what kind of innovation? So then I start to put all the concepts about, uh, yeah, about human centered design, about service design and sustainability, so that is my my, my way of. of sale is uncomfortable question. ,

Daniele: that's a very good punchline.

I like how you use the word innovation, which has like a a positive connotation for many people who are not in the field. It's oh, but everybody would like to innovate, that sounds nice. And and sustainability. Oh, that's that. Who wouldn't like to do that?

So you are, you're framing it in, in, in a very positive and and welcoming way. If I was one of those guys in the birthday party who says, that was lovely, but what do you do every day? How do you make this

Igor: happen? I have to say that we always try to understand users, understand people and users.

And in our case, we try to understand socio ecological context. This is where the solutions are developed or deployed. Yeah. Which is material for next questions though, but yeah. Absolutely. Absolutely.

Daniele: And I'm curious because when I saw your kind of because we don't know each other yet that much.

So the only thing that I know about you is our conversations within LinkedIn comments and like your LinkedIn profile, which is very rich, and my question to you is. Where in that journey that you have, where came sustainability as something that really drives your work today?

That's a good question.

Igor: I guess that we all, as human beings, we all have a need of connection with nature and, everybody has that, I'm sure about it.

## From disaster to personal change

Igor: But if you ask me for a critical point where I decide it, it was the earthquake happening here in Mexico City in 2017 I was like in zero, I'm living in the zero zone, you know what I said, so it was really shocking and that was like a first big call where I would like to do it.

But pandemic was like the like the last call, after pandemics, I said for me, there is no sense to work in a different thing, that something that helps to sustainability,

Daniele: yeah. It's crazy how those crazy moments, there's very harsh, difficult moments.

In fact, so that's. As a parenthesis, my wife complains about that because I always, see too much optimism always, and I, and one thing that I see here is that even in those harsh realities, they serve also as a wake up call. And that's very inspiring to see how, in the worst moments of our life, it changes us and makes us move to, Oh, but there's more important things to do than innovate on.

How do you open a yogurt? Maybe you can do something more interesting and important than creating another yogurt opener or whatever

Igor: else. Yeah, definitely. I wrote an article about the earthquake. It's in Spanish, but nowadays you can put it on a translator. Because, yeah, the shock situation brings a lot of positive things.

which is something paradoxic. It's paradox, no? Maybe you don't want to take it like that, but yeah. And I can say that I was a witness of an extreme collaboration as I've never been part of before and after that. It was amazing. Yeah, that moves everything. Yeah.

Daniele: That's and so I'm curious today. So you went, so the earthquake happened the emergency happened COVID happened.

Igor's projects

Daniele: So how do you work today? What are the kind of projects that you do or what are the clients that you help with your innovation for sustainability? Yeah. Yeah.

Igor: That's a good question. We, after pandemics, we make a focus trying to work only with companies that already understand sustainability or have it in their agenda, et cetera, as a mission, vision, whatever they make the statement.

For example we help the whole customer experience. for a water filter brand, which is a compromise. They are a B Corp. I don't know if you're familiar with this certification for everybody, it's a systemic I guess we're going to run to that concept later on, but it has systemic, it is a systemic certification.

So when you see this letter B with a circle. And that means that company has a it's compromised with with nature and society. So we work with, we try to work with companies with this certification, for example, this one, the water filters. We do different things like the UX experience in their e commerce.

We did their cx, their customer experience, unboxing experience adding values of sustainability, adding education and motivating to to spread work because of course here and Switzerland as well. But and maybe all around the planet we have this pet dependence. No we all.

Used to drink water from pet bottles, which is a terrible problem for, especially for the oceans and for our health as well. So we picked this client, for example, or we had a match with this client because that we worked with an organic food company, the oldest one here in Mexico. Creating their digital experience, we create, we, they are programming it right now.

It's a super interesting business case because we are, we create a tool to improve the health of the clients. It passed through a really deep process of user research. Where we find out that finally their clients buy their products because their health, not because the planet, which was a shock for the brand because the brand was claiming on the ecological side.

So we turning to the health users health side. And we created gamification and behavioral change or behavioral nudging techniques to do that, and to bring another example, we work with a foundation that it is the most important investment on water here in Mexico.

For 40 years, they've been the biggest economical investment in water quality here in Mexico. And we are creating all their, trying to find a standard for the different course of water. Because it's a really technical problem, and on the other side, creating a digital experience for that.

More or less, we can say that we found we used to find a client that is already working on sustainability, and we add value of methodologies on the backstage, and overall on the front stage with the digital things, in a way. I hope

Daniele: it's clear. That's awesome. I always have this feeling. So we're also coming from a, an agency background.

The beauty. The beauty of working in a consultancy is that you touch so many different worlds and that you get to learn so fast, from one project, you suddenly are directing the next one, you're directing the next one and the next one. So the iteration bit is working not only within one project, but between multiple projects at the same time.

That must be a very exciting place to also try out new things for sustainability.

Igor: Yeah, for sure. It's super exciting, to be honest. Yeah. Since sustainability is super complex and you cannot be an expert on everything, it's impossible.

Daniele: And that creates a wonderful transition to the conversation I'd love to have with you.

## Challenges in Sustainability Efforts

Daniele: Because this conversation started already on a LinkedIn comment section, where maybe there is This is a situation that I feel and see, which is that there are people who I see going towards questions of sustainability, who are very excited about it. And then once they get into it, you feel that there is a moment where then they get blocked.

They get blocked by. By the complexity of it, they get blocked by all the sheer amount of things that they should know. They get blocked by the fact that maybe the impact is limited in what they can do themselves. And and one thing that I've seen and that I always suggest is, Because this reminds me of my own coaching sessions, with students and companies where, they all also get stuck in this analysis paralysis thing, even if it's not related to sustainability, there is a similar thing happening where suddenly it feels like that's too much. So we're just gonna. Stop or continue researching until that will happen. And one thing that I always suggest is, hey, just start somewhere. Just start maybe somewhere local with something that you have, maybe get there somewhere.

And we started a bit of a conversation with with this question of, or this lovely provocation of maybe it's good to, to get stuck. Maybe it's good that it's. blocking us. And I'd like to hear your take on that. Thank you.

Igor: Of course, for me, it's the answer is like, of course, it's good to get stuck.

Of course, it's good to to stop in a way, a certain moment and ask yourself and ask everybody or ask the organization, are you doing what we are doing that? Otherwise, you are running through the same line, and of course you're going to get the same results all the time. Of course, sustainability is something super complex.

And there is a book from, precisely from Swiss authors and French. They are called Les Catastrophistes. The cata how do you say in English, like the catastrophes. And they made a great compelling of work, and they, their main question is how we can manage the, our behavior and our feelings through this crisis.

No, because finally we have to accept that we are in. It's such a historical moment, certain authors compare it to the beginning of agriculture in terms of the change that we have to do right now. So we're in a moment of change, definitely. And sustainability is, for me right now, it is not even enough. I am pushing more for something that is called generation.

No. So narrative culture, businesses and A, B, C. But these outdoors like the catastrophes they talk about how to navigate the catastrophic because finally it's gonna happen. It's happening. We, everybody, we see flutes dry. Change of Climate Agency. So they said you cannot be, you cannot be like stress, like with eco anxiety, which is something that it's already detect, or like eco anxiety, which is something that overall young people it's like suffering right now, because what would happen?

And, on the other side, I said, you cannot be so cynical to say there's nothing to do and let's keep doing the same thing. So how do you find a middle point on all these, no? And I think that is what we need to be prepared for to have, to take action. Thank you.

To take these questions as a serious thing at a personal level, at a fa familiar level in the, as a companies overall, and of course as a society, nations, and humanity. And what I right now described by going from personal to to, to nations is to describe the different scales. that, that are involved and there are nests as a networks within this complexity of the problem that we're facing right now.

No. So what I'm trying to say in the linking exchange was that it is important to to save these. This energy that young people have saying, I want to change the whole thing, okay, because of course they want to, and everybody, if you are young and you don't want to change everything, you're dead, man, you're not young, you're not being young enough.

So it's a sign of health of the, of young people saying we want to change everything. So going from that point. And maybe they have to learn the complexity of the challenge that they are facing. And there is when Catastrophist comes to the scene to say, okay, there's a lot of information.

Definitely we are in Let's say bad trajectory, the forecasts are not so optimistic, but you cannot get freezed because of that. And you cannot fall in this eco anxiety or analyze the paralysis that you mentioned. And you have to do something, okay? What is something, okay? That depends on you and how much.

You want to, how much time and effort and energy you want to invest on this needed change. I used to call it like we have a needed change as a civilization. I don't know if I answered the question. Yeah, absolutely. It makes a lot

Daniele: of sense. To continue in that direction. We just had, a few months ago, one of the worst floods in Switzerland in the south of Switzerland.

And let's play this scenario. Let's imagine one a cafe owner from that region. There are plenty of cafes there. Wine is, it's a wine region, so people love to drink and have a fun time together. And let's imagine that a cafe owner comes to you and says, we just had that plot and it changes my perspective.

We need to do something. He says, but I'm a cafe owner, what can I do? Either I could be paralyzed and anxious and I don't want that because that doesn't feel right. And I just don't want to continue as before. Because I don't see the sense in that. What would you suggest as a way of thinking, a question to help this person start reflecting to, to get out of these kind of two polar zones of either paralysis or just continuing like usual?

What's there in the middle? What can you suggest to, to our cafe owner of the South of Switzerland? Okay.

Igor: The problem was the flues, you mean like water flues?

Daniele: No, the flood is more the moments that created the, oh shit. We have to do something like you with the with the earthquake.

With the earthquake and and Corona, which was a wake up call.

Igor: For

Daniele: example. Yeah.

Igor: Yeah. For me, for example, all these. This kind of services has a change, a supply change, and it looks like it doesn't matter. I have to go for the cheaper options because I have to increase my role because everybody told you that from, I don't know, 30 years ago.

Everybody talks about cost efficiency and blah, blah, blah. That is the first parting that we have to change. And maybe I would ask to this owner, how do you feel with all this, with all this news that we have about this needed change or whatever you want to call it, how do you feel, how do you feel about your daughter or your sons?

Do you think it's fair enough to be pushing to have more return of investment instead of sacrificing a little bit of that and going for a local supply change, no? There is another, which is a huge change for all these kind of services, which is the use of water, no? Because we are pooing over fresh water and we throw away all that is contained in that, and there's a lot of minerals that are need to crop in the countryside.

Of course, you need treatment for that. It's not something direct, no. But, whoa, that is a super change for restaurants and coffee shops. And that is something where you need to interact with your audience, the coffee audience, in order they to understand and to pledge to this movement where you stop to use clean water, to, to lift away your Disposals, no way to sell, no?

The use of pets, I guess it's another one. Do you want to steal? Putting the pet on these expensive bags that you have in Switzerland that you have to pay a tax to throw away the pet and now the Swiss government doesn't know what to do with all this quantity of pets because I'm sorry to say, but in Switzerland you use a lot of pets.

It's amazing, I'm amazed about it oh my god. And everybody goes to the, since people is paying, it's I'm paying, it's not my problem. Of course it's your problem, even if you are paying. For the coffee shop owner, do you want to be part of, the change of pets or the use of water?

Or the supply chains. There is a lot levels of compromise that you can be involved of, or you can just give some money to local, uh, organic food production, no? Yeah. So that's my way of putting like different stages, no? But I think the most important thing is when people.

Ask questions, for example, sustainability, it's a word that I would like to challenge now, because what is this, what do we want to sustain? Do we want to sustain this way of living that put us at this point? Is it for real? Are you feeling good saying that to your son? Oh, listen, no? We have we've been, like, polluting the planet, but it doesn't matter.

We're going to keep doing that, the same. So we're going to do sustainability. I don't, it doesn't make sense. So questions are, like, the main matter of regenerative

Daniele: from what I'm feeling, you say, someone who would say, Oh, I'd like to make my service more sustainable. One of the first questions you might ask is something like,

Would you like it to be, to continue like that?

So that's the idea is that we want to, what part do you want to sustain? And what part would you like to continue to be like that? Where you feel this is a good part. We are happy about it. For example, the fact that we greet people in a very lovely manner. That's something that we can sustain and that it's lovely and makes sense.

And what are the parts that you. I think that's something that we wouldn't like to sustain because my grandkids will shout at me in two generations when they will see that this is something that I decided to sustain. It's like making the choice between there are things That already makes sense today in the way that you work, that are perfectly, make sense to be sustainable in that way.

And there are parts that need to be reworked and therefore go rather on a regenerative side. Is that kind of like the way you see that?

Igor: Yes I'm now, nowadays I'm trying to avoid the jargon in general. Human Centered Design, design jargon, which is, I didn't make it at the beginning of the interview.

But I try to avoid jargon, and I try to do a kind of radical empathy with the client in this case, and just understand what is, where is his understanding or her understanding of the problem, and maybe you can challenge that and point to bigger changes just in order for him to understand that it's more complex than the actions that he could take.

Definitely you have to kick off from their understanding and their capacity.

Another example is waste. What about trying to be zero waste? That's a hard one.

Daniele: So from what I'm hearing, there is a thing where you say in these questions of trying to make services lovelier for the planet. without using that much language. There is then the notion of, okay, you, people start somewhere with kind of a, this is something that we could do. And a lovely provocation that you're bringing is, and what if we went bigger?

What if we went with a bigger change? What if we moved to a, to another scale of the thing? For example, you want to reduce waste. What if. We want zero waste. What if you produced something that made the world better instead of adding waste to it? Does it go in that direction?

Igor: I don't think that provocation for a bigger scale or a bigger problem would be will be a priority for us.

I guess it's more about the Trying them to understand the interconnected, the interconnectedness of the problems and the concept of intervene. Our rational minds our rational training always look for fireworks and for achievements and all that, and goals and KPIs and all that stuff.

We, we love in business, but when you said, for example, just trying to be zero, trying to be zero waste, there is a chain of changes that the user or the owner of the business have to face, that it he will explode in questions, why am I doing this? All this, no? And I, and we bet that the change lives there.

In that question, in that moment when she or he said, Do I really want to do this? No? Because of course you're going to find a huge list of excuses to avoid the changes, no? But how do you bring arguments to do that, that is the hard part, and those, so those arguments are more our goal, in a way, to set provocation.

It is just when the conversation goes to this rational way of thinking, then you can use B Corp certification or you can bring, all well in a not in a coffee shop example, but in other examples that we have, we are getting into, gr green finances. It's coal. We to said no.

The financial world is changing completely. They're focused to, to sustainability and and regeneration. You can use this tools for, to provoke them when rational mind it's aware and as, but as soon as you feel that this rational guard comes down, you can , you have to do the inception about intervening in life as a network life as a network of nested networks and all the complex complexity and how a little change in a little scale if you, if it will connect with the next scale.

It's going to, it's going to provoke change beyond the personal scale or level, no? So I guess it's more about that, like trying to do the inception.

Daniele: And there are three things that I hear in what you suggest here. One is this notion of when people are in crisis Because they realize this is gonna be way more complicated than what I expected.

. Instead of coming with maybe more knowledge what we need is to rebuild the motivation. And rebuild why people are trying to, why did they select the route that they're taking now? And that's something that we hear a lot from, there is a whole field about that, which is called motivational interviewing, which is a field in psychology where they basically say people don't have a problem of knowledge.

Daniele: People that need to stop drinking, they know basically what they should do. Problem is that The motivation, my friends are people who drink. If I stop drinking, I will not be able to see those friends. And I'm an introvert. When I drink, I'm less, I'm a bit more easy to to communicate with. It makes me easier.

It makes it easier for me to network. And then it's okay, but what's the early motivation that you have? Why would you change? What, is there a reason to go in that change? And one thing that they do in motivational interview, which is quite, quite a smart thing. Sometimes they do a thing where they say, Oh, but obviously, no.

I think you absolutely can continue to trick, and, sometimes you hit your wife. That happens. And then the guy says, no, how can you say that? It's terrible. I love my wife and that's why I want to change. That's why I want to stop. And I can make new friends, and then suddenly, confronted with, you By taking what they are saying without saying it, and you put it there clearly by saying it's an option, you could choose to continue to drink and to continue to hit your wife.

That's, at the end of the day, it's your choice. Then suddenly people realize, oh, but they have a motivation. What is it? And by talking about it, suddenly they rebuild the motivation. So I feel that there is something like that, that you're doing. Is that correct?

Igor: Yes maybe that, that, that's a good reminder that you made me right now to revisit this techniques.

We are, we used to be more focused now on, on behavioral change. It's called behavioral nudging as well. And so we tried to put some techniques coming from there. Which are really simple, which are really like bridges between yeah, between hard words that people face sometimes, and so we create a message, a WhatsApp message to to push that change.

And on the other side, we used to use gamification techniques as well, no? Because coming back to the. Coffee shop owner, of course, he's not alone, and he has to convince all the collaborators. We used to try to make a little game about it, a little leaderboard, little poems on there, little games.

Something that makes it fun at the same at the same time, but, yeah, maybe this, the motivational interview that you are saying, it's something that we should revisit and add it, add to our toolbox, in a way. Thank you for that reminder.

Daniele: Because The part that, that I'm intrigued is when you say, when people are in the crisis mode, so I'm less speaking now about, the user of the service, but rather the owner of the service who wants to make a change and who realizes, oh, if we want to go zero waste, All the things that we're going to have to do if we want to go B Corp.

That's all the things that we're going to have to do. And I'm quite interested as like consultants, the owner, who is faced with those conversations, owner to owner, and the owner would tell you, yeah, that was our early motivation, but now we're stuck. It feels impossible. How do you manage that conversation?

Thank you.

Igor: When they already tried and it, and the enthusiasm falls down. Yeah.

Daniele: How do you manage that that drop that's or doesn't happen?

Igor: Yeah. Yeah. First of all, as something natural, because all the efforts for change has a psychic, a cycle of descendants and. And Ascendance, no?

In, in, in a way to set. First of all like that, and after that I used to go. For the motive, yeah, for the motivational points of the stakeholders and of the collaborators, I'm trying to create something fun from considering those elements, something fun for the stakeholders, something fun for the collaborator, and even for the end user if it's the case, but something that, that, that could give us a room to interact. with the people to have certain feedback about why is that is not working and Then doing the change with them, which is another huge one for us That's why we call codec because it's co creation or collaboration. No, so We always try to create these solutions with the people in the room Yeah, more or less I will do that

Daniele: That's super interesting.

The Role of Certifications

Daniele: And now if I come back a little bit before you, you mentioned the use of standards like vCorps and this kind of stuff. Is it something, what's the value in those things? Do you feel that it helps businesses having a standard or how do you present that? Is this something that people it, is it something that is helping them?

Is it something that you feel is useful? How do you, it's a good question. Yeah.

Igor: I have to say that I I was a hater of certifications at my beginnings of sustainability, but after starting it I feel that there are, that they are doing two jobs which are super important. One is the standardization of the efforts for the change, which is super important because otherwise every, everybody's doing their own efforts by their own terms and it's impossible to measure and to compare and to.

to share good practices. I think the work that they do in creating a framework and a common language is super important. And that is one. The other one, it's, for example, with B Corp, it's that people that are aware of Sustainability issues in a way to set have a more than more than 60 percent of recognition of the certification.

So it gives you an endorsement on, on, on that field. But nowadays it's becoming, and it will be an essential because finance, finances are looking for that. Now if you want to, it's a super complex thing and nothing to, to put it right now here, but the, there are a lot of financial instruments, brand new that, that are emerging right now and almost everyone ask for a third that certifies that your.

Sustainability efforts are real and are measured. So in that way, certification is going to play a huge role in the next years. And that's going to change the whole game, I feel.

Daniele: For someone who might say, oh, that sounds interesting, these certification things, and sounds like a there are very clear benefits, like I can compare to how we are doing compared to others. It gives me learning points because it tells me where I can improve and so on.

And it helps me maybe Think about stuff that I didn't think about. B Corp, I feel, is like a good example because it's like systemic and it's helping you to just not think just about making things nice for nature and just forgetting about humans. It's like a very complete thing.

And so if someone is interested in that. What are certifications that you feel as an ex hater? That you feel, oh, this is actually useful, this is actually something that can help people towards goals of making their services nicer, both for humans and the planet that hosts them.

Igor: I think it depends a lot of on the goals and again, the motivations or goals of the company.

No. If the company just want to be recognized in their industrial environment their, there, there are set of certifications that that, that do that, . But if people, or if. If the company or organization wants to have awareness and recognition, B Corp for example is for me the best example.

But if the goal or the motivation is about financing, then another set of more technical certification comes to the scene, no way to say it, no? For example. We now, we have a project in Costa Rica. It's about skincare products and they are interest interested in, in, in B Corp.

They're running their process to do that, but suddenly they find they, they found a huge opportunity in a bigger market. , but they don't have the money to invest on that. So they, they need a loan. And the banks in Costa Rica already have the KPI to put certain amount of money on on, on green businesses in a way to set, oh my God.

So then the huge conversation, now it's. The question is on negotiation is which is the best certification for the bank, because the bank only recognize American standards, like from United States, so they have to apply for that. So the bank have to pay for that or not. It begins this technical problem, no?

But it depends on the goals of the company, I would like to say.

Daniele: And for the curious ones that would like to have a name to Google, of one of those finance related, very technical certifications, do you have one in mind that you have either heard of a few times or that you have worked with a few times that you feel that's something that people can look into?

You mean certifications? Yes, so you spoke that there is interesting stuff that you said, which is very specific, obviously. And you said there's this general stuff with B Corp. And then you said there is a kind of a space in finance with with with more technical ones. Yeah.

Igor: it depends it's related to carbon credits, for example. There is a set of laboratories and certifications that place that. If it's water, there is another.

it is specified by business, vertical or impact vertical.

there are a lot for real estate.

which are Minergy, which is a Swiss one, super old one, and a good one, Edge, it's another one, LEED, it's another one, and the most robust for me, which is Lifebuilding Challenge. These four certifications for a real estate project, which involves sustainability, and bonds, and all complex financial instruments, will help you to get there.

To get the money to do such a project. But, yeah, interconnectedness and and interbeing are clue, are, yeah, are main part of the three scales, no? Because the standard of certifications creates a connection with the other scales, you know what I'm saying?

Daniele: Thank you so much. We already explored a lot in this conversation. So I'd like to give you back a bit of a summary of a few key takeaways that maybe you can add your own that you feel like I missed in the summary.

For me, there was one aspect, which is this, the first one is that there is a middle situation here. That we don't have to get either anxious and paralyzed or say, we can't do anything, so we're just going to continue. And there is a kind of a middle way, which is a way of the curiosity of asking questions and and getting started some way.

So that's like the first element. Second element that I got from you is that. There will be a moment where people will get in a crisis mode, in a project, in a new project, or at the start of a project, where they will feel, why are we doing this? This is so complicated. And there Kind of your approach is to rebuild that motivation in some way or another, it can be by making it more fun, it can be by re going back to the original idea and saying, why did you want to do that?

It can be by asking questions like, about the future impact, by saying, hey, but for your children, what would you like to do for your children? And so to bring the thing back to what's the motivation? And then finally, there is a third element, which I heard from you, which is that certification sometimes can be a good element, again, a good helpful element.

And from what I heard from you is obviously when it comes to finance aspects, they're very specific one based on the vertical. So people have to be able to explore their own vertical for that. There are also industry specific one. There are, in each country, region, there might be different ones that people can look into.

And if people are interested in in general, there is B Corp, which is a bit, a good all rounder which is a recommendation that we can give here where people are not making a mistake if they try to explore that one. So that's like the three levels. One is recognizing that we don't have to, If you please, we can continue, but that needs curiosity and asking questions.

The second one is we need to rebuild the motivation, and there are several ways to do that. And the other one is having a standard is something that is helpful, which gives like a bit of a recipe and even if sometimes we hate the recipes, sometimes they also be helpful.

Igor: Hearing you, if you realize the first one falls in the personal sphere, which is like the minimum scale. And yeah, you have to understand how to navigate the catastrophe. And the second one, It's more about how, about organization, which is more or less a little bit the next scale. You have to understand how you, how do you connect those scales, because in dynamics of complex systems, it is super studied that you need to connect both, no?

In the second one. I think which is important is to be part of a community. No, I remember I took a course with Fritjof Capra, which is a physician a scientific about systemic thinking. And at the end of the super complex course, he told, he tells, you have to be part of a community. Thank you.

If you want to make a change by yourself, you will not get nothing, you have to be part of a community. So in both scales, I guess it's important to be part of a community as a person, to be part of a community as a business, no? And it connects with the third level, which is certifications.

Daniele: I love how you, if I'm getting you right, how you say the community part is what links all of it together, where we basically say it's to help you get out of freezing.

It's nice to have a community. You rebuild the motivation. It's nice to have a community. To learn what certification and how to use the thing, it's nice to have a community. And basically that's where you connect all of these different aspects together. The me and personal, my organization and the world I live in can be put together through a community of practice.

That's the, that pushes you forward.

Yeah,

Igor: definitely. We have to. change the paradigm from competition to collaboration.

A last tip

Daniele: Is there an important thing, obviously there are at least a million, but is there one important thing that you'd like to add that you feel this will be a last tip or suggestion or reading recommendation that you would like to share with the community?

Igor: Yes,

Daniele: of course.

Igor: For us, it's about life centered design. It's not more about human. Human is a part of life centered design. And within that, of course, communities should be on the center of the design. Maybe those

## Call to action

Daniele: Thank you so much. So you shared a lot with the community today. So is there something that the community can do back for you?

Is there a place that people should connect with you? Is there something that people can do to help you out?

Igor: I guess being in contact for LinkedIn is the most active social network that I use. And, yeah, and follow us. We are Codec in LinkedIn. And that's it. I hope I'll be around Switzerland in the next month.

Let's see. Maybe we can create something together with the Swiss community there.

Closing words

Daniele: Wonderful. Again, a big thank you to you. It was a very interesting conversation. It started well on LinkedIn and it ended up even better in here live. And I'm excited and sure that we will continue to have some similar conversations in other places.

But once again, a big thank you to you and enjoy your time on the other side of the world. . Thank you, Daniella.

Igor: Thank you very much. I am I really appreciate this time too for sharing these kind of ideas and hope that it's it's gonna be help helpful for every everyone else. Thank you so much.

Product Design

How can we instill meaning in boring services?

Joel Hügli - Switzerland

A photo of Joel Hügli

Early principles uncovered

In this conversation, we uncovered 5 early drafts of Service Design Principles:

  1. Write a secret shitty personal manifesto about your own values.

  2. Do the “edge of the mattress check” to verify if you really live your values.

  3. Be stupidly naive about your field by asking why this is done like this.

  4. Ask yourself what happens at the end of a service.

  5. Don’t get stuck in one emotionally loaded topic; instead, do the math to reveal the biggest impact and leverage you could have on the planet.

About the human

Joel Hügli is a Mattress-Designer, Researcher, Green Concept Award Nominee, and Design Prize Switzerland winner. Yeah, next time you’ll hear the words award-winning designer, you’ll think of Joël.

He is the founder of Ecomade, which aims to improve sleeping comfort with Swiss quality and sustainability.

The full conversation

This transcript was automatically generated using Descript without any hand-made corrections. So it might be pretty creative at moments.

Teaser

Daniele Catalanotto: How can we instill meaning into boring services?

That's what we chatted about with Joël Hügli in an interview for my next book on how to create services that serve both humans and nature.

Joël is a mattress designer, researcher green concept, award nominee, and design prize, Switzerland winner.

He's the founder of Ecomade which aims to improve sleeping comfort with Swiss quality and sustainability.

With Joël we uncovered these five early Service Design principles to create more meaning and boring services and products like mattresses.

Daniele Catalanotto: Write a secret, shitty personal manifesto about your own values.

Do the edge of the mattress check to verify if you really live your values.

Be stupidly naive about your field by asking: why this is done like this?

Ask yourself what happens at the end of a service.

Don't get stuck in one emotionally loaded sustainability topic. Instead, do the math to reveal the biggest impact and leverage you could have on the planet.

Thanks so much to Joelle for this unboring and lovely conversation.

A Deep Dive into Joël's Journey and Sustainable Design Philosophy

Daniele: Hey Joël, such a big pleasure to see you again!

Joël: Hello, Daniele. Thank you for welcoming me here. It's a pleasure to have a chat with you now.

Daniele: Yeah we've been in touch, through LinkedIn messages and other ways about service design and other stuff. But I'm excited because today I get to steal one hour of your time to, uh, look into your brain about all things ecology, sustainability, design.

And so I'm very excited about this conversation. But before we get into that, I have one question, which is when you go to a birthday party, how do you present yourself?

Joël: That's a good question. So first, I do not try to talk about my profession too much at birthday parties, I would say but if it comes to this topic, then I would describe myself as a sustainable product designer who is working in research at the University of Applied Science and Arts in Lucerne.

And besides that, I'm currently developing my startup as an entrepreneur and designer for sustainable Swiss mattresses. I think that's, that sums it up more or less.

Daniele: And I've seen you are. One of those guys, who we can call award winning designer. When I looked at your website, I was like, Oh fuck, he has a lot of these things.

Joël: Yeah, that's that's actually. It's obviously a big honor to be awarded for some of the work and it's also like somehow a bit, uh, it's a good feeling to be awarded because it's often such a huge effort that, that I or people have put into those projects and especially now with with my mattress topic, which evolved from my master thesis, this This is great to see like how many people are actually interested in mattresses because it's already a bit it's a bit of strange topic but I think the people are getting more and more aware of why we need to look into topics that are Not that relevant in social media or newspaper like a mattress.

And it's great to see that, that it gets recognized from the community.

Daniele: And that's one of the things that I love about your approach. It's A bit harshly said, you're working on one of the most unsexy things on the planet, but at the same time you do it with such a passion, and I think many people, which are Building services or products.

There are many unsexy services and products, but necessary, and still you have passion and I think you can be a really good example for people of of these unsexy, boring services to see that, yeah we still can be very passionate about, but I'm very curious, so today you ended up, being a very niche with these mattresses and stuff.

But. What's up with your journey? How did you arrive in these topics of sustainability? What's up with your sustainability journey?

Joël: So originally I started, I wanted to get into the, more into the creative field. So I started to work in an architectural office in Bern in Switzerland. Did an apprenticeship as an architectural draftsman and Then I noticed, ah, there's this thing called industrial design and product design.

And I started to study it and got the tools of being a product designer. But during my studies I began a bit to question my profession, and during this time I also noticed a book of Victor Popanec. Actually have it here with me, because it's, I think it's one of the, or, if not the key.

role of of my change of mindset. It's called design for the real world. And I love the first sentence in it because Viktor Papenek describes the profession of a product designer as one of the worst professions on the world. And this somehow shocked me a bit at this time, because I just was A few months ago from being a fully finished, if you want like that product designer.

And then someone said in a book from about 50 years ago, that this profession is actually not a good one, simple said. And then I started to question myself from what I, what am I really doing here? It's a lot focusing on consuming and it's, Not a consume in a good way. Like it's really about money and consuming as much as possible.

And we are just, as in product designer, I would be a part of that. And then I started to reevaluate a bit what I want to achieve what I want to, what I want to contribute. And I wrote a small manifesto for myself. And from this point on, I tried to. To be on this path from this manifesto that I wrote back then, this was about eight or eight years ago.

And after that I, I got obviously I had some difficulties to find a job in the, Design field because a lot of these jobs are focusing again on consuming and not in a good way. And by luck I got into a research job. The one I'm still in it now. And during this time I also did my part-time master with you as a coach as well.

I think two or three times. I, you were my coach for my master thesis. And the master thesis then was. About my, about the approach for more sustainable mattresses and my startup now. So that's a bit rough sketch out of how I got into this and what led me to reevaluate my work or my profession.

Daniele: It's inspiring to see how. A book can change, our perspective. I feel we share a similar story there. There was also a book for me that kind of shifted my attention from, Oh, for me, it was graphic design back then. And then it was like, Oh, you can do something which is useful. I don't have just to do ads and that's fun, but there is other stuff that we can do.

Which book was it for you? It was the book about services and the one from from Andy and Ben Reason and and for me it was like the discovery because I came from a very more, much more kind of artistic school, where it was legibility. We don't give a fuck about it, as long as it looks great,

Yeah. Seeing, oh, there are humans, we can serve them. That's interesting.

The Power of a Personal Manifesto

Daniele: And and there is another thing that I find extremely interesting in your story is how You had the guts, the inspiration to write a personal manifesto. So what was in that manifesto?

Joël: Yeah, so I read it, like from time to time, I do read it again.

But it's written in a horrible way. It was, I remember because it was just, it was more spontaneous sort of action to write it down because I felt the need to have this as a guidance for later because There's, I see a bit the problem that as soon as you get out of studies and you need to have a job and everything, then you lose a bit your own personal values.

Like you, yeah, you loosen them a bit up and, ah, no, sustainability is maybe not that important anymore. I'm just happy if I have a job, which is paying me well. With this manifesto, I want to reduce this risk and therefore I put, I wrote down things like that, that I really value my, Personal interests and my motivation higher than monetary reasons or monetary payouts salaries, for example.

And one aspect is also that I want to have with my work, I want to have a more positive impact than the negative impact I'm having with my life. Like the consummation, like everything I'm consuming has a negative impact. And the least I want to do is to compensate somehow this negative impact with my, my work as a sustainable product designer.

Daniele: For someone who is listening to you and saying, wow, that sounds pretty great. This this idea of let's call it writing a bit of a shitty personal manifesto, like not putting too much pressure on, on, it has to be very philosophical and stuff, it can be badly written, but it showcases the values.

How can someone get started with this? What if this could be an interesting exercise, what's a question to answer? What's a good start. That's a good question.

Joël: I think there's a bit the fear of the white paper. I think that's a common fear in creative business. I don't remember exactly how I did it back then, but I think it helps to just try to have a bit, a list of personal values.

Then you write down some of these values and then you try to rank them. And by that you can formulate a bit more elaborated text and try to contextualize it with why you want to be or act like that. And maybe you can also. Reference it to some other literature or projects or designers that inspire you and just fill this Manifesto, Shitty Manifesto, as you said it, I like this name to get bigger and then have some importance.

Daniele: I like this idea of saying it's hard to get started. So maybe starting with just a few bullet points, just Keywords, and then starting to rank them and then saying, okay, now I feel that I can start to write something. Maybe another piece of advice that we could explore is this idea of, sometimes people, it's hard to start writing.

Especially for this kind of stuff. So maybe we could have kind of a sentence, in life, I think I should value this for the next 20 years, two points. And did you make a bullet list of 10 points? Yeah. Like a

Joël: building block. Yeah.

Daniele: Yeah. And it's just to start, obviously it will change, but it's Oh, I already have a bit of a starting point and maybe this can get it.

Joël: Yeah, and to have in mind it's only for yourself. I would never ever have someone read this manifesto, but I tell a lot of people about this manifesto that I have it. And this helps me actually to like, because some people will ask me, are you still on the path that you wrote down in your manifesto?

And then I have to evaluate this on myself, but I will not hand out this manifesto, so it can be shitty, and it still it's it still has its purpose, and I think that's also one aspect to have this in mind. It doesn't need to be good Grammatically.

Daniele: But and you're adding a one word that is extremely important, which is secret shitty manifesto.

Because by making it secret, it just keeps the pressure low. And at the same time, it's like your little diary, your little private thing. And if you fail at it, you're the only one who knows that you failed at it, which is already like a big enough pressure in life.

So that's a very great piece of advice. Thanks so much. That's super interesting, because I think this Exactly the type of stuff, that if we look not just, and at services as, these fuzzy, strange, intangible things, they are made of humans, and I think this piece of advice is already like a principle that can help people who have a business or who are the future.

Working in a service, someone who is a barista, can still say before I'm going to start my job as a barista, let me write down, what's important for me for the 20 next years, and then when they are at work, they can try to remember the way I'm working. Does that fit with my values?

Some of these values might be linked to planetary stuff and maybe not that's then up to the person, but that's a very interesting exercise. And that, pushing employees maybe also to do that, writing your personal values and let's see. Should you fire yourself because you're not at a good place for your values?

Joël: Yeah. I think it's a huge chance for people if the personal values are more or less similar to the job you're doing or to the company that you're working for. It's like you will, or I noticed at least in my case, I'm so much more motivated to do like maybe some extra hours or this extra mile and to, Just get out of bed.

Like I a mattress

Daniele: designer who goes outta bed. That's really, yeah.

Joël: And they actually have a somehow a principle about this, like when you're in, on the edge of your bed in the morning and you don't want to work if it's like that every day, you need to change your job. Like I call it the edge of the mattress problem.

I'm not sure if I read it somewhere or if it is, if it's something I'm. Just, but it helps me and now I don't have this problem anymore because they are so similar, the values from my research, from the research group I'm working for and my own personal values.

Daniele: That's very good. Other very simple principle, it's if on the morning you're on the edge of the mattress Oh, fuck my life.

And you're doing that a few times per week. Yeah. Maybe there is something to change. And maybe don't do it

Joël: on Monday because Monday is always a bit rough, right? But on a Tuesday, if it's always like that on a Tuesday, then you should question yourself, your choice of the profession. Yeah.

Daniele: Yeah. And On the day after a breakup or a hangover might not be also the best time to do that.

Yeah, there are some exceptions, right? Yeah. Obviously. And now I'd like to, I'd to explore what you're doing with It's called EcoMajor startup, is that right? Yeah. So I'd like to know, what's the stuff that you learned, in these last two years, maybe, where you are like, oh shit, if only I knew that, that's really stuff that, that I could, Tell to a friend, who's starting a business a service, a product business, a startup to not only, do some great, interesting work, but also to do work that has a bit of a purpose.

Is there something that you learned in the last years that you feel like, Oh, this is a key that I now have and that I would have been super happy to have had before.

Asking the Right Questions

Joël: So yeah, I think there are a few learnings. Maybe one, one aspect is more in the conceptual phase. So I think it's quite helpful to have in the beginning of a new project or of a startup, goal of a startup.

It's, I see it as a positive. Big chance to have this mindset. To be really curious and naive a bit almost, because from this you can then do some research, you can observe stuff, processes and things that are important for the project. And then you can learn from it and question it because of this naive, uh, Einstellung.

Personal mindset. Yeah. Thank you. From this naive personal mindset, then you can really improve something in a new and innovative and sustainable way, because you Obviously, it has been done all the time in the past, this thing that you want to improve. And the people who are in this field they don't have this luck to question it in the perspective that a new person does it.

So from this re questioning and evaluating comes a big chance and therefore it can happen. Lead to a great improvement in terms of sustainability. And I think it was the same with with my mattress project. So it started during the master project, master thesis. And I had so many interviews and I visited several production sites and did a lot of hands on stuff and just try to learn as much as possible like a sponge to soak it up and then.

came the point where I was on a level of know how that I really felt comfortable. In improving the things I researched about and from this point on, it was way more about the ideation and prototyping process and not that much about the research process and from, yeah, and this obviously led to some valuable Outcomes and results that that helped me to then continue with the startup.

Daniele: So what are some of these, stupidly naive questions that you asked either yourself or to people, can you maybe share an example and how this question, Set the, the pace for your startup.

Joël: So I think in my case, it was a lot about materials. A mattress is often a big mix out of different materials.

And in the end, you don't know what's inside anymore. And it's really difficult to make a mattress ecologically sustainable. Or circular and therefore I worked together with some people from the mattress industry and they were just always asking why is this material there? What's doing that here?

And then I soon noticed Wait a moment, like a lot of these extra materials and cuts and designs they put into a mattress are actually just for aesthetical reasons. Because you mentioned it at the beginning, a mattress is actually not that interesting to people. It's a, they call it a low interest product.

And. To make a mattress more interesting, the industry tried to add more colors and extra design features and stuff like that. And so I noticed like a lot of the effort is actually done in the wrong area, so it would be way better to Improve other things like circularity and not care that much about the aesthetical design focus more on construction of the mattress and the materials and reduced amount of materials and yeah, so that was just one part where I had this learning of, ah, actually, yeah.

It doesn't make that much sense to me when I came into this field. For sure, marketing is important as well, but it's a question of how balanced is it. That's

Daniele: super interesting. This kind of question of guys, why do we do this? Just, I'm happy to do it, but just. Before I get started, why? It's a very, it's one of these, very fresh questions, my kid was in this why phase for a moment that it's been super inspiring, to get him like asking Daddy, why do we do that?

Why do we do that? Why do we do that? It's okay, it's an interesting question. And especially when it's done in a bit of a naive way. I think that adds, when it's not this, why, like consultants, the consultant why is like the worst thing, when, you come in a suit and say, why do you do that?

Joël: Yeah.

Daniele: Which is like this, you're stupid, but there is like a more, a why that comes with I don't understand because I'm new here. So please don't hurt me, but still, could I have an answer? Yeah. It's a very different why. And I think that's, That says, maybe that's not a question that I'd like to hear from you is how do you frame this why questions, without them being again, this.

consultant feeling, of, Oh, I'm an expert and I'm questioning all everything you do because I'm looking at it as a, researcher and I know best. And instead being this kind of naive, I'm interested, I'm passionate, I might ask stupid stuff, what, how do you frame it so that it has the right intention?

Joël: So are you Brought up some important points there. I think like one aspect is for sure also to make, or at least in my case, I did it often like that, that I wanted to also bring up. Share my vision with them. So I didn't just research, do research about the mattresses because I was interested in the mattress.

I wanted, in the end, it had the goal to lead the mattress industry into a more sustainable sustainable economy. And so I shared this vision with them. And simultaneously, I showed my real interest. So I was really curious to to see what they are doing. Like I was interested in their company and their processes.

And it was an honest interest. And I cannot tell you how I exactly formulate this question, but I can more tell you like my or share with you like that that I had this real I tried to show my real interest and I think with this attitude, the other, the people on the other end were also more interested to share what they have and like to have this real This honesty and not like this consultant selling thing vibe.

So an honest interest about the topic helps a lot.

Daniele: It feels as if you, instead of just asking the question, you're already revealing. Before I ask you a question, my bias is this what, where I try to go is there. So that's why I'm asking these questions. And then you'll say, okay I might like to help him with his vision.

Or you might just say, oh, this is something I don't want to help him with. So I don't even, I don't want to even answer the question, but it's interesting this notion that, we often ask questions, but we don't reveal the intensity behind the question. And that's when the, this kind of weird feeling can come like, why is he asking this question?

What does he try? What does he want to try to do with me? But in a way, you were very provocative by saying, My intent is to push this industry towards a more sustainable way, which is not an easy thing to, to hear, from from the industry, but at the same time, I feel people were receptive to that, even if it was a bit of a provocative thing.

Joël: Yeah. I think it's as you Summarized it quite well. So it's and not all of the people are interested in it then, right? Some people close up and then you notice anyway, it's maybe not the right person to collaborate with, or maybe not the right time because there's a lot of pressure from somewhere on this company.

And then you ask again a few months later but it's worth a shot for sure. And it has a bit, the limitation that if you. Or I noticed in some cases when I came in with the attitude that I wanted to ask a lot about the processes and maybe to have in mind like optimizations for sustainable reasons, then the people also tried to give me answers which are already going in this direction.

So that's like a, also difficult balance to navigate. Not let them know too much so they can share what they know and not adapt their answers already too much to the things I want to hear, but that's always the thing, like always a problem in interviews anyway.

Daniele: Yeah. Obviously it's being respectful by revealing the intent, but still not biasing them too much.

So that they give you the answer that you want to hear and not the answer That they have, which is obviously a different thing. You are asking this very good question, which is like, why do we do this? Are there other questions that you'd like to suggest? Again I'm thinking about, a dentist, a barista someone who, a pastor, these kinds of jobs where, they are not, into service design, they might not be into sustainability, but they might be curious about it, by about the intention.

What are, early, tiny things that they can question themselves to get started a bit in a more sustainable journey? Are there other questions than, why do this? Yeah.

Exploring Circular Economy

Joël: So a thing which is quite important from the perspective of a product designer is for sure the paradigm shift or change to, from a linear economy.

So take, make, dispose economy from a linear economy to a circular economy is to think about the whole supply chain and then try to loop it as often as possible. In this regard, it's quite important to ask, for example what happens when the consumer has its product where does he or she dispose it?

And that's it. Is this the right way to dispose it or should we take it back and recycle it on ourselves, like by ourselves, maybe the product has some value, still some value that we can use and recycle it in a closed loop or maybe take out some components and reuse them, repurpose them. And so that's a good question.

Already a quite simple question, which a lot of developers are not asking themselves that often, or not at all. So already to to have in mind, like, how could a circular approach to this product look and this is a big challenge for a lot of them.

Daniele: Yeah, absolutely. It's the ending question, knowing, okay, we're prepping.

We have I think someone that we both know who's Joe McLeod, I might give his last name in, in, in a very strange way, but Joe, who writes this book about endings and engineering which is asking the question, like, how do we end things? Which is a very specific question, which is a very good question, right?

Because often we spend so much energy. Thinking about how do we get people in, how do we get people to use it, and then not thinking so much about the end. I'm curious because you're taking obviously, a product perspective, where there is like a creation of something more physical,

Joël: yeah.

Daniele: How would we, do the same for, maybe, I don't know you're an accountant. How can we help an accountant to be more circular? Do you have maybe, can we play a little bit this experiment of trying to think how can we help an accountant to be more circular, more sustainable? Are there tips that you could imagine for him?

Joël: That's a good question. I haven't done projects in this field yet, I think, because I'm mostly focusing on fiber based materials, or at least physical materials. But if I look at an accountant, I think maybe like it's a bit all connected because an accountant, Has in some companies, they have direct touch points with end consumers and they play also a big part like they have a role within the circular economy as well.

If it's again, example of the mattresses, if it's about And the take back system of mattresses. So the end consumer must have somehow some way of they must need to gain something or have to have a really easy process to give back their old mattresses. And I think an accountant can.

Promote this by giving give it or providing them a really simple solution to, to sign up for this return of the old mattress or to get a discount or to make it as comfortable as possible for them. So that but I don't think with, or at least in my understanding, I don't see now a direct, like within only in this job.

I don't see. It's going there or it playing out there because circularity is anyway, always an approach with so many stakeholders. There are so many stakeholders along the value chain and it needs a lot of different professions and companies. And I think accountant is just one part part in this circular economy.

Yes. Do you have something in mind?

Daniele: I would summarize it because I see there is something interesting here to me, which is you're looking at the accountant as part of a system, and you're saying, sure, the accountant himself, outside of, recycling his sticky notes might not be like the big, the bigger Circular guy in the world, but he can with his process knowledge, help others do more circular stuff because he can make it easier from like a text perspective or a forms perspective, that you say, Ooh, it's just one click of a button, and I can get my money kick back if I give back my mattress.

There's okay, this is a big difference because usually accountant world, it's very detailed. It's very complex. It's very it's very rich and legal and compliant, but then see, okay, how can we still make it legal compliant, but something that is, that has a kind of a simplicity that pushes people to be motivated to, to do the circle of things.

So that's a, so it's a very interesting way of looking at the accountant.

Practical Advice for Starting Your Sustainability Journey

Daniele: As part of the system, and maybe he can help in that perspective.

Joël: I think it's also interesting to have from time to time a chat with them, because often we overlook positions like that. And I think, especially in the research phase, in this naive and curious phase, it's great to have a chat with them because they have a lot of know how and maybe they are not the creative people who are, Building things in a way like services or products, they still have their thoughts and they know maybe where they're, where, which screw could be more tightened or changed or so that's great to have a perspective on from them as well, included in the research phase.

Daniele: Yeah. And and it's we could propose this little piece of advice to say, Hey, go chat with the back office guys, and and ask them, okay, I have this vision. We're going to try to be instead of linear or circular, what can you do? What processes can you change?

So that's. Either within the company or with the people that we are working, It just gets easier and then they might say oh, We're making very hard for people to give stuff back because we have these long forms. Ah, okay Can you show me the form? And then we get in another conversation because we don't know all of these things usually.

Yeah And it's a very kind of going to the back office guy is usually a very good piece of advice

Joël: Maybe they even have a good coffee machine. So then you have some time to chat. And yeah,

Daniele: awesome. So is there, so we have like these I will do a little bit of a summary of the principles that we already covered which always, in this conversation we get like a few little pointers and then we will see how they, these grow then further in the writing and stuff.

But I would like to summarize them already now so that then we can go in the, oh shit, this makes me think about this. So for the summary the first one that we have is this idea of writing a secret shitty personal manifesto. So to reveal, to write down our own values and then to see how, And then that brings us to this lovely and very poetic edge of mattress principle, which kind of asks us to reflect back if there is this itch to stay in bed, maybe it's, that's something in our manifesto that we is not happening in real life.

And if it gets, if this itch comes back and back, maybe look back at the manifesto and maybe you see, oh that's why I don't want to go out of that. And then maybe you can change something. And then there are these two big questions. One, which is You say, hey, be stupidly naive about your field by asking why is this done like that, but not in a consultant way, where it's like I know better than you, but rather by saying, hey, this is my intent.

This is the stuff that I want to discover. This is where I want to bring change. And because of that, I'm super interested in, in, in what you're doing. And then the second thing is helping people to transition from this linear thing from, we create stuff and then we dispose stuff to, Hey, maybe before we dispose, there's some stuff that we can bring back and we can have some circularity and that asks us the question of what happens at the end of the service So knowing all of that in the little summary, is this, is there something that we missed in our little conversation where you feel, Oh, this is still something that I'd like to share that I think could be helpful for people?

Joël: Actually, this helped a lot to summarize it. Yeah.

Leveraging Data and Science for Sustainable Impact

Joël: I think one, one aspect, especially regarding the last point, I think is It's I often notice that media or social media or newspapers they are often focusing on some sustainability topics. So they are maybe focusing on, ah, there's so much microplastic from our garments in the rivers and seas or lakes, or they're like, we should reduce our packaging I think there are so many emotionally loaded topics, and we don't really set them we don't put them in relation to other impacts that we have on the environment.

And I think, That's, I'm saying that because it often helps to step one go one step back and observe, like, where do we really have the biggest impact on sustainability, and where do we have a leverage. And I think, Because you mentioned circularity and recycling, and a lot of people think about recycling as one major step for circularity.

But I think it's also helpful to think about other strategies, like for example, there's the reuse, or renting, or reducing, or not buying at all. So these are all different strategies. They are often called R strategies. And connected to that is also to really use science based data to evaluate like what's important and not focus on the topics which are important in the newspaper or in social, on social media.

And I think there are great tools or, and literature online available for free. For example, from perspective as a product designer, I think it's quite helpful to use. to use Wordly. This is a simple LCA life cycle assessment tool to check on which material could be a better fit for my project.

And I think it, it just helps to really evaluate the impact. And then from this, you can decide on where Do you put, like, where do you want to work on? Which topic do you want to work on and with which strategy within the circular economy? Just a small, but long note to that point.

Daniele: Yeah, that's exactly why I'm doing these summaries.

It's it's like in weddings, where when you say now, if someone has something to say, it's the right moment, or they will be married together. Then there is the one guy. I love her, that's the moment where he remembers. So at least in the movies. Yeah.

At least in the movies. I never saw that in real life. I'd love to see it.

Joël: Hopefully not on, on our own weddings though. Yeah.

Daniele: But who knows, could be fun. But more seriously, I think they're from what you're saying is to not get stuck in an emotionally loaded topic, to not get stuck in this kind of tunnel vision of, oh, carbon, we just have to think about carbon, or we just have to think about recycling, because that's the thing that we see on the news and just then to ask, Okay, what could be all the things that we can do?

And where does it really make a difference? Because once you do the math, that's also super interesting, because when you do the math, then suddenly you realize, but yes, we could do here a few things carbon related, but the impact is not so big. But, On another part, wow, there in the reuse part, for example, we could do much more.

And and yeah, I'm going to check out also these R strategies. I think that's something that I'm going to explore a little bit further. But before we come to our conclusion, is there another resource that you'd like to recommend for people? who are interested in this topic. So we had the book from Victor Papanek, where he said, okay, this changed your life.

So this is surely a good recommendation. But is there another recommendation? Can it be a tool? Can it be an article? Anything else that you say this would be interesting for people?

Recommended Resources about Sustainability

Joël: So something which helped me in the beginning of my research profession, I think was the Resources from Ellen MacArthur Foundation.

They have a lot about the circularity approach and they have like they have tools for it and they have some reports. So it's quite interesting to, to get into that and not sure how much. Yeah. There are actually also some service topics, I think, especially like in urban areas cause it's a lot about how do you.

include your community and stuff like that. I think this is a great institution for more know how. Awesome.

How you can help Joël

Daniele: And so you shared a lot today and as it's a common practice between lovely people, once you give something, sometime you receive back. So my question to you is what can people do for you?

Because now you shared a lot for people and so they received a lot from you. So if they want to do something for you, what could they do?

Joël: So I think as I said in the beginning, maybe I want to have a positive impact on the world with with my work. So I think it's great if the people already re question a bit them, that their work that they are doing and checking if they are.

Doing something that is important for them and the environment and the community. I think that's already a big achievement if we can reevaluate our own values. And if that's not enough, feel free to check out own mattresses. So that's something that is coming up. I think market launch is in August 2024.

Maybe you will hear from time to time something about Ecomate mattresses and feel free to, to get in contact with me and have a chat about sleeping mattresses and all these boring, but important topics. Awesome.

Daniele: Awesome. So if someone. Had like a moment where he said, Oh, I'm going to write my own secret manifesto.

Let him know. I think that's always lovely when you see the impact of the conversation. If something inspired you, let him know. And if you're interested about the mattresses, obviously, have a look at that. And I'm excited to to hear more about the lounge. Make sure to let me know when the launch is so that I can share that with you.

Closing words

Daniele: But for now, the one important thing for me to say is As the last thought is really thank you so much to you because you invested one hour of your precious time with me and and I've learned a lot as always with you and it's been a pleasure and I'm excited to, to have more conversation in the future with you, obviously.

Joël: Thank you. Thank you as well. Great effort. Bye bye. Bye bye. Cheers.

Getting started

How to overcome climate anxiety and paralysis?

Haley Anderson - Canada

A photo of Haley Anderson

Early principles uncovered

In this conversation, we uncovered 11 early drafts of Service Design Principles:

  1. Start local, or with your passion, where you have skills

  2. Don’t do it alone: you are an email away from community

  3. It’s a good creative constraint

  4. You are going to mess up, but the timeline is much longer

  5. Change the way you perceive your work: from small to huge

  6. It’s okay not to be 100% sustainable, but be consistent

  7. When in doubt of what to do: look for the co-benefits (what serves the humans better)

  8. The seven generations philosophy: who can you learn from the past, who can you protect from the future

  9. Start with what you have: don’t build it

  10. Think about the end: how will it be disposed of? How does the service end?

  11. Don’t be a dick: Saving the world shouldn't mean we can be dicks to other humans.

About the human

Haley Anderson is a Climate Change Project Coordinator at ICLEI Canada, which is part of a global network of more than 2,500 local and regional governments committed to sustainable urban development.

The full conversation

This transcript was automatically generated using Descript without any hand-made corrections. So it might be pretty creative at moments.

Introduction

How can an organisation come out from climate anxiety and paralysis?

That’s what we chatted about with Haley Anderson in an interview for my next book on how to create services that serve both humans and nature.

Haley is a Climate Change Project Coordinator at ICLEI (ikli) Canada which is part of a global network of more than 2,500 local and regional governments committed to sustainable urban development.

With Haley we uncovered 11 early Service Design Principles that can help come out of climate anxiety. Here are my five favorites:

  • Climate change create one of the best briefs for creative work

  • Use the severn generations philosophy: learn from seven generations before, and think about the impact your work has for the next seven generations

  • Be active for the planet but don’t be a dick to humans because of it.

  • Don’t thrive for 100% sustainable. Do it unperfect but consistent.

  • Don’t work alone: bring in the community, find the community or create the community.

Thanks so much to Haley for this lovely conversation.

Meet Haley

Daniele: Hey, Hayley, it's such a pleasure to meet you today. We have common friends who said that we need to be in touch together, to discover more about the worlds of sustainability and service design. And today I'm excited to, to speak with you.

Haley: Daniele.

Daniele: And so my first question for you is. When you go to a birthday party, how do you present yourself usually?

It's

Haley: different every time. Usually it's something to do with hobbies because I think that's more relatable and interesting. And a lot of those hobbies are often to do with crafting and repurposing materials which spans into the work that I do anyways. It's a lot to do with I'm a Person that's interested in creating and sustainability and curious about all things life.

Daniele: Awesome, so it seems like the pitch for a wonderful human on earth. That's it. I'm also interested in, in, in not showing, in not only knowing your party self, but also know a bit more about your business self. We always have kind of these different part parts in ourselves and I'd like to know, how could you maybe share a bit of your journey?

Of how to bring sustainability and these topics in businesses. How did it all start and where are you at with those ideas?

Haley: I guess it depends how far back I could go, but I did start thinking about sustainability and the environment as young as a child. I grew up in a family where we made crafts all the time, and that stayed true through my whole life, and everything was always, what can you do with what you have?

And then I continued on to design school where that ethos was pretty I was pretty well supported and present by a couple of the professors that I had and I continued to go down the path of design and communications and started realizing more and more that there's a potential to affect change through communication and design.

But I didn't have enough of the context politically or in terms of like how change is made on more of a policy scale. So I decided to go back to school for urban planning. So my career has been a blend of working with community and design and sustainability. and trying to find ways to bring people into making decisions about their spaces, their cities, their businesses and the things that they interact with.

Daniele: Awesome. So from what I'm able to see, and I think it's always, you're too humble to name drop. So I'm going to do it a bit for you. From what I'm reading, on stuff like LinkedIn you're pretty prolific, you're You're well involved. So if I'm just reading, I see Climate Change Project Coordinator for

ICLE

Daniele: Canada.

Could you tell me what that is? Because it's a lot of it's a fancy acronym, but I don't know what it is.

Haley: Yeah ICLEI is a non profit and it started in Germany actually over 20 years ago as a non profit working with sustainability for local government. I work with the Canadian chapter and the work that I do is largely to do with climate adaptation.

So we are on track for changes. We know that this is going to happen. Climate change is happening. How do we live our best lives with that in mind? Mitigation, on the other side, is how do we prevent those impacts from getting worse? It's important to have both of those things, but the team that I'm on, we focus on, okay, we know that these impacts are coming, how do we prevent them from making our lives worse?

In terms of the impacts that we're most affected by here in Canada, in Toronto, it's a lot to do with flooding. Wind, heat stress, and a lot of it comes down to how do we make people informed on the ways that they can prevent that that stress. If it's okay, there's a building that you can go in on a super hot day to get a bit of shade and make sure that you're not out in the heat and the blistering sun midday.

It can come down to communications. It can be a lot to do with working with municipalities to develop programs and services so that people can access rebates and different kinds of programs that help them enable that kind of prevention and risk risk prevention in their own lives.

Daniele: That's super interesting.

Avoid the climate tunnel vision

Daniele: I love that you're bringing this idea that it's just, it's not just prevention. It's not just mitigation. Obviously there is like the, both elements which are important and which we should take into account. That's that's an interesting part, which. I feel, from the little I know about sustainability, which is not a lot, I've heard this term, that we often get into kind of like a tunnel vision in one thing, either it's carbon stuff or it's mitigation or it's prevention, and we get stuck into one element.

Exactly. But that we need to do. To think about it in a more broader way.

Haley: Yeah I definitely think that is the case, but personally I'm maybe a little bit the opposite, because I find all of it so fascinating and interesting that I can't help but dance around all of them, and even as you're talking about carbon, I'm thinking about, okay, Carbon emissions are typically thought of in operational sense.

So the things that keep your building running, lights, heating, cooling. The other side of it that is less talked about is embodied carbon. And that's the pieces of your buildings, the infrastructure, all the things that make up the things around you. All of that has embodied carbon. So when we talk about materials being wasted, you're wasting carbon that has already been spent.

So it's this multi layered, multi pronged kind of thing that you have to think holistically, but you can't do everything. You have to be able to focus enough to make progress. And that is something that I honestly have struggled with for a while because I find everything so compelling and they're all problems to be solved.

Daniele: Absolutely. And so building on that you're telling me I'm interested in all these possibilities, all the things that we could do, because, the problem is so big, obviously there is so many things that we should do. And still there is like this need of focus.

How to focus: start local

Daniele: What has helped you in your journey to put a focus on something specific is this even something that makes sense? How are you thinking about that?

Haley: Yeah, I think working with the people that are in my network is one way to focus is that. Local talent, local knowledge, local context, that really is helpful and thinking about human need, what is the most impactful and what is the most needed for your community, that's What I've found to be more of a focus, but honestly, it comes down to sometimes I just really like design and furniture.

So sometimes I focus on, okay, what about making systems for better procurement for people that are in the crafts and want to create furniture? What if we intercept their normal supply lines or supply chains with a reuse solution? We've got tons of materials that are going to landfill every day.

Let's find a way to take those, put them into supply streams and add value to them again.

Daniele: Super interesting. So you know that I'm doing these kind of calls in, in the not so secret plan to then extract tiny bits of of provocations that we can then package to people. And there is an early idea that I see here, which is this notion of if you are in a situation where you're overwhelmed by all the possibilities, there are two paths that can work quite well.

One, which is. Start locally, start with the communities you have access to, be very pragmatic, don't think about the whole country, the whole continent, the whole world, but just start with local stuff that you can do to more or the other one, which is, which I love is it.

Sometimes make something which you're just passionate about, which just in French, we have this saying, which says, the heart has its ways that we can't explain. And so if you don't have a thing where the heart is strongly saying, Go in that direction, then local will be obviously a great way to start, but if the heart has its ways, then follow the heart.

That could be an interesting, approach to just take the overwhelming effect of, oh, climate change, climate emergency, crisis, ah, it's so big. And suddenly we can say, yeah, but local, that's already something interesting.

Sustainability is a creative constraint

Haley: Yeah, definitely. I think that it can be really overwhelming and there have been more and more conversations and groups of people coming together to try to combat that climate anxiety.

And it is something that I struggled with for a while. And now at this point, I've come full circle to I'm really energized by all of this because it's almost like a creative constraint. How do you work within this realm of, there's climate change, okay, what are we going to do about it? If we didn't have that problem, we'd just be floating around oh, we could do whatever we want.

I'm not creative enough to come up with an idea from thin air. So my creativity comes from that place of need.

Daniele: Ah, interesting. So from what, if I'm understanding you you're saying all these constraints that come from climate change, climate crisis are not we say it in a poetic way, are not problems.

That are the frame that we have for the artwork that we're going to do. And maybe the frame is now much smaller but doesn't mean that we can't use a microscope and, take a very small pen and do little dots to create a masterpiece. We still can do that. Yes, totally. Okay, and is there something else that in your journey where you said you had a bit of this climate anxiety that helped you to be at peace with it, but not in a peace where you say, Okay, fuck it.

I'm going to go on holidays and and we're all going to die. So no worries, but more in a peace, which is, this action piece where you do what you have to do and what you can do. Yeah. And you can be at peace with doing that.

Haley: Totally. Yeah. Yeah. It's really easy to think Oh, I'm not doing the most important thing.

And even the thing that I'm doing that is trying to make an improvement is not the most important one. And I need to get to the top of the pyramid, to the top of the problem. But I think that Over the years, I've focused on what I can do, what I have value bringing, and what my skills are, and also that community piece again.

It's like finding the community of people that are actually working on some of these problems and are doing it in a positive way, in a way that is It's community focused and brings brings value, but also camaraderie. I think that's really what gave me a lot of support and hope because I've been the only person in the room sometimes where I have that concern or that voice saying what about the environment?

What about sustainability? And it's always yeah, we'll get to that. But, once you start working with people that are also in that similar mindset. It makes you feel like you're not totally alone in it and it makes you feel like progress is possible and that it is real. I think a lot of it came down to yeah it's something that we'll get to, but it's not really our focus.

So now that I'm able to focus on it, I feel that momentum and that energy and feeling productive is a really good source of positivity as well.

Daniele: Super interesting. Ah, I'm repeating myself. I'm always saying super interesting because I'm learning so much. It's a topic that I don't know anything about. So thank you so much for bringing me in your world and There is another piece which I'm seeing here, which I find so interesting, which is this idea that we have some anxiety with all of that, it's overwhelming.

So there is a kind of a first element that you're bringing, which is say, start locally, start either with your passion or start with your skills, it's like limiting the scope by, okay, now it feels like something that I can manage. The other thing is switching. I always start the perspective by saying it's a creative constraint, like in any design process, we need, we love a good a good briefing, we always say clients can't make good briefings, and Planet is giving us a great briefing, which is very clear.

So it's a very good client. And then the third aspect, which is here, which I feel is like in all of this anxiety, feeling that

Don't do it alone

Daniele: if in a business, you're like the only force pushing for it to not do it alone, to find community, you from what I'm hearing, sometimes you can find a community within the business, but sometimes you can't.

And if that's okay, that's also okay. You can also find people who are in other businesses doing it alone, and you can be a team of alone people who can exchange about, Oh, okay, this is something that I did to make it move forward. And it worked well on my side. Oh, cool. Maybe I'm going to steal that.

Yeah, for sure. Do you have? Are there other elements that you can maybe share on this kind of don't do it alone aspect? Because from what I heard, you are now in a position where obviously it's like a more climate focused group. But how did you do it when it wasn't a super climate focused group?

Haley: Yeah. That's a good question. A lot of the work that I have done, even when I was independent doing freelance graphic design before I went back to school for planning, it was more who are the clients that are working in this space that I can find, and I did find a niche to work in projects that were either human centered, Ethical, sustainable, and I do recognize that those are more rare, and it's harder to find those clients, and sometimes it's a double edged sword where it's okay you want to work in these projects, but you also have to sustain yourself, and sometimes those projects don't have as big a budget, so I think it's also about balance And not trying to be 100 percent sustainable or 100 percent under that kind of umbrella all the time.

If you can make a roadmap for yourself and try to be consistent with it that's what I've done is I've just been incredibly consistent because I can't help it. It's what I care about. And that's how I ended up talking to you is I've been consistent and I've made these relationships and people think of me when they think of sustainability and design.

So I think that if the community side of things isn't happening. Where you currently are, you can try to create it, and that's something that I learned a little bit later on, too, is if something doesn't exist, it means that you should create it, or seek it out, because it might exist, but it might not be exactly where you are.

Take inspiration from somewhere else. For example, I am going to Copenhagen in a couple of weeks, and there's a business there that I'm super inspired by, and I'm meeting up with them to talk about how we might do something like that here in Toronto. And it was really just a simple email, but in previous Times in my life, I would be like, oh, why wouldn't, why would they answer me?

Who am I? They don't know who I am. So it's really having that kind of confidence and curiosity and just putting it out there into the world and trying to connect with people because I think that it's easy at least for myself to say oh, I don't really have any reason for anybody to want to talk to me it's just me over here in Canada, they're doing their own thing, they've got their whole business, they're doing great, but I think people are generally very open and welcome to having conversations about things they're mutually interested in, and people can be more generous than you assume.

So I think that confidence, but also trust that other people are willing to share and have that generosity.

Daniele: It's It's lovely to hear your story, that in some ways, community is one email away, it's just an email. It's it seems like for maybe people like me who are introverts can be feel, it can feel like, oh, wow, this.

Who wants to talk to me? And obviously it feels a bit scary and stuff and, it's just an email, and if people don't respond, it's okay. It was just an email. It didn't cost you much. And and it's quite easy to write. And if you can't write it you can find a template.

ChatGPT will help you. Yeah, even that, but that's easy. But I. I think there is a very interesting idea here, which is additional to this, don't do it alone aspect, which is,

Don't do it perfectly but consistently

Daniele: it's okay to not be 100 percent perfect, but consistent, in French we sometimes have this this joke that we make in in soccer training and this kind of stuff where we say Bad, but consistently bad, it's like, it's not a great group, but and we're not good, but at least we're consistent in how bad we are, we're reliable.

And and I think there is something interesting here which is. At least start small but keep doing it instead of having these peaks of, Oh, we're going to do it. Perfect. And then we're going to forget about it. And then we're going to do even worse and instead just say, Hey, let's make it 10 percent better for the next five years and then maybe 20%.

better and slowly we'll get to a place where it's pretty good.

Haley: Yeah and I do think that there's an element of pressure when you're working in environment where you're like I only have one shot I can't mess it up because the people that are listening are going to critique this or if something is intended to be sustainable but You haven't done your kind of due diligence and there isn't an un, there is some kind of an unintended consequence that can diminish the kind of like investment in, or the belief in doing work that is sustainable versus the other kind of pressures of profit and I don't know the kind of wicked problems of our time.

Which one do you, Okay. Pick. And it's not about picking. It's about, okay, you, you've tried and that's great. Keep trying. You are going to learn, but it's not as easy to learn and fail as it is with, say, like a tech platform where you're like trying to fail fast. There's a bigger scale to it because you're working with systems and people and environments.

And. When you do mess up, it's a little bit more visible, and it's a little bit more detrimental. But it also is we're in such a long timeline that the impacts that you see are going to be probably a decade away. So you have to find those little moments where you're getting those moments of feedback and communicating progress and saying this kind of action might not actually be present in like the public eye for another 10 years.

You won't see the effects of it. So even if you have messed up, there's more chances to redirect,

Daniele: to recover from it. Ah, it's interesting. How do you work with that? Because, maybe you know that show the, I think it's called The Good Life where in short they present a dilemma, which is, you, it's impossible to make the right choice because the right choice, it would be a calculation, which is It's impossible to do and and it shows oh, we are, that's either you do something or either you get stuck in, okay if it's all fucked up and we can't even know what is good, then how, what do we do?

And it's a question that I feel sometimes businesses have, also small businesses where they say, yeah, I'd love to do something. But whenever I say. I'm going to do this, people point me and say, yeah, but no, that's a very bad idea because there are these unintended consequences.

And so how can we help people when they are in this situation where it's hard to predict, even if something is really good, is there a kind of mental models or things that help for that?

Haley: That's a really good question. But yeah the paralysis effect is really it's definitely a real thing.

Let me just think on that, because I think it really depends on the size of business and the type of business and if you are, Working on kind of more of a sales or interaction based business, it doesn't always have as big of a impact because you're like, oh we've done these things and it's incremental and you can see the progress over time, maybe because it's accumulated, but when it's like a larger kind of infrastructure piece, it does get set on a path.

Maybe. And it's harder to reroute that path because it's in a, it's in a plan. It's in a a policy. Like it's a lot bigger, but yeah I don't know. I have to think about that a bit more. Can you reframe the question maybe?

Daniele: Yeah, obviously.

When in doubt start with the co-benefits

Daniele: So in your experience, so in the work that you've done what's something that you did to help people realize.

That's it. There is something that they can do even if they feel all options seem like have issues, it's like choosing between pest and cholera. So why would I choose, is there a way to get out of that view? Maybe I'm thinking out loud. Is it like, Oh, it's not about diseases, and you just have to.

Make 10 steps back and then you realize that there is something else. Is it to ask another question? What's

Haley: Yeah, okay. I think I have some Does it help? Yeah, for sure. I think there's co benefits with a lot of these things that you have to find what the value is, either the kind of internal business value, what is the personality of the business, what are the people in that business or the customer what are they interested in and whether it's some kind of a, an aligned value, okay, you want to save money, okay, you want to have a protected future for your family you need housing, all of these different things can be co benefits.

So for example, if you're trying to encourage a kind of larger business to maybe install A food garden, or something like that your employees can use it, they'll be interested to go out on their lunch break and come back to work more energized, it's a good kind of internal HR service, but it's also good Marketing, if you communicate about what's happening there maybe you can share the food in community that you're growing, connect with people and use it as an engagement opportunity, invite people in how do you have conversations around these things with your customers?

How do you have conversations around these things with your employees to try to see Okay, this is what you're actually interested in for your personal life or for your work life. These kinds of sustainable outcomes or tweaks to your business and service align with those actually.

Daniele: Yeah. So again, when we are in this analysis paralysis then we can bring in this co benefits and say, okay, let's have all the solutions.

And which one is in more interesting for us also saying, Hey, there are, it might be all at least quite good on the sustainability aspect. And this one is either more fun or is just aligns better with our brand values or is gives us an opportunity to for communication and all the other ones we can't communicate about it.

Yeah, it could be like a very simple way to say, when stuck, just add a bit of ego into it, and that's okay. Don't start with it, but if you're stuck, then ego can help a little bit, or business ego can help a little bit. Yeah, and

Haley: I guess again, it's that human centered design focus at the end of the day, what are we doing any of this for?

It's because we want human life to be successful and well. We live on this earth and the earth will be fine without us. It will do its thing. We are just here. So as humans, it is in our interest to do the things that are good for us. And I think that a lot of that good can come from sustainable practices.

We are seeing these things in air quality. When we do consume fossil fuels and things like that, it does have negative impacts on human health. And the same thing when we extract materials and throw them away, it has an impact on our livelihoods. And we're in theory running out of space It's definitely happening more in Ontario right now, our landfills are filling up, and we're going to have to negotiate between how we use our land, and it's not as simple as that, but if you compare land uses, it's like we're trying to get more housing over here, we need to develop more housing so that people have places to live.

It's not a direct correlation to say that building a landfill is a bad choice, but if you just put these things side by side, even in like very basic terms, it's why are we dedicating land to these things? So it's not as simple as option A and option B, but if you're presented with these things it's almost like a cognitive dissonance.

Would you like to have housing? Yes. Would you like to have a landfill? No. These things are leading to us needing to have more landfills.

Daniele: I already have six elements mapped from our conversation. And and yesterday I sent you a little reminder by saying, Hey, if we can find three I'd be already super happy. Are there other elements than what we discussed here that while you were under the shower this morning, you were like, Oh, an idea comes up, usually for me, it's under the shower that this comes, that this stuff comes up.

Is there a kind of a under the shower idea that we didn't talk about yet?

Haley: I did actually make a note this morning, so I'm looking at my phone because I wrote it down.

Start with what you already have

Haley: But I think we did talk about creative constraints and I think that kind of the start with what you have. piece, it is like on a material level, but also on like a human level.

Start with the people and the relationships that you have, and I think that being efficient as sustainable as well, because if you are efficient in, okay, maybe I don't need to create this internally. It exists already. I just need a partner. It's really efficient. and Sustainable to be collaborative.

Daniele: Okay, so it's a very interesting reframing to, to say collaboration is a great path towards sustainability.

Think about the end

Haley: Yeah. And then I, from that carbon life cycle world is when you start something, think about the end. If you are, you can't obviously predict the future, but if you're working with materials, when you're designing something, how will it be disposed of or reused at the end of life?

If you're thinking about the life cycle of a service or that customer experience, how does it come back to the start to inform? how it was developed, and then reiterate.

Daniele: And there's a good resource, I'm gonna mess his name up, but you will correct me, I think, as soon as I will say his name. Joe McLeod, who wrote the book Ends?

Haley: I actually don't think I know that one.

Daniele: Okay, good, it says, it's he's the expert of endings. So he has even a course called Engineering, which is like Engineers of the Ends. So that's a resource for people interested in that might be quite interesting. He made, created, do two books about it.

I don't know why I haven't heard of it. Okay, good. So happy that's a, to, to have shared that one with you. Is there to, so that's a good transition.

Recommended: Thinking in Systems

Daniele: Are there resources? Like Joe that's you can share where you say, Oh, this for people starting in that journey, businesses who have questions about that can be a framework can be a book, can be a name obviously there is your name which which will add to the list, but but outside of your name, are there?

There are people that you think are worth mentioning and that people should watch or books or anything else.

Haley: I think, so I've done some reading on Donella Meadows work Thinking in Systems and a lot of that is just naturally sustainability because systems and ecosystems, whether you're looking at the larger system of the earth and nature or an ecosystem of a relationship or business.

It has a lot of really interesting practical tools, but also philosophies around sustainability.

Recommended: 7 generations philosophy

Haley: But there's also it ties to a lot of indigenous knowledge as well, where like these theories and philosophies have existed for centuries and generations and I would encourage people to look into the seven generations philosophy and it's basically thinking about the generations that came before you and the generations that will come ahead of you, and you live within the center of those.

So who can you learn from three generations before you? Who can you So you're not thinking about your life and being completely shut off to the kind of ecosystem of your own world. It's thinking about nature and people connected and how those work in tandem. So I'm probably not doing it justice, but there's a lot

Daniele: of

Haley: Thank you.

There's a lot of literature out there around seven generations and I would encourage people to look into Indigenous knowledge and to look to elders for that kind of information.

Changing the scale: from small to huge

Daniele: This, resonates so, so big in me because often in, in service design, which is more my practice we often say, think about what happened, what's happening before and after, we always say, a service doesn't exist.

Service Design is by itself, if you take a flight, usually there is a train ride before the train ride, there is people packing up their stuff, there is a checklist, there is all of that stuff. And once you took the flight, there is a lot of stuff that goes after, and thinking about the before and the after is a very important practice in service design and having that.

Which is like this, there's a super meta view of, okay, seven generations back, what can I learn from them? And then seven generations in front, what can I do for them so that they still are here and that they can thrive and have an interesting life? Changes really the perspective of what you're doing.

Yeah.

Haley: And it might not even really end up that way, but the fact that you've thought about it, it is, it's community again. I think that's really the core of it. You're thinking in a holistic and communal sense instead of an individualistic sense.

Daniele: Yeah. And in some way

It's,

Daniele: It brings back the this is something that I heard from you a few times, which is, this change of of measurement, it's from now to seven generations it's from you to community, the measurement is much bigger.

The scale is much bigger than what we used to work with, in, in businesses where we're like, okay, what are we going to serve? 10 people because we're a cafe or 100 people or a million. And then suddenly it's Oh, no, but we're thinking about a lifetime. We're not thinking about one customer interaction.

So I think there is like a, this idea of thinking in a bigger scale, which then suddenly makes your. So your ideas feel much smaller and where you can say, at the end, it might be not so interesting to do that because the added value for the next generation of us doing that. So maybe let's not do that, and so that's also an interesting kind of like reframing.

Keeping it down to earth: a 7th thinking hat

Haley: Yeah, I think it's hard to, it's hard to always have that view and it's important to have it maybe in one person on a team or as a undercurrent but there's always reality and like businesses run in quarters and cycles and we do have to have that scale too. But when you have a step back every now and then, it does give you that perspective to make decisions.

Is this really something that we need to lose sleep about? Is this the best use of our money? Is this the best use of our talent?

Daniele: It's, and this advice that you're bringing, which is, this fixed thinking hats of sustainability, having like a seventh thinking hat, which would be like this super long term thinking hat having saying we don't need all to be.

Thinking about that, but we need someone on the team who is like the nudger and say, yes, by the way if we think about that in a big, in a bit of a bigger scale, doesn't matter what we're doing here. Or if we're doing that and at the biggest scale, wow, that's going to be really great.

This little thing here. It's oh, wow. So maybe let's put more energy on that tiny thing, which we. Didn't think would be very interesting, but if we look at the generations, it has a much bigger impact. So that's a super interesting I'm taking a lot of notes. So thank you so much for that.

I'm just finishing that note so that I don't forget about it.

Synthesis

So

Daniele: what I'd love to do if that's okay for you is to slowly come to a bit of a synthesis. So that's the base of a summary and maybe usually that's we're going to have, this classical moment that happens in workshops or in weddings, which is, when you say, and now we're going to marry these people, if there is someone who still has something to say, now is the right time, then there is a guy, I love her so that might happen.

But, so I'm going to do like the summary and then I'm sure you're going to have you're going to have a. I love her moment with another thought to add on it. So like the big topic that I feel we've discussed today is how to fight climate anxiety and paralysis, that's I learned a lot from you on, on, on these elements.

And there are a few points I've written out I think 10. So I'm just going to. Go through them, there are rough notes, so maybe they will be merging in less or maybe they will come out more, but for now there are 10. And the first one is, if you're overwhelmed, start local, start with your passion, start with your skills.

Feels already much more doable. The other thing is don't do it alone because if you're with other people, it builds the motivation to do it. If you're doing it alone then it doesn't work and how to not do it alone, either search community or create community. And even when it's about creating community, you can just steal it from somewhere and say, Oh, this is really cool how they do it in that other place and I'm going to do the same here.

And community is only one email away, as we learned from your story. And the other reframing that you're doing is it's a good creative constraint, all of this climate issues, policies, regulations, and things, we can think about them as Nature giving us the best brief, and nature is a good client, it's giving us a clear brief, and as people designing things we should be happy about having a good brief.

And then, there is this notion of sure you're gonna mess up and that's part of it but still the consequences are decades away, so you can still a bit adjust. And even in messing up, there is a bit more. of of possibilities than what we are used to in the tech world and stuff, where it's like you fail, you're closed.

Here we can still adjust which again, brings a bit of anxiety out because it's a longer scale, which links really well with this idea of of timeline, change of perspective, change of measurement which we just discussed before, where we say. We need to change our measurements from one person to community, from one interaction to a journey, from a journey to a lifetime this kind of stuff.

And then not having the pressure by just saying, we need a six the seven thinking hat, which might be that one, but we don't need to have it all. Another thing that you brought is this element of saying. Not 100 percent sustainable, bad, but consistent at least 20%, 30%, and then slowly adding up to it but don't try to do perfect but instead try to do consistent.

When in doubt, look for co benefits, look for what serves the humans. The 7th generation principle, I think that's a very strong one with a lot of reading to do there. Start with what you have and think about the end. And we have a few references here, Thinking and Systems, a great book we have the engineering stuff from Joe and we have the Seven Generations philosophy which is also a super interesting resource.

So what's your, I love her moment? What did you, what did we miss in this conversation that you say, Oh, I have to put it there.

Haley: You're great at summarizing. That's, I'm, I love the way that you put a lot of those pieces and I think I might. Use them even though I might have said them. I think the way that you say it is more eloquent so I Yeah, I think that covers it very well.

Don't be a dick

Haley: Maybe the only thing That I would add is that Reinforcement of action is good, but as long as it's positive and community focused, I think it's not just about go for it, take action, go out there and act act, but it's taking a positive action forward. Is the missing piece there,

Daniele: even though it's very much through everything.

And how do you define positive? Because community, I see how I can do that. If you tell me action is good, but always include two aspects, community and for good, how would you, community, I know it's, I'm going to have to chat with a few people and bring them in and hear and hear like them saying to me.

Sounds like a good plan, but it's not a good plan because this will happen and we hate it. Say, okay, interesting. Now I've learned. How do you define good? I guess it's a difficult question.

Haley: Yeah. Yeah. And good is maybe too broad in general of a word for it. But I think Additive rather than defensive or reactive, I think, is what I'm getting at, is if you're acting in order to be in offense or oppose somebody for the fact of sustainability, I think there's a lot of Kind of energy that can be caught up in, in the fight and in the combating those that are not paying attention.

I think it's acting in a human and relational and positive way so that you are not acting for the sake of environment over being a good human.

Daniele: So I'm going to formulate it in my. Street poet way, which is Don't be a dick. Yeah. Serve the planet is great, but that doesn't mean that you can go out and say, you put some trash not in the bed, you piss off, blah, blah, blah, blah, blah.

, don't be a dick. You can just go and say, Hey mate there's a trash. I can help you. Definitely have a good day instead of, okay. Okay.

Haley: Yeah, you've got it. This is, we're a good team. You're, we're good collaborating.

Daniele: Yeah but that's a a very strong thing. At least

maybe

Daniele: It's a bit of a, so I'm going to go in, in in a territory which might be a bit political and and scary, but I feel there is a bit of a difference.

So I'm from Switzerland, we're working in Switzerland, and Switzerland is a bit more conservative. And I've been working in London also, which is much more progressive. And it was fun for me as someone who comes from a more conservative culture. The amount of dickness, if I can call it like that, where, you know, people coming at me, like saying, Oh, this is bad.

This is, you shouldn't do that. No. It's you could just say it in a way that is nice. I'm not from here, so tell me how we do things here and I'm going to do it as you want, because I'm a guest here. So as a host, you have to introduce me like we do in Switzerland.

We tell people here, we take shoes off before entering, and we don't tell the guy once he's, yeah, it's, you don't tell the guy once he's in the kitchen, you're a dick. You take a bit of, and

Haley: that's interesting. It's maybe the carrot and stick principle of behavior change, it's just okay, we've got a lot of sticks already, maybe we just need a few more carrots.

Daniele: And is this something that you see is a real struggle? That you see like this don't be a dick thing is something that you see as quite big?

Haley: I think it's getting better. I think that the conversation around that kind of like positive framing. Of things, versus doom and gloom that's the big scale of it, but on the interpersonal scale of it, it's just don't be a dick.

Just because you know this, and the other person doesn't know this, doesn't mean you should yell at them about it. They're on their own journey, let them get there, and help them, don't scold them for not being there already.

Daniele: If you have one more minute, do you have one more minute?

Haley: Yeah it's lunchtime now,

Daniele: then I leave you for lunch because it's an important thing, obviously.

Being a dick doesn't change other people

Daniele: It's super interesting because from a psychology perspective, the thing that I've been learning in the last year is it's called from motivational interviewing, which is a thing which is made maybe you know about

it?

Daniele: Okay, good. So for those who don't know about it, who are listening to us this idea of how do you motivate people for change? And the one thing that they say in a very short way and a bit simplified is advice doesn't work. Telling people what they should do just doesn't work because usually what it makes is that people then give you back all the reasons why they don't like your advice.

Yeah. And being a dick does exactly that, which is if you yell at a person, the only thing that they want to do is explain to you why it was in fact their true right to not put the trash in that bin and why you are the sucker.

Haley: You're solidified in that belief and go the opposite direction.

Daniele: Which is a very interesting thing to, to just feel that The push that we have to correct people to be right, to advise, to give advice usually just does backfire and which is hard, which is a very hard thing because we have to work in other ways, Which are more supportive reflective.

It takes more

Haley: energy to inspire than to scold.

Daniele: Hey, thank you so much for that last I love her moment. Yeah. It was really cool. Thank you so much for that.

Meet the creator

I'm Daniele an Innovation Coach and Service Designer from Switzerland.

I worked with clients from all over the world to help them find innovative solutions to their problem. I've been blessed to be able to learn a lot. 
Today I want to share  these learnings back with the community. That's why I've built the Swiss Innovation Academy.